BENERU
Basics and getting startedPublished

Who is "while you're young, don't borrow; save first" right for?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

This is Wang. "While you're young, don't borrow; save first." In the way we said it in my day, it was "Debt ruins a man; the young should save as if lighting their fingernails for candles." Put more stiffly, "Measure what comes in, then decide what goes out." They all say the same thing, and none of them is wrong. The question is who the words are aimed at.

Let me tell you an old story. In 1963 (Showa 38), a system that didn't tax the interest on small deposits, the so-called maru-yū, was created. Those who saved could receive their interest whole. Then in 1988 (Showa 63), it was changed to the maru-yū for the elderly and others, and those eligible were narrowed to people aged 65 or over, people with disabilities, and so on. That is how it is laid out in the materials of the Government Tax Commission. One tailwind for the young when they saved stopped blowing here.

There's one more. In August 1984 (Showa 59), the Japan Scholarship Foundation Act was entirely revised, and a system of interest-bearing scholarships was set up. That's from the records of the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology. The number of people receiving scholarship loans grew from 930,000 in fiscal 2004 (Heisei 16) to 1.31 million in fiscal 2012 (Heisei 24). Among the young today, not a few carry a debt they start repaying the day they go out into society. For some, the premise of "don't borrow" doesn't hold from the very start.

Let me tell you about a hangover. When I was young, I took "Drink sake, but don't let sake drink you" to heart, and so as not to be drunk by it, I stuffed my belly full of rice before drinking. Whether a full belly made me bold or what, that night I knocked back twice my usual, and the next morning I couldn't crawl out of my futon. I kept only the form of the words and missed what was inside them. Kakakaka.

Well, enough about me.

"Save first" is right for those whose earnings swing month to month and year to year, and those with thin reserves for hard times. Those who earn by commission or by piecework, those who have just started a business, those whose take-home pay is squeezed by scholarship repayments. If people like that take on debt first, then in a month when earnings swing, repayment and living expenses fight over one wallet. Savings are the foundation that absorbs that swing.

On the other hand, what happens when someone whose earnings are almost the same every month, and who has built up some reserves, keeps only the words and goes on saving for years? The time you have to borrow and repay grows shorter with each year. In my view, for someone like that, "save first" can also become words that make you give up time while you think you're keeping to them. That doesn't mean I'm telling you to borrow. A life without borrowing is a fine thing too. What I'm saying is, don't swallow the words whole without checking which side you're on.

Even when the times change, people's habits don't. The more familiar the words, the more people keep to them without checking whose mouth they came from and who they were aimed at.

A word to the young. Line up the amounts of your salary deposits for all of last year, and write down the smallest month and the largest month. Those with a big gap, save first. Those with a small gap, write in the corner of that paper the deadline for how many years you'll save.

(Updated 2026.10.18)
Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! Lately I switched my vending-machine canned coffee from "low sugar" back to "extra sweet"! Because I learned that holding back too much never leads to anything good. Today's story is about how I learned that!

When I was 25, I was a contract employee, and my contract was renewed every 1 year. In the break room at work, the regular-employee seniors all said the same thing: "Don't borrow while you're young. Save first. Everyone does it." I looked around, and really, everyone was nodding. Right, me too! I decided on the spot.

And what I did was follow only the "don't borrow" part, extremely seriously. When I had to buy a used kei car for a job you commute to by car, I didn't take a loan and paid all in cash. ¥1.2 million. I had ¥1.3 million in savings, so ¥100,000 was left. Zero debt! I'm living more correctly than my seniors! I was a little proud.

3 months later, my contract wasn't renewed. It took 2 months until my next job was decided. Rent was ¥65,000 a month, and with my other living costs it was about ¥120,000 a month. The ¥100,000 in hand was gone in the first month.

So what did I do? I took a ¥250,000 cash advance on my card. The interest rate was 18% a year. I, who bought a car in cash so as not to borrow, took on the highest-interest debt available to me to pay rent! It took 4 months to pay it off, and the interest was about ¥10,000 (rough calculation!).

I realized later that the seniors were all regular employees, with monthly salaries that were pretty much fixed. Those words were right. In fact, they applied most of all to me, on a contract renewed every 1 year. And yet I kept only the easy-to-see part, "zero debt," and emptied out my own savings, which was the part that mattered.

There are three things I'd like to tell the me of back then.

  • Compare how the "everyone" in "everyone does it" works with how you work
  • Decide big purchases not by whether you can pay in cash, but by how much you'll have left in hand after paying
  • If your contract renewal date is fixed, save by working backward from that date

When I told my older brother this story, he started saying it to me every New Year: "The man who hated debt so much, he paid his rent with debt." This past New Year, even my nephew had learned it, and said it to me before I handed over his New Year's money! I pulled the envelope back once, and my brother teased me again: "So childish"!

(Updated 2026.10.18)

Read a little deeper