BENERU
Basics and getting startedPublished

If I can reach my goal without real estate, is there still a reason to use credit?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. ¥30,000 a month. This one number settles about half of this question.

Say there's a 40-year-old who wants to add ¥10 million to their retirement money by age 65. They save ¥30,000 a month for 25 years. Assuming it grows at 3% a year, that's about ¥13.38 million; even if it only grows 1%, about ¥10.22 million; even if it doesn't grow at all, ¥9 million. It nearly reaches the ¥10 million goal. With zero debt.

So, the answer shows when you go back to the formula. The formula for borrowing to own real estate is, roughly, "what's left in hand = what the property earns − the cost of the borrowed money − vacancies and repairs." Borrowing is a tool that lets you own a property bigger than your own money, right now. In other words, what credit adds is two things: "size" and "speed." If the goal is ¥10 million and saving gets you there, you need neither size nor speed. The reason to buy something you don't need with debt is thin. Don't get it?

So, here's the real point. Well, I said "nearly reaches" a moment ago, but that stands on assumptions too. What if the goal were ¥20 million? Even at 3% it's about ¥13.38 million, short by more than ¥6 million. The ways to fill that are to raise the monthly amount, extend the period, raise the growth assumption, or borrow and own something big. Only here does credit enter the options. "Enough without real estate" is something you can only say once the goal and the assumptions are decided as a set. Okay?

Let me knock down the other side too. The logic that "credit shrinks with time, so you should use it while you can." Half right. As you get older the period you can borrow for shrinks, and credit you don't use doesn't stay like savings. But "use it because it shrinks" is full of holes. What shrinks is the amount you can use, not the reason to use it. Even if you have a coupon about to expire, things you don't need are things you don't need.

So when does a reason remain? One, when the size your goal needs won't be reached in time at the pace of saving. Two, when you see value in the real thing itself. You or your family might live there, you want to decide how to rent it out yourself, you want to leave it in the form of land and a building. A savings account can't stand in for these. Three, when you have one of those, and on top of that, because of your age, now is the only time you can borrow over a long period. Three alone isn't a reason. It looks like a teeny-tiny difference, but this is the crux.

So if you're going to do something, do this. Write your goal in one sentence, and see whether the sentence contains any of "big," "soon," or "the real thing." If not one is in it, there's probably no reason left to use credit. If one is, decide by whether you'll take on the monthly repayments and vacancies for that one word. Am I wrong?

If all you want is chestnut rice, buying peeled chestnuts does the job. The reason to go wrestle with burrs in the mountains is thin. What? The fun starts with peeling the burrs? Oh, fine. Then that's a reason peeled chestnuts can't buy.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. If you can reach your goal by means other than real estate, mainly 3 reasons remain for using borrowing: owning assets larger than your own funds sooner, using the property in ways only physical real estate allows, and the treatment of valuation for inheritance. If your goal needs none of these, the reason to borrow becomes thin.

Comparison by goal

GoalMain means without borrowingWhat owning real estate with borrowing addsBurden added at the same time
Retirement incomeRegular investing, deposits, government bondsIncome in the form of rent. After full repayment, there are no more repaymentsVacancies, repairs, changes in interest rates. Little cash left over until full repayment
Size of assetsRegular investingYou can own assets many times your own fundsSwings in gains and losses also grow by the amount borrowed
InheritanceDeposits, securitiesValuation as land with a building for rent (kashiya tatetsuke chi), the special provision for small-scale residential land, etc.Hard to divide. The special provision has conditions

Limits for means without borrowing (NISA, as of October 2026 (Reiwa 8))

ItemDetails
Annual investment quotaTsumitate (regular investment) quota ¥1.2 million, growth investment quota ¥2.4 million (¥3.6 million in total)
Tax-free holding limit¥18 million over a lifetime (of which ¥12 million for the growth investment quota)
Tax-free holding periodUnlimited

Calculation

The numbers are assumptions. This is the case of saving ¥50,000 a month for 20 years.

Growth assumptionAmount after 20 years
No growth (0%)¥12 million
4% a yearabout ¥18.34 million

If the goal is "¥15 million by age 65," it is reached if it grows at 4% a year, and if it doesn't grow, you are ¥3 million short. If the goal is "assets on the scale of ¥30 million," saving over the same period won't reach it, and borrowing enters the candidates to compare.

Treatment in inheritance

ItemDetails
Land with a building for rentValued as the value as self-used land minus (value as self-used land × leasehold ratio × tenancy right ratio × rental ratio)
Special provision for small-scale residential land, etc. (residential land for lending business, etc.)50% reduction up to 200㎡. Residential land newly put to lending within 3 years before the start of inheritance is, in principle, not covered
Revision of the valuation of property for lending (planned)For inheritances, etc. on or after January 1, 2027 (Reiwa 9), a revision is planned under which certain property for lending acquired or newly built for consideration within 5 years before the start of inheritance is, in principle, valued at its normal transaction price (the National Tax Agency published a draft circular in September 2026 (Reiwa 8))

Order of checks

  1. Write your goal as an amount and a time (example: ¥15 million by age 65).
  2. Calculate whether means without borrowing reach it, using a lowish growth assumption.
  3. If they do, check whether you are looking for uses that only physical real estate allows.
  4. If they don't, compare whether to fill the shortfall with the savings amount, the period, or borrowing.

From here on, this is my opinion

Of the 3 reasons, when valuation for inheritance is the reason, I think you should not decide by the amount by which the valuation falls alone. You should put the difficulty of dividing, the burden of vacancies and repairs, and the conditions of the special provision in the same table, and decide after comparing them with the expected inheritance tax itself. That is because if you borrow looking only at how the valuation falls, you may take on a burden larger than the tax you save.

Read a little deeper