BENERU
Cash flow and yieldsPublished

If I factor in falling rent, how does my income and expense plan change?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. 0.82. If rent falls 1% every year, rent after 20 years is about 0.82 times what it was at the start. ¥80,000 becomes about ¥65,000. 1% a year looks like a teeny bit, right? But stack it 20 times and this is what you get.

Now, the way this question is framed. Aren't you thinking of it as a choice between two: "put in the assumption that rent falls, or don't"? Better to rearrange that. Not whether to put it in or not — work out first "how far can rent fall, in percent, before I can't hold out."

Let's go with an example. Rent ¥80,000, management fee and repair reserve fund ¥15,000 a month, loan repayment ¥50,000 a month. What goes out is ¥65,000 in total. Which means even if rent falls to ¥65,000 — a bit over 81% of the start — the cash left over stops at zero. The room it has to fall is about 19%. That's this unit's stamina.

So how many years does that stamina last? If it falls 1% every year, the cash left over hits zero in a bit over 20 years; at 2% every year, in a bit over 10 years. It's just a calculation of how many times you multiply by 0.99 before it drops below 0.8125. A little tricky? Well, hang in there. In a spreadsheet it's one line.

If I stopped here, I wouldn't deserve the name sharp-tongued debugger. This calculation still has two soft spots.

One. Rent doesn't fall smoothly every year. While the same person lives there, rent often stays the same. It drops all at once when tenants change. And that month, vacancy, fixing up the unit and the cost of finding a tenant pile up together. The real way it falls isn't a slope, it's a staircase, and every step comes with a one-time expense attached. Get it?

Two. The outgoing side moves too. Many condominiums plan to set the repair reserve fund low at first and raise it in stages later. With a variable rate, the repayment amount moves too. A simulation that lowers only the rent and keeps expenses fixed is a calculation standing on one leg. It's painful to watch.

No, well, there are units where rent doesn't fall. In a place close to a station where new properties are hard to build nearby, rent can be almost the same even after 10 years. So I'm not trying to declare that it will fall. What you want to know isn't "will it fall" but "if it falls, in what year do I start paying out of pocket." Once you know that, the amount of money to keep on hand and the guide for thinking about when to sell are settled. If rent falls, the yield a buyer calculates also falls, so it affects the price you can sell for too. Am I wrong?

So on the simulation you were given, add the room it can fall, and how many years that lasts at 1% and at 2%. Just two more numbers changes what the table means.

You know fragrant olive? While it's in bloom it feels like autumn will go on forever, but after one rain it's already scattered. The rent on the day you buy is the same as that scent. Make your plan in the garden after it's scattered, and if you can pick a unit whose flavor lasts over time, like turnips that get sweeter in winter, that's a job well done.

Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! I got new glasses, and now I can see the small numbers in tables clearly! The first thing I noticed once I could see was how sweet the income and expense table for my own unit was, though. By the way, today too I put 2 sticks of sugar in my coffee. I like things sweet — coffee and stories both!

When I bought my current second-hand condominium unit, the person in charge made an income and expense simulation for me. Rent was ¥75,000 a month, the same for all 35 years. Loan repayment ¥46,000 a month, management fee and repair reserve fund ¥12,000 a month. The calculation left ¥17,000 in hand every month.

"Doesn't rent go down as the building gets older?" I did ask, just in case. The person in charge said, "This station is popular, so if anything, rents have been going up the last few years." Sipping a sweet café au lait, I nodded at that sweet table. I stopped there and didn't calculate the case where it falls myself.

4 years later, the first tenant moved out. The unit was empty for 2 months until the next person was found, and the rent they agreed to was ¥71,000. Down ¥4,000! "Going up" was about new units near the station, not about my unit, which was over 20 years old. In the same year, at the condominium's general meeting, the repair reserve fund went up ¥3,000 a month.

The cash left over went from ¥17,000 a month to ¥10,000. On top of that, 2 months of vacancy meant ¥150,000 of rent didn't come in, and the cost of new wallpaper and finding a tenant went out too. That year's cash left over almost disappeared!

When I later remade the table myself, even if rent falls just 1% every year, the cash left over drops below ¥10,000 a month by year 10. If the repair reserve fund goes up another step, even sooner. If I had done this calculation at the start, my price negotiation and the amount of money I keep on hand would have been different.

The person in charge didn't lie. The station is popular, and rents for new units really were going up. It's just that nobody talked about my unit 20 years on. My fault for not asking! No — I did ask, so my fault for being convinced after one answer!

Three things I'd tell myself back then:

  • "Rents at this station don't fall" might be about new units. Ask about rents for units of about the same age
  • In the long-term repair plan, look at when and by how much the repair reserve fund is scheduled to go up
  • For the year tenants change, put in the vacancy and fixing-up costs together

Lately I've cut the sugar in my café au lait down to 1 stick. Same as with income and expense tables — if you start with less sweetness, you won't be disappointed later!

Read a little deeper