BENERU
Market and macroPublished Updated

The population is falling, so why don't real estate prices go down?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Do you remember March 1990 (Heisei 2)? The government asked lenders to hold the growth of lending to the real estate industry at or below the growth of their total lending. What people call the "total volume restriction."

Let me tell an old story. Reading the government's White Paper on Land, in the following year, 1991, land prices in the three major metropolitan areas turned downward for both residential and commercial land, and regional areas followed in 1992. New lending to the real estate industry fell from about ¥10.4 trillion in 1989 to about ¥6.7 trillion in 1993. The total volume restriction was lifted in December 1991, but prices did not come back for a long time after that.

My view is this: what decided price movements back then was the flow of money more than the number of people. Land prices began to fall while Japan's population was still growing. According to the Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications' white paper, the total population peaked in 2008 and turned to decline. Yet in the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's 2026 (Reiwa 8) Land Price Publication, the national all-use average has risen for 5 years in a row. Prices fell when people were increasing, and rose when people were decreasing. Read prices by population alone, and you'd have been wrong both times.

When I told my wife this, she said, "You should count the number of sake flasks rather than the number of people." My wife counts every night how many I empty with my evening drink. So when I say, "Only 2 tonight, that's not many," she comes back with, "You switched to the big flasks, didn't you." Looking only at the count, you can't tell how much is inside.

Well, never mind my story.

Population is an important number. Over the long run, there will be towns where both renters and buyers decrease. But at the two turning points where the direction of prices changed in these 30-plus years, the number of people did not change direction; it was prices that did. Divining with one number is the same as trying to guess how much someone drank from the number of flasks.

When people get scared, it usually goes like this. Everyone looks at the same one number and runs all at once in the same direction. As far as I've seen, at the start of Heisei everyone pulled back at once with "land is dangerous," and lately everyone is bracing at once with "people are decreasing, so everything will fall." After everyone moves at once, there is usually an overshoot.

If you do one thing, check the flow of money with your own wallet. For the amount you plan to borrow, use a lender's repayment estimate once to work out how much your monthly repayment would rise if the interest rate went up by 1 percentage point. What moved prices at the time of the total volume restriction, too, was not the number of people but the amount of money that could be borrowed.

You can't tell how much sake was drunk from the number of flasks. You only know once you pour, drink and look at what's left.

(Updated 2026.10.15)
RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. And, and, and there it is. The "why doesn't real estate go down when the population is falling" question. The standard topic someone always brings up when real estate comes up.

No, what you're saying is right. If people decrease, people who rent and people who buy decrease. It really is a force that kicks in over the long run, and I'm not going to deny that.

But of course, here's the real point. Everyone already knows the population is going to fall. A national research institute publishes projections decades ahead, and you see it on the news again and again. So why do people buy at high prices even though they know? Are all the buyers naive people who don't read the news? No way.

Wait a sec, I'm going to flip one thing here. Prices aren't decided just by "what will happen in the future"; they move with the gap between "what everyone already knows" and "what they don't know yet." The story that the population will fall is widely known. You can assume a widely known story is already priced into today's price to a large extent. OK? So what moves prices is the part that deviates from everyone's expectations.

So, what that deviation actually is. One: the price of borrowed money. When interest rates are low, the amount you can borrow for the same monthly repayment rises, and the price you can pay goes up. Two: the money to build. If construction costs rise, the floor on the price of newly built properties rises, and second-hand ones get pulled along. Three: location skew. Population is a national total, but each home gets its price by location. Even if the national total falls, stations where people gather move differently. Get it?

Now the other side. If it's priced in, do you not need to worry about population? That's wrong too. What's priced in is only "the average expectation." If the town you buy in shrinks faster than average, that gap will show up in prices from here on. This part is quietly brutal.

So, fixing the question, it becomes this. Not "why doesn't it fall when the population is falling," but "will my town shrink faster or slower than everyone expects?" The way to check is to put that city, ward, town or village's future population projection side by side with the projection for the whole prefecture. If it shrinks more steeply than the prefecture, it's on the side where that gap will show up in prices from here on. Am I wrong?

Crab, you know, everyone knows it's expensive, but every winter it still sells, right? Because there are people who complain about the price and still pick the one packed full of meat. What you look at isn't the price tag; it's how packed it is inside the shell. See you.

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper