BENERU
Basics and getting startedPublished Updated

Shouldn't people be given the freedom not to pay into the pension and to invest on their own?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. Starting from the shortfall in pensions — that's a good eye. It's the question of someone who actually looks at the numbers. But it's still too soft. That ¥20 million is a number that came out on the premise of receiving a pension.

Let me give the answer to the question straight. If the freedom not to pay were allowed, the shortfall wouldn't stop at ¥20 million. So "it's not enough, so I'll opt out" has the logic backward.

Here's the reason. The Financial System Council's report of June 2019 (Reiwa 1) does a simple calculation: for a couple with no job, husband 65 or older and wife 60 or older, subtracting expenses from income including pensions gives an average monthly deficit of about ¥50,000, and if that continues for 20 to 30 years, it comes to about ¥13 million to ¥20 million. It's a deficit on the premise that pension money comes in. Erase the pension line and the monthly deficit isn't ¥50,000, it's your entire living expenses. You know?

One more thing — what's inside the money you pay. For employees' pension insurance for company workers, the premium rate of 18.3% is split half and half between the company and the person. Opting out also means giving up the half the company pays. Nobody has decided whether that would be designed to come back to you added to your salary. And the basic pension covers 1/2 of its benefits with national treasury funds, in other words taxes. Even if you opt out, you keep paying taxes, so you'd end up supporting other people's pensions with your taxes while not receiving your own. Don't get it? The design here is a bit tricky, but which way the gain and loss point is clear.

Well, the argument has its merits too. If you saved ¥180,000 a year at 3% a year for 40 years, it would come to about ¥13.6 million. Looking at the number alone, it's big. That's right, it's right — but that number assumes you never touch it for 40 years, never become unable to work along the way, never die first and leave family behind, and can guess how long you'll live and use it up exactly. The value of a pension isn't its average yield; it shows up when plans go wrong. If you try to prepare for the cases where they go wrong on your own, the amount you have to save seriously shoots up. Does that answer it?

I said "the logic is backward" earlier, but I'm not saying "the pension alone is enough" either. The shortfall really is a shortfall. But that's not a reason to opt out; it's a question of what to add on top, and how much.

One way to check. Put your own numbers into that ¥20 million calculation and set the pension line to zero. If you see how much the deficit swells, you get the price of the freedom to opt out. Am I wrong?

You know yuzu? Some people only want the juice and throw away the peel. But the fragrance is in the peel. Squeeze only the inside and throw away the outside, and all that's left is plain sour water.

(Updated 2026.10.14)
Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. The public pension is not a system for saving up living expenses for old age; it is social insurance that prepares for old age, disability and death. Enrollment in the National Pension is mandatory for people aged 20 or older and under 60, and the choice not to pay premiums is not allowed. If paying premiums is difficult, there are systems for exemption and payment deferral. Under the current system, the part the pension alone does not cover is topped up through systems with tax benefits and the like.

Public pension benefits

BenefitDetails
Old-age pensionIn principle received from age 65, for life
Disability pensionReceived if a certain level of disability remains due to illness or injury
Survivors' pensionReceived by the surviving family if an enrollee or similar dies

Disability and survivors' pensions may not be received if the premium payment requirements are not met.

Revision of pension amounts

Pension amounts are revised every fiscal year according to changes in prices and wages. However, in fiscal years when adjustment by the macroeconomic slide is applied, the revision rate is held below the growth in prices and wages.

Main ways to top up the pension

MethodDetails
iDeCo (individual-type defined contribution pension)Contributions are fully deductible from income. In principle cannot be withdrawn until age 60
NISAInvestment gains are tax-free. Can be withdrawn at any time
Assets such as real estateTopped up with rental income and the like. Carries the risks of borrowing and vacancies

Order of checks

  1. Check your own expected pension amount through Nenkin Net or similar.
  2. Compare it with your expected living expenses in old age and calculate the shortfall.
  3. If paying premiums is difficult, check the exemption and payment deferral systems.
  4. Compare the ways of filling the shortfall by when the money can be withdrawn and how it is taxed.

From here on, this is my opinion

I think it is more rational to design what goes on top with the pension as the premise than to seek the freedom not to pay into the pension and invest on your own. It is difficult to prepare a substitute for protection against disability and long life through personal investment alone.

Sources (in Japanese)

Read a little deeper