Wang here. Tonight I am drinking warmed sake. The residential land special provision for fixed asset tax is, so to speak, a story about a vessel. To give the answer first: if a house for people to live in stands on it, whether you live there yourself or rent it out, that land goes into the vessel of the special provision. A rental apartment building and the site of a condominium unit are the same. But if you know when and why this vessel was made, you can see what the fear of falling out of it really is.
In fiscal 1973 (Showa 48), a special provision was made that set the tax base of residential land at 1/2 of the price. The next year, fiscal 1974 (Showa 49), a special provision was added setting small-scale residential land of 200㎡ or less at 1/4. The reasoning was that, along with the move to a system that taxes on the basis of assessed value, the burden on land people live on should not suddenly become heavy.
The next peak was fiscal 1994 (Heisei 6). It was decided to bring the valuation of residential land into line at around 70% (7/10) of the Land Price Publication prices and so on as a target. If valuations jump all at once, taxes leap too. So from the same fiscal 1994, the special provision was deepened: small-scale residential land from 1/4 to 1/6, and general residential land from 1/2 to 1/3. Today's 1/6 is a vessel that was deepened to absorb the shock of raising valuations.
When I came across to Japan by ship from Manchuria, the first thing that surprised me when we reached port was how houses were packed onto narrow land. The fields of Manchuria went on to the horizon. In a country with little land, how you tax land decides the shape of people's lives as it is.
But deepening the vessel grew another problem. With a house standing, it is 1/6; tear it down, and it goes back. Then some people leave even a damaged house that nobody lives in standing rather than tearing it down. In May 2015 (Heisei 27), the Act on Special Measures concerning the Promotion of Measures for Vacant Houses, etc. came fully into force, and with the revision of the Local Tax Act the same year, the sites of designated vacant houses that received a recommendation from the mayor of the municipality were removed from the special provision. From May 2015 (Heisei 27) to March 2023 (Reiwa 5), recommendations to designated vacant houses total 3,078 cases. With the revision in force from December 13, 2023 (Reiwa 5), poorly managed vacant houses, which could become designated vacant houses if left as they are, also fall out of the special provision if they receive a recommendation.
Being afraid usually goes like this. Afraid the tax will rise, you leave it standing without tearing it down. While you leave it, it deteriorates. The deteriorated house receives a recommendation, and in the end the special provision is removed anyway. You take the long way round and arrive at the very place you were trying to avoid out of fear.
What matters for those who hold property to rent out is that the special provision attaches not to "a building being there" but to "being usable as a house for people to live in." Even if vacancies continue, if you keep it maintained you are inside the vessel; neglect it and receive a recommendation, and you are outside.
What you can do tomorrow is ask at the municipality's tax counter how much the land's fixed asset tax would be in the year the special provision no longer applies, and write down on paper the difference from the current tax. That difference is the price of neglecting maintenance.
Warmed sake, if you pour it from the flask and leave it, cools and loses its flavor. While it is in the vessel, you check the temperature.