BENERU
Market and macroPublished

Is a property in an area with planned redevelopment or a new station a good buy?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. You know, AI reads sentences by cutting them into words. For this question that's "redevelopment," "new station," "planned," "property," "buy." And when you cut it up, the lightest-looking word, "planned," is seriously the heaviest. Every other word hangs off that one.

The general points, everyone already knows. Plans get delayed, change, and sometimes disappear. If it's a widely known story, the expectation is already in the price. Up to here, that's right. Right, and anyone can say it.

So here's the thing. Why do people buy anyway, even when they know all that? If you don't dig into this, the next time you hear the same story, you'll nod along again.

One: plans often have no date attached. "In a few years." "In the future." The day it's confirmed the plan missed never comes, so even if it misses, you never have to admit the loss. You can keep saying "it's just still in progress." A promise with no deadline can't be broken, even if it's never kept. Don't you think?

Two: it hides how weak today's numbers are. I mean, I'm not saying that's true every time. But if a property's numbers work at today's rent and today's price, the seller doesn't need to bring up the future at all, right? The more the redevelopment story is pushed to the front, the more likely it is that today's yield is falling short. That's a state where the story is standing in for the numbers.

Three: at the exit, you need someone who believes the same story. Making money on a price rise means there's a next person who'll buy it from you for more. Will that person also pay for "planned," or only for "finished"? If you sell while it's still planned, the next person carries the same uncertainty, so the price has a hard time going up. If you sell after it's finished, you need the stamina to hold on until it's finished. Does that answer it?

"Didn't you just say the expectation is already in the price?" Yes. So what you check isn't the story, it's the stage. Is that redevelopment or new station just being talked about as a concept, has it been decided as a city plan, or has it gone as far as approval for the construction? You can look up which stage it's at in the city plan maps and public notices of the city, ward, town or village. The further along the stage, the more concrete the dates get, and the more of it is already priced in ahead of time. If there's a high price tag at the concept stage, you're paying for a full-of-holes plan. Okay?

You know apples — even if someone tells you "it'll turn red next month," you don't pay red-apple prices for a green one. Wait until you see the color, then decide the price. Ciao.

Sources (in Japanese)

Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! Redevelopment and a new station. Those words get you excited, right? I get it — I got excited too, and bought right on the spot.

When I was looking for the condominium unit I own now, the agent at the real estate company showed me a studio unit 12 minutes' walk from the station, 18 years old. The price was ¥19.8 million. The agent pointed at the map and said, "There's a plan for a new station up ahead. Once it opens, the nearest station will be a 3-minute walk, and the rent will go up by about ¥10,000. We expect the price to rise by 20% too."

I nodded right there: "Whoa!" If ¥80,000 rent becomes ¥90,000, the gross yield goes up from 4.8% to about 5.5%. I did that much of the calculation myself. But I never once asked what "¥10,000" and "20%" were based on. I was too busy nodding!

About 1 year after buying, I looked up the transaction prices of other units in the same building on the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's Real Estate Information Library. It turned out that a little before I bought, units of about the same size had changed hands for around ¥18 million. So I had paid about ¥1.8 million extra for the new-station story. Divided by ¥80,000 rent, that's a little over 22 months. I had prepaid nearly 2 years' worth of rent to a station that doesn't exist yet.

As for the new station, when I checked the city's website, the opening date had become "undecided." Apparently talks with the local community are taking time. The plan hasn't disappeared, but nobody knows when it will happen. The rent is still ¥80,000. The units around mine are being advertised at almost the same rent too.

Looking back, the agent said "we expect." Not "it's decided." The words were chosen carefully, but my ears converted them into "it will go up" all on their own.

The numbers are somehow working. But if I had calculated at ¥80,000 from the start, I think I would at least have negotiated the price.

Three things I'd like to tell myself back then.

  • For any number you're told will "go up," ask once: "Compared with what?"
  • Look at the transaction prices of similar units nearby, and check how much extra is built in
  • Decide on whether it works at today's rent, even with no new station

When I told this story at my parents' place, it was a huge hit. Now, every time my dad calls, his first words are "Is the new station open yet?" Even my mom laughs and says, "When the station opens, we'll come celebrate." I wonder when that celebration will be!

Sources (in Japanese)

Read a little deeper