BENERU
Financing and interest ratesPublished

What changes between borrowing up to the limit and stopping at half?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. "Borrow while you can, as much as you can." A line you hear a lot in sales talk for investment loans. Good rhythm. What it says, honestly, is the same as "spare room is waste."

Let's sort out the spec. Three numbers move with how much you borrow. Cash left over = scale × (the share of rent − expenses − repayment). The hole in a bad month = scale × (repayment + expenses). Room for the next loan = limit − amount used. Look at the formulas and you see it. Double the scale, and the cash left over and the hole both double together. The only thing that shrinks is the room.

Let me put numbers on it. All assumptions. The limit a lender showed you is ¥40 million. You buy condominium units at ¥20 million each, with rent of ¥92,000 a month and a management fee plus repair reserve fund of ¥16,000 a month, fully financed at 2% over 35 years. The repayment is about ¥66,000 a month per unit.

Borrow up to the limit for 2 units, and the cash left over is about ¥19,000 a month, about ¥230,000 a year. At half, 1 unit, it's about ¥10,000 a month, about ¥120,000 a year. The limit side gets about ¥120,000 more a year.

What about a bad month? Say you have ¥3 million in cash on hand. In a month when everything is vacant, the payments are about ¥165,000 a month for 2 units, so the ¥3 million lasts about 18 months. For 1 unit, about ¥82,000 a month, so about 36 months. Go half, and the number of months you can hold out doubles. OK?

Then the room. Borrow to the limit, and the limit left at that point is zero. At half, ¥20 million of it remains. That's the difference in whether you can reach out when you want a home of your own, or when a better property comes up.

A bit tricky? Well, hang in there. Here I bite at my own formula. At half you have 1 unit, and when 1 unit goes vacant, it's all vacant. In a month when only 1 of 2 units is vacant, the out-of-pocket is about ¥73,000; in a month when the single unit is vacant, about ¥82,000. I mean, if you only look at months when one unit is vacant, the limit side is lighter. Holding more units spreads the swings. That's right, it is right — but that lightness assumes "they won't go vacant at the same time," and the hole in a fully vacant month is still double. That's the tricky part.

So there's no right answer between the limit and half. It's a matter of pricing whether you trade ¥120,000 a year of cash left over against 18 months of endurance and ¥20 million of room. The sales line doesn't write down this exchange rate. Get it?

When you hear your limit, try writing one sentence with your own numbers. "For ¥◯ a year of cash left over, I give up ◯ months of endurance and ¥◯ of my limit." Read it aloud and see whether you can nod along. Am I wrong?

With yudofu, if you cram the pot with tofu, the water goes lukewarm fast and the kombu broth doesn't circulate. It's because there's room in the water that the tofu sways and warms right to the center. Cram or leave space, that's up to taste, but check the size of the pot first. Ciao.

(Updated 2026.10.18)
Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. What changes between borrowing up to the limit and stopping at half is mainly three things: "the cash left over each month", "how long you can hold out in bad months", and "room to borrow next". Borrowing up to the limit increases the cash left over, but the shortfall at times of vacancy or rising interest rates grows in the same proportion, and almost none of the limit is left for the next loan. Which suits you depends on your cash on hand and whether you plan to borrow again.

Assumptions for the comparison (assumption)

ItemBorrow up to the limitStop at half
Loan amount (fully financed)¥30 million¥15 million
Rent (monthly)¥160,000¥80,000
Management fee, repair reserve fund, etc. (monthly)¥32,000¥16,000
Interest rate and term2.5%, 30 years2.5%, 30 years
Cash on hand¥2.5 million¥2.5 million

Annual income is ¥6 million, with no other borrowing. Taxes are not included.

The three differences

ItemBorrow up to the limitStop at half
Monthly repaymentabout ¥119,000about ¥59,000
Cash left over each monthabout ¥9,500 (about ¥114,000 a year)about ¥4,700 (about ¥57,000 a year)
Out-of-pocket in a month when all units are vacantabout ¥151,000about ¥75,000
How long cash on hand can hold outabout 16 monthsabout 33 months
If the interest rate rises to 3.5%a shortfall of about ¥6,700 a montha shortfall of about ¥3,400 a month

Stopping at half halves the cash left over and doubles how long you can hold out.

Room for the next loan

Take buying a home with Flat 35 as an example. The standard for the total debt-to-income ratio is 35% or less for an annual income of ¥4 million or more (as of April 1, 2026 (Reiwa 8)). This calculation also includes borrowing for housing that is being rented out (excluding loans for rental apartments such as a whole multi-unit building).

ItemBorrow up to the limitStop at half
Upper limit of annual repayments (¥6 million × 35%)¥2.1 million¥2.1 million
Annual repayments on the investment loanabout ¥1.422 millionabout ¥711,000
Remaining limitabout ¥678,000about ¥1.389 million
Guide to the amount you can borrow for a home (2%, 35 years)about ¥17 millionabout ¥34.9 million

How other borrowing is counted, including how rental income is treated, differs by lender.

Order of checks

  1. Write down the upper limit the lender showed you, and the interest rate and term at that time.
  2. For both the limit and half, calculate the cash left over each month and the out-of-pocket in a month when all units are vacant.
  3. Divide your cash on hand by the out-of-pocket amount to get the number of months you can hold out.
  4. Write down whether you plan any other borrowing within 5 years, such as buying a home, and compare it with the remaining limit.

From here on, this is my opinion

I think the upper limit is the amount a lender judged it could lend, not a target for how much to borrow. If you borrow up to the limit, you should check in numbers whether the added cash left over is worth the reduced endurance and the lost room. If you clearly plan to borrow again, I recommend setting aside that part of the limit first and then deciding on the scale.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.18)

Read a little deeper