BENERU
Financing and interest ratesPublished Updated

What happens if I rent out a home I bought with a home loan?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. Before "what happens," let's first separate what it is that happens. This question has 3 separate topics rolled into one.

The first is about the loan contract. The second is about the tax deduction. The third is about when you sell. Let's go in order.

First, the loan. A home loan is money for buying a home that you or your family will live in. The terms are good because they come as a set with the premise that it's a home to live in. For example, Flat 35 clearly states that it can't be used for investment properties intended to be rented to third parties. Private home loans, too, are in principle for a home you live in yourself.

And here's the part that's often misunderstood. Is renting it out an instant fail? No, it isn't. With Flat 35, if you temporarily can't live there due to unavoidable circumstances like a job transfer, you can rent it out on the premise that you'll come back. However, you need to go through an address change procedure with the lender. The key is the set of 3: "temporary," "on the premise of coming back," and "notifying them."

Conversely, what happens if it turns out you used a home loan intending to rent the place out from the start? You may be asked to repay the full amount you borrowed in one lump sum. If you borrowed ¥30 million, that's ¥30 million, you know? Get it? If you break the very reason the terms are good, the terms get taken away along with it. Well, of course.

Next, taxes. The home loan deduction requires that you live there. From the year you stop living there, you can't receive it. If it's unavoidable circumstances like a job transfer, and you notify the tax office before you stop living there, you can receive it again for the remaining period when you come back. If you just leave without a word, that path gets narrower too.

Also, if you rent it out, rent comes in. Rent is real estate income, so you need to file a tax return. Someone with only a salary suddenly ends up on the filing side. "There's income from a house that's supposed to be my home" — doesn't that state of things seem a bit odd? Yes, that feeling of oddness is right.

Last, when you sell. The ¥30 million special deduction for selling your home can't be used unless you sell by the end of the year that contains the day 3 years after you stopped living there. For example, if you moved out and started renting it in 2026, the deadline is the end of 2029. If the deadline passes while you're renting it out, the home is no longer treated as "selling the home you lived in."

Now then. This is what I really want to say.

"Buy it with a home loan, and when you move, just rent it out" — ever heard that pitch? It skips all 3 topics. The loan promise, the deduction conditions, the deadline for selling. Step off on just one of them and you lose the good loan terms and the tax benefits at the same time. Is the person who told you that going to pay alongside you when you step off? They're not, right?

Conclusion. Renting out a home bought with a home loan does have a path, depending on your circumstances and the procedures. But if you intend to rent it from the start, then you should set it up with an investment loan from the start. Lie at the entrance, and you'll be billed for all of it at the exit.

You know new-crop rice — it doesn't sell at the new-crop price just because the bag says "new crop." If what's inside is last year's rice, of course people get angry. The contents and the bag being different is the one thing you must never do, whether it's rice or a loan.

Sources (in Japanese)

Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! I'm weak against recommendations. Back when I was looking for my first studio unit, I fell in love at first sight with a second-hand unit that showed up under "Recommended for you" in an investment app.

The app's ad said this: "Buy with a home loan's low interest rate, and the rent pays the loan with money to spare every month!" It came with a cash flow simulation too: borrowing ¥18 million at 0.8% interest over 35 years, the repayment is about ¥49,000 a month, the rent is ¥85,000, and even after subtracting ¥15,000 for the management fee and repair reserve fund, about ¥20,000 is left every month (the numbers are assumptions based on the screen at the time). I believed it: "So I just buy with a home loan and rent it out!"

So I went to the bank to apply for pre-screening for a home loan. The person at the counter asked, "This is a property you'll be living in, right?" and I answered honestly, "No, I plan to rent it out!" The person at the counter kindly explained that a home loan is for a home that you or your family will live in, and that if the purpose is to rent it out, it would be an investment loan.

The problem came after that. When I recalculated with an investment loan, the interest rate was 2.4% (an assumption). With the same ¥18 million over 35 years, the repayment is about ¥63,400 a month. Subtract ¥15,000 and ¥63,400 from ¥85,000, and about ¥6,600 is left. Subtract the property management company's fee and fixed asset tax, and it's almost zero or negative. The app's "money to spare every month" was a number that only appeared with a home loan's interest rate!

In the end, I didn't buy that unit. All I was left with was the copy of my pre-screening application.

Later, I worked out the difference between the 2 interest rates myself. With the same ¥18 million over 35 years, the difference in repayment is about ¥14,200 a month. That's about ¥170,000 a year, and about ¥6 million over 35 years. The app's "money to spare every month" was counting that entire ¥6 million or so as my gain. A home loan's low interest rate is a number for a way of borrowing meant for people who live there, not a number I could use when buying to rent out.

When I told this story at my parents' house, my dad laughed hard: "Were you planning to let the app's recommendations decide your home loan too?" My mom said, "At least you deserve credit for being honest!"

3 things I'd tell myself back then.

  • When you see an ad's simulation, first check "which loan's interest rate is this?"
  • If you plan to rent it out, rebuild the cash flow with an investment loan's interest rate before you decide
  • Say honestly at the very first counter whether you'll live there or rent it out

By the way, even now, whenever I'm looking at my phone, my dad asks, "Is that a recommendation too?"

Sources (in Japanese)