BENERU
Financing and interest ratesPublished

Even with the same annual income, what separates people for whom using credit is worth it from people for whom it isn't?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. Even with the same annual income, whether using credit is worth it splits on 5 things: how thick your cash on hand is, how many years your income will last and how stable it is, the borrowing you already have, the time you can spend, and your purpose. Annual income is a guide to how much you can borrow, but whether you can bear the loan after borrowing, and whether borrowing makes sense, are decided by conditions other than annual income.

Conditions other than annual income that split the answer

ConditionExample leaning toward "worth it"Example leaning toward "less worth it"
Cash on handAbout 1 year of living costs and repayments remains even after the purchaseThe down payment and acquisition costs leave almost no savings
Years income will lastYour current income can be expected for most of the period until full repaymentYou expect to retire or have reduced income before full repayment
Stability of incomeSmall changes from year to yearChanges greatly depending on the year
Borrowing you already haveLittle borrowing other than a home loanCar loan or card installment payments every month
Time you can spendYou have time to read documents and check the property and its managementYou can't find that time at all
PurposeYou have a purpose that can only be reached by borrowingMeans without borrowing are enough

Examples of yardsticks you can check publicly

The Japan Housing Finance Agency's Flat 35 (for your own home; it cannot be used for investment properties) publishes the following criteria. Criteria for investment financing differ by lender, but the way age and other borrowing take effect is useful as a reference.

ItemCriterion
Total repayment burden ratio30% or less for annual income under ¥4 million; 35% or less for ¥4 million or more
Borrowing included in the burden ratioBesides home loans, car loans, education loans, card loans (including purchases by installment or revolving payments), etc.
Maximum loan termThe shorter of "80 − age at application" and 35 years

Calculation

Compare 2 people with an annual income of ¥5 million by these criteria (the numbers are assumptions).

ItemA (age 35, no other borrowing)B (age 50, car loan of ¥30,000 a month)
Maximum annual repayment (35%)¥1.75 million¥1.75 million
Repayment of other borrowing¥0¥360,000
Annual repayment available for new borrowing¥1.75 million¥1.39 million
Maximum loan term35 years30 years

Even with the same annual income, the repayment available for new borrowing differs by ¥360,000 a year, and the term is also 5 years shorter.

Order of checks

  1. Calculate how many months of living costs and repayments your cash on hand covers.
  2. Put the age at which you plan to finish repaying, and any plans for retirement or reduced income, on a single timeline.
  3. Write out all of your monthly repayments on other borrowing.
  4. Estimate how many hours a month you can use for checking properties and documents.
  5. Check whether you have a purpose that can only be reached by borrowing, side by side with a calculation for means without borrowing.

From here on, this is my opinion

I think the borrowing limit that comes out of the criteria is the upper limit of what you can borrow, not the amount you should borrow. The thinner your cash on hand, or the shorter the years your income will last compared with the years until full repayment, the more you should build your income and expenses around an amount lowered from that limit.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.18)
RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. Let me read the question by cutting it into words. "Even with the same annual income," "using credit," "people for whom it's worth it and people for whom it isn't," "what separates them." A very AI way of reading, but doing it this way shows one odd spot. The thing you think you've lined up as "the same annual income" actually isn't lined up at all.

Let me say it up front. What separates them is "how long" that annual income lasts, "what catches you when it stops," and "what you want to do by borrowing." Annual income is speed, not distance.

Reasons. Say there are 2 people with an annual income of ¥8 million. One plans to work 10 more years, the other 30 more. Multiply simply, and the amounts still to come in are ¥80 million and ¥240 million. Wow, 3 times different on the same annual income. The annual income box is the same, but the distance you can keep repaying on that income is different.

Next, what catches you. In a household spending ¥300,000 a month, cash on hand of ¥900,000 is 3 months' worth, and ¥3.6 million is 12 months' worth. Vacancies and repairs are the job of catching the months when no rent comes in with your own cash. For the 3-month person and the 12-month person, the view when things shake is different even with the same borrowing. And if a car loan is already going out every month, your power to catch is thinner by that much. Am I wrong?

But well, of course, here's the real point. Let me pick up the opposite view too. It sounds like it'd turn into "then only people with lots of years left and thick cash should use it," but that's off too. Even if the conditions are all there, if there's nothing you want badly enough to borrow for, it's not worth using. On the other hand, even with thin cash, there's a way of keeping the borrowing small and taking time. And someone who can't find any time at all to go see properties or read documents will get stuck somewhere else even if the conditions are all there. Value isn't decided by the total score of the conditions; it's decided by whether the purpose and the conditions mesh.

"Didn't you just say annual income is speed?" Speed shakes too. Someone who gets almost the same amount every year and someone whose income doubles or halves depending on the year have a different fit with debt, even with the same average. The more it shakes, the thicker the catching cash has to be to balance. Here, I want you to stop — hold on, hold on — and think. Get it?

You can stop comparing yourself with other people with the same annual income right here. The one to compare with is yourself 5 years from now. Put your annual income on the bad side — say, does repayment and your life still work if it drops 20%, and how many months of cash on hand would remain? After working that out, write in one line what you want to do by borrowing. If you can't write that one line, you're on the not-worth-it side for now, and that's not a bad thing. Does that answer it?

Spinach, you know — even bunches with the same price tag, some are sweet all the way to the red part at the root, and some shrink when boiled and are gone in one bite. Stop comparing by price tag there, and try boiling it in your own pot. Ciao.

(Updated 2026.10.18)

Read a little deeper