BENERU
Financing and interest ratesPublished

How do a car loan or card installment payments affect borrowing for investment?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. In many screenings, car loans and credit card installment payments are added to the repayments on the new borrowing not as a "balance" but as an "annual repayment amount". The shorter the term of a loan, the larger its annual repayment relative to its balance, so even a small balance can greatly reduce the amount you can borrow. Which borrowing is counted, and how, differs by lender.

The range of borrowing that is added together (a public example)

Flat 35 sets the standard for the total debt-to-income ratio (the share of annual income taken up by total annual repayments) at 30% or less for an annual income under ¥4 million, and 35% or less for ¥4 million or more. The borrowing included in this calculation is as follows.

Borrowing included
Housing loans other than Flat 35
Car loans, education loans
Card loans (including cash advances on credit cards, and purchases of goods by installment payments or revolving payments)
Borrowing for housing to be rented out or being rented out (excluding loans for rental apartments such as a whole multi-unit building)
Borrowing by a person whose income is combined with yours

Flat 35 is a loan for your own home and cannot be used for investment. With investment loans, some lenders also look at rental income, and how repayments on other borrowing are counted also differs by lender.

Balance and annual repayment (calculation)

BorrowingBalanceInterest rate and termAnnual repaymentShare of balance
Car loan¥2.4 million3%, 5 yearsabout ¥517,000about 21.6%
Investment loan¥30 million2%, 35 yearsabout ¥1.193 millionabout 4.0%

The balance is 1/12, but the annual repayment is more than 40%.

The effect on the amount you can borrow (assumption)

Assume an annual income of ¥7 million, an upper limit of 35% for the debt-to-income ratio in screening, and a screening interest rate of 4% over 30 years.

Other borrowingAnnual repaymentLimit available for new borrowingGuide to the amount you can borrow
None¥0¥2.45 millionabout ¥42.8 million
Car loan (example above)about ¥517,000about ¥1.933 millionabout ¥33.7 million
The above plus installment payments of ¥8,000 a month and revolving payments of ¥10,000 a monthabout ¥733,000about ¥1.717 millionabout ¥30 million

The guide drops by about ¥9 million with a single car loan, and by about ¥12.8 million with the installment and revolving payments added. How rental income is treated and the screening rate differ by lender, so these numbers are an example to show the mechanism.

Order of checks

  1. Write down the monthly repayment on all borrowing, including car loans, installment payments, revolving payments and cash advances.
  2. Multiply by 12 to get the annual repayment, and work out its share of annual income.
  3. Ask the lender you are applying to how it counts other borrowing and rental income.
  4. Compare the amount you can borrow if you reduce repayments by paying off in full or in part, and if you don't.

From here on, this is my opinion

I think whether to pay off small loans should not be decided only on the basis that the amount you can borrow will increase. If you use cash on hand to pay them off, your reserves after acquiring the property become thinner. You should set out in numbers both the effect of lower repayments and the cash left on hand before deciding.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.18)
Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! How do a car loan or card installment payments affect borrowing for investment? In my case, it all started with a "recommended household budget app ranking"!

3 years ago, I installed the household budget app ranked number 1. Register your card, and it graphs your monthly payments. Inside that app, an ad popped up: "Make your payments a fixed amount each month. Your household budget gets so much easier!" I tapped it, and it was a guide to switching my card payments to revolving payments. My monthly payment would be constant, and I'd get extra points too. If it makes things easier — awesome! I switched on the spot.

After that, I casually bought a new computer and new glasses on the card. The computer in 24 installments, and the glasses too while I was at it, in 12. The monthly payment was constant, so it didn't hurt at all. The graph in the app was beautifully flat, and I felt like I'd gotten good at managing my budget.

Then came applying for the loan on a condominium unit. The person at the bank asked, "Do you have any other borrowing?" and I answered proudly, "I don't even own a car — none!" Then they said, "You have revolving payments and installment payments on your card."

What, that counts as borrowing too? I was shocked. The revolving balance was about ¥360,000, at ¥12,000 a month. The installment payments for the computer and glasses were ¥12,500 a month. Together that's ¥24,500 a month, ¥294,000 a year. According to the person at the bank, these repayments are also subtracted when calculating the limit you can repay out of your annual income. In that bank's calculation, the guide to the amount I could borrow got about ¥5 million smaller!

A little over ¥20,000 a month, and ¥5 million. The balance alone looks small, but because the repayment period is short, the monthly repayment is surprisingly large. And that eats into the limit for a loan you repay over decades.

In the end, I paid off the rest of the revolving balance with cash on hand, and paid off in one lump sum the installment payments I could. That reduced the money I'd meant to keep after buying, and I felt uneasy for a while.

There are three things I want to tell the me of back then.

  • An app's "easier" only flattens your monthly payments; it doesn't reduce the amount you've borrowed
  • Treat card installments and revolving payments as part of "other borrowing" too
  • Don't press a button that changes your payment method on the spot; press it after looking at the fees and the month you'll finish paying

With my new glasses I could see even the fine print on my statement clearly, but the 2-character word for "revolving" was the one thing I didn't see. I'd like to blame the glasses, but blaming glasses still partway through their 12 installments felt a little too much!

(Updated 2026.10.18)

Read a little deeper