BENERU
Law, contracts and systemsPublished

After buying real estate, can I do the registration myself?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. Can I ask first? What do you want to do? Save the fee, or understand how registration works with your own hands? The answer changes depending on which.

The general answer is simple. You're allowed to apply for registration yourself. You can submit on paper to the Legal Affairs Bureau, and there's an online method too. But if you're buying with a loan, it's a different story: the payment of the price, the disbursement of the loan, the transfer of ownership and the setting of the mortgage all move at once on the same day, so it's normal for the lender to make a judicial scrivener's handling a condition. The registration and license tax costs the same whether you do it yourself or hire someone.

If I stopped here, I'd be a disgrace to the name of the sharp-tongued debugger. So why is there no end to people who, even knowing this, say "I want to do it myself"?

One reason is that the fee looks like "a handling charge for submitting documents." But what you're actually paying for isn't the labor; it's the role of filling the gap between the moment money is paid and the moment the title moves. With real estate, the person who registers first can say to others, "this is mine." If you pay the price but the registration is delayed, or it isn't accepted because of a defect in the documents, that gap leaves room for some other circumstance on the seller's side to slip in. Checking that the mortgage on the seller's loan is properly cancelled on the same day is also part of the gap's work. Get it?

The other is the sense of accomplishment of "I did it myself." I mean, that's right, it's right, but for practicing on an investment property, the price of a slip-up is too high. "But you said 'the answer changes depending on which'"? Yeah, so let me split it here.

If you just want to save the fee, as long as you buy with a loan, you'll save almost nothing. Even buying in cash, what you save is only the fee, and the responsibility for the gap moves entirely onto you. Whether it pays off, look at what % of the property price the fee is. Say the fee is ¥100,000 and the property is ¥10 million: that's 1%. To save that 1%, you carry ¥10 million worth of gap yourself. Put in numbers, that's a pretty sad trade, right?

If you want to understand how it works, there are ways without applying yourself. Have the judicial scrivener's estimate split into transfer of ownership, setting of the mortgage, and cancellation of the seller's mortgage, with each one's registration and license tax and fee on separate lines. When the registration is done, get the certificate of registered matters yourself and read the title and the details of the mortgage. That's seriously enough to understand how it works. Okay?

If you want to save, line up the amount saved against the gap. If you want to understand, what you work with your hands isn't the application form but the estimate and the certificate. Either way, decide before the contract. Am I wrong?

You know shimeji mushrooms — take them out of the pack and cut off the base, and anyone can cook them right away. But picking them yourself where they grow in the mountains takes an eye that can tell them apart from look-alike mushrooms. Registration too: you can start reading the part that comes in the pack today. Going into the mountains can wait until you've got the eye. See ya.

Sources (in Japanese)

Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hi, it's Jamie! On the night 8 days before settlement (closing), I got a call from the person in charge at the bank. "Jamie, which judicial scrivener will be handling the registration?" I proudly answered, "I'll do it myself!" The other end of the line went quiet for about 3 seconds.

It started at a drinking party with investor friends. A senior member said, "Registration? Everyone does it themselves. Paying a judicial scrivener is a waste," and everyone around nodded along. If everyone does it, I can too! — I decided that same night. The judicial scrivener's fee in the estimate was about ¥100,000. If I saved that, I could replace the unit's air conditioner!

The next weekend I booked a procedure consultation at the Legal Affairs Bureau and learned how to fill in the application. I used 1 day of paid leave too, and got my certificate of residence and seal registration certificate. I made the application myself as well. I calculated the registration and license tax by multiplying the property's price by the tax rate. I thought it was perfect!

But after the call, the person in charge explained it carefully. When there's financing, the rule is that a judicial scrivener designated by the bank applies for the transfer of ownership and the setting of the mortgage together on the same day. Thinking about it, the seniors at the drinking party were all people who'd bought cheap properties in cash or changed the title through inheritance. Among "everyone," there wasn't a single person who'd bought with a loan! My fault for not asking! No — my fault for just nodding and not asking a question!

From there, they hurriedly arranged a judicial scrivener for me. The document checks didn't make it in time, and the settlement day slipped back by 1 week. In the end, I paid the fee just as in the original estimate. All I saved was the fatigue from the paid leave I used!

On settlement day, I showed the judicial scrivener my handmade application, and they gently corrected just one spot. "The registration and license tax is calculated based on the fixed asset tax assessed value, not the sale price." My calculation was wrong from the foundation up!

And I hadn't learned my lesson. The envelope with the registration identification information arrived a few weeks later; relieved, I piled it on a stack of papers without even looking inside, and finally dug it up in the big cleaning half a year later!

Three things I'd tell myself back then.

  • For the "everyone" in "everyone does it," ask one by one whether they bought in cash or with a loan
  • If you're buying with a loan, ask the bank how the registration will be handled before the contract
  • When the registration identification information arrives, check the property and the title that same day and put it away in a set place

That New Year, when I went home to my parents' place, my nephew greeted me at the door with "Welcome home, Uncle Self-Registration!" Apparently my mom told him. And my mom had put a sticky note saying "Application enclosed" on the New Year's food boxes. Even now, whenever some document comes out at a family gathering, everyone looks at me!

Sources (in Japanese)

Read a little deeper