BENERU
Basics and getting startedPublished

If what I want is to prepare for retirement, do I really need to borrow and own real property?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. What you need to prepare for retirement is income, or money you can draw down, that covers the monthly shortfall from age 65 onward. Borrowing to own a rental property can create income in the form of rent after full repayment, but until full repayment, loan repayments and out-of-pocket spending continue, and even as you grow older, the decisions about management and sale remain. If the shortfall can be covered by means that do not involve borrowing, such as how you receive your pension or regular investing, the need to borrow becomes smaller.

The retirement shortfall in numbers

From the Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications' "Family Income and Expenditure Survey (Income and Expenditure), Summary of Average Results for 2025 (Reiwa 7)", the monthly household finances of non-working households aged 65 and over.

HouseholdDisposable incomeConsumption expenditureShortfall
Non-working households of a married couple only¥221,544¥263,979¥42,434
Non-working single-person households¥118,465¥148,445¥29,980

These are averages, and housing costs and pension amounts differ from household to household. If the couple's shortfall continued for 25 years, it would be about ¥12.73 million.

How to compare the means of covering the shortfall

MeansBorrowingEffort in later yearsCan you use just the amount you need?
Deferred pension receiptNoneAlmost noneThe increased pension continues for life. Nothing is received while you wait
Regular investing (NISA, etc.)NoneLittleYou can choose the amount to sell. Prices can fall
Borrowing to own a rental propertyYesTenant turnover, repairs and decisions about sale continueYou cannot sell just part of it. Rent may move together with prices

Deferral increases the pension by 0.7% per month, and deferring until age 75 increases it by 84% (for people born on or after April 2, 1952 (Showa 27), and others). The new NISA has a tax-free allowance of ¥3.6 million a year and ¥18 million over a lifetime (as of October 2026 (Reiwa 8)).

A calculation splitting the same money into two paths (assumptions)

Suppose that at age 48 you buy an ¥18 million condominium unit with a down payment of ¥3 million and borrowing of ¥15 million (interest rate 2.5%, 22 years, full repayment at age 70). The rent is ¥70,000 a month, and the management fee, repair reserve fund, fixed asset tax and so on are ¥22,000 a month.

Borrow and ownInvest the same amount regularly
Ages 48 to 70Against repayments of about ¥74,000, the net income is ¥48,000. About ¥26,000 out of pocket every monthInvest ¥3 million at the start, then ¥26,000 every month
Ages 65 to 70Still repaying, so it is not income that covers the shortfallYou can draw down the amount you need
At age 70No borrowing. If the rent is unchanged, net income of ¥48,000 a month and the property remainAbout ¥9.84 million at 0% returns, about ¥15.47 million at 3% a year

Falling rent, vacancies and the burden of major repairs are not included.

Order of checks

  1. Check your expected pension amount from age 65 in your Nenkin Teiki Bin (pension statement) or similar.
  2. Estimate your monthly spending in retirement, and work out the shortfall and the age at which the shortfall begins.
  3. Calculate whether deferral, the length of time you work and regular investing cover the shortfall.
  4. Only if part of it remains uncovered, calculate the age at full repayment if you borrow and own, and the out-of-pocket spending until full repayment.

From here on, this is my opinion

If the purpose is to prepare for retirement, I think you should first work out how far the shortfall can be covered by means that do not involve borrowing. If it can be covered, the reasons to borrow and own real property become purposes separate from retirement funds, such as possibly living there someday or wanting to leave real property to your family. If you have such a purpose, I think it is enough to compare it as a decision separate from retirement preparation.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.18)
RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. "What I want is to prepare for retirement" — you put the purpose ahead of the means. Good eye. Real estate talk usually starts from a property, and the purpose gets stuck on afterwards. But it's still soft. Once you've set the purpose, you have to write it all the way out as a formula, or you can't compare it with the means.

Write retirement preparation as a formula, and roughly it's: what do you cover "the monthly shortfall from age 65 × the number of years it continues" with. Put real property owned with debt in there, and it becomes this: "(rent − expenses) × the number of years after full repayment + the sale price − out-of-pocket spending until full repayment." You know?

So, now the real point. This formula has age hidden in 2 places.

The first is the number of years after full repayment. Suppose you take out a 35-year loan at age 40, and full repayment is at age 75. For the 10 years from 65 to 75, the rent goes to repayments and hardly comes over to the side that covers the shortfall. For the first 10 years when your work income stops, the first term of this formula is almost zero.

The second is what's inside rent − expenses. What goes into the formula isn't the rent in the year you bought it — it's the rent the 75-year-old you receives. By then the building has added 35 more years to its age. Rent tends to go down, and repairs tend to go up. Tenant turnover, replacing the water heater, whether to sell or hold — the one deciding is you at around 80. Seriously, have you put all that into the numbers?

Wait a sec. Up to here it sounds like real property is the bad guy, so I'll pick up the other side too. In an age when prices go up, waiting for retirement with cash alone is unsettling. Rent sometimes moves together with prices, so real property has a strength there. That's right, it is right, but that's a reason to "own real property," not a reason to "borrow and own." Whether to borrow is a different line of the formula. Get it?

One more. The formula for covering the shortfall without borrowing is about "the amount invested × returns" and "how you receive your pension," so there are few variables. The formula for borrowing to own real property has many variables, and the hits and misses are bigger by that much. If the shortfall can be covered without borrowing, there's little reason to go out of your way to add variables. If it can't, that's when it first becomes a candidate to compare. OK?

If you're going to get your hands moving, write 3 ages on paper. The age you finish repaying the loan, the age the monthly shortfall begins, and the age you won't want to decide things about the property yourself anymore. If the first is later than the second, and also later than the third, that property is less a retirement preparation than homework you're carrying into retirement.

Around the time of the first frost, a box of mandarins arrives on top of the kotatsu. But if you plant a mandarin sapling in the garden, you wait years until it bears fruit. Boxed mandarins and sapling mandarins are the same mandarins, but the winter you can eat them is different. Decide first which winter you want to eat them, then choose whether to plant the sapling or order the box.

(Updated 2026.10.18)

Read a little deeper