BENERU
Basics and getting startedPublished Updated

When stock index investing exists, why do some people invest in real estate?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Let me give my view first. That question seems to be asking "when there's an easy road, why do some people take the long way round?" But half of it actually carries "a leftover from the days when there was only one road."

A bit of old history. The mechanism for holding real estate price movements in small lots began in Japan not so long ago. In November 2000 (Heisei 12), the laws on investment trusts and investment corporations and the Building Lots and Buildings Transaction Business Act were amended, making it possible to form J-REITs. The first 2 were listed on September 10, 2001 (Heisei 13). In the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's white paper, even at the end of February 2003 (Heisei 15) there were only 6 listed. Before that, there were no small lots of real estate priced daily on an exchange. If an individual wanted to earn from real estate, buying one whole physical property was the main way — that's my view.

On the stock side too, regular investing got a tax push only recently. NISA began in 2014 (Heisei 26), Tsumitate NISA was created in 2018 (Heisei 30), and from January 2024 (Reiwa 6) it switched to the new NISA. According to an explanation by Financial Services Agency officials, Tsumitate NISA had 7.25 million accounts at the end of 2022 (Reiwa 4). The road of holding things spread out without effort grew thick as a system only in the last 10 years or so.

Back to the point. A reader in 2026 (Reiwa 8) has 2 easy roads that didn't exist when we were young. Stock indexes and real estate REITs. Those who still choose physical real estate aren't refusing an easy life. They're going out to buy what only a physical property can give. One is being able to decide its use yourself. Rent it to someone, or let your child live there when they go off on their own. REIT units can't be lived in, and you can't change how they're rented. The other is being able to check and choose with your own feet. The road from the station, the building next door, the foot traffic morning and evening — you can see them with your own eyes. Nobody walks around inspecting the contents of an index.

But the flip side comes along with it. Being able to decide the use means deciding, and cleaning up when you decide wrong, is also on you. Being able to check with your feet also means your assets lean toward towns your feet can reach. When it comes to holding things spread widely, indexes and REITs do it better.

Well, it won't kill you. But not being able to sleep is a problem. On a night the index falls, you can sleep if you don't look. On a night a room you bought with debt sits empty, the debit date won't leave your head. It's not which is better, but which kind of night you're strong against. Kakakaka — I'm hopeless on nights with debt.

If I recommend one thing: before buying a physical property, move the monthly repayment for the amount you intend to borrow into a separate account every month for 1 year. If you keep it up for a year and sleep soundly at night as well, your nerve for owning a physical property is set. If you get sick of it partway, there's nothing wrong at all with REITs or an index.

With drink, too, there's the way of ordering one glass at a time at a bar, and the way of buying a whole jar and letting it age. A jar takes up space, and if it breaks, it's a sorry sight. But the flavor of your own jar is one only you can bring out.

(Updated 2026.10.15)
Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! Stock index investing and real estate investment — I do both. So let me talk about why some people do real estate, from my own experience.

The first thing I started was regular investing in an index fund through NISA. A fixed amount is debited every month, and after that I do nothing. Honestly, it was really easy.

After that, I bought one second-hand condominium unit. The reason was simple: a senior colleague at work said, "The feature of real estate is that you can buy it with borrowed money."

Actually doing it, I found 3 differences.

First, you can buy with borrowed money. With an index fund, you can only buy as much as the money you put in. With a condo, you can buy a property worth several times the down payment with a loan. If the rent covers the repayment, something bigger than your own money works for you. But this also works the other way. If vacancies continue, the repayment comes out of my salary. In fact, when a tenant moved out and it sat empty for 2 months, all of that was out of pocket.

Second, it takes effort. Even when you leave it to a property management company, there are restoration estimates when tenants leave, equipment breakdowns, and contact at every renewal. Exchanges that never once happened with an index fund happen several times a year. When the water heater broke, replacing it cost over ¥100,000. That came out of my wallet too.

Third, you can't see the price every day. Stocks move in price every day, and when they fall I end up checking because it bothers me. With a condo, you don't know the price unless you put it up for sale. It's easier on the mind, but because of that, you don't know how much it would actually sell for unless you look it up yourself. Once a year, I check nearby transaction prices on the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's Real Estate Information Library.

Which is better honestly depends on the person. If you don't want to put in effort, I think an index is enough. For people who want to use borrowed money, take on the effort, and judge for themselves, real estate has meaning.

Three things I'd like to tell myself back then.

  • Being able to buy with borrowed money works by the same multiple when things go badly too
  • Even if you leave it to a property management company, moments of judgment remain
  • Precisely because you can't see the price, research the market yourself

By the way, my regular investment got debited as if nothing had happened, even in the month the condo's vacancy put me out of pocket. That month, I got through by using one less sugar in my coffee!

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper