BENERU
Market and macroPublished Updated

If I invest in real estate while the population is shrinking, where should I choose?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. "Is real estate really OK when people are decreasing?" I get the feeling. I get it, but that worry probably has one formula wrong.

What decides rental demand isn't "population" — it's the unit that rents a room, in other words the number of households. As a formula, households = population ÷ people per household. Even if the population falls, if the number you divide by falls faster, households increase. In fact, in the 2020 (Reiwa 2) Census, over the 5 years from 2015 the population fell by 949,000 people, yet ordinary households increased by 2,373,000. People per household shrank to 2.21. In a country where people are decreasing, by the room-counting measure the customers were increasing. Am I wrong?

Well, saying "so it's all safe" here is too early as well. The number you divide by can't keep getting smaller forever. There's no household smaller than someone living alone, so the shrinking hits bottom someday. When it does, population decline turns straight into household decline. So both "population decline means demand decline" and "household growth means demand growth" only look at one side of the formula.

Now here's the real point. What matters for investing isn't the national total — it's the formula around your own property. How easily vacancies appear is decided, roughly, by subtracting the number of rooms put up for rent from the number of households looking for a room in that area. In the same Census, only 8 prefectures, including Tokyo, Kanagawa and Saitama, saw their population increase over the 5 years, and 29.3% of the total population is concentrated in the Tokyo area. Even if the total is falling, the answer to the subtraction is completely different by area. Keeping up?

So where's the place to aim for? It's right — that question is right — but the moment you answer with a place name, the formula disappears. Instead of place names, I'd line up three numbers. How the number of households in that municipality moved over 5 years. How many new rental homes are being built there. How many rooms are being advertised for rent at each distance from the station. You can track the first in the Census and the second in the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's housing construction statistics, and the third — honestly, anyone can get a rough view by counting on listing sites. A place where households are increasing and new rental homes haven't caught up is strong on paper. Conversely, a place where households are increasing but even more is being built gets vacancies despite its popularity. Makes sense, right?

"You just said households, not population," you say? Yes, but look at what's inside the households too. If what's increasing is people living alone, what's wanted is studio units or 1LDKs, and that's a different formula from spacious family rooms.

Population decline is neither a reason to quit real estate nor a reason to start. It's a reason to add one more item to the formula.

You know how spinach is said to get sweeter in winter when it's hit by frost? It's not the cold itself — the flavor is decided by what kind of field it is and how it reacts to that cold. Population decline is the same: just look at the numbers for what kind of town it is and how it reacts to the chill. See you.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.14)
Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Kakakaka. Is it wise to buy real estate in a country where people are decreasing? The scarier the story, the harder people think.

Let me tell an old story. Mind you, it's not something I made up. It's a story left in the statistics. In the Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications' population estimates, Japan's total population has been falling continuously since 2011, and as of October 1, 2023 it was 124,352,000, the 13th consecutive year of decline. In that one year, the only prefecture whose population increased was Tokyo. While the country as a whole shrinks, people gather in one place.

The state saw this and took action. On February 12, 2014 (Heisei 26), the Cabinet approved a bill to amend the Act on Special Measures concerning Urban Reconstruction and other laws. It was an amendment allowing municipalities to draw up location normalization plans. It's a system of drawing lines on a map: residential inducement areas to gather homes, and urban function inducement areas to gather hospitals and shops. Building housing of a certain size or larger outside a residential inducement area requires notifying the municipality. The towns themselves began writing on the map, "we want you to live here" and "we won't expand this anymore."

I was born in Manchuria. The town of my childhood had roads stretching out from the station, and the farther from the station you went, the sparser the houses. On the ship over to Japan, too, when the harbor lights came into view, the lights were clustered around the harbor and the mountains were pitch dark. I was green in the face with seasickness, and the man next to me offered me kaoliang liquor from his canteen — and when I drank it, it made me even dizzier. Kakakaka. People's lights cluster where there are roads, water and work, I thought back then.

Now. When people hear about the population falling, they get scared. When they get scared, it usually goes like this. They quit everything, or they swarm at a high price to the one place everyone names, or they jump at a distant property with only a high yield figure because "it's cheap." All of them decide by mood without looking at the map.

In my view, rather than asking others where to aim, it's quicker to look at the lines the town drew itself. Inside a residential inducement area is where the town wants to gather people from now on. Outside, at least, the town has no intention of expanding there. It's not that you'll make money inside the lines, plans can be revised, and some towns haven't made a plan. But you can see who is drawing the shape of the town 20 years ahead, and how.

There's only one thing to do. If there's a property you're interested in, open that municipality's location normalization plan and check whether the property is inside or outside a residential inducement area.

A little population decline won't kill you. I crossed one sea and changed countries once, and here I am drinking again tonight.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.14)

Read a little deeper