BENERU
Financing and interest ratesPublished

What helps in a tough month — cash on hand, or a reduced loan balance?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. And, and, and here it comes: "The more you reduce debt, the safer you are." The classic of classics that comes up every time prepayment is the topic.

Let me say it up front. What helps in a tough month is almost entirely cash on hand.

The reason is simple: money you've repaid doesn't come back. Money you prepay reduces the balance in the bank's books, but you can't withdraw it at the end of the month and put it toward the water heater bill. On top of that, prepayment comes in a type that shortens the term and a type that reduces the monthly repayment. If you pick the term-shortening type, your monthly repayment doesn't change by even ¥1. Frankly, it's no help at all in a tough month. With me so far?

"The repayment-reducing type works, though, right?" Let's look at numbers. All assumptions. If you prepay ¥1.5 million on a loan at 2% with 25 years left, the monthly repayment gets lighter by about ¥6,400. And what's a tough month? Say a tenant moves out, the unit is empty for 2 months, and fixing up the unit and the advertising fee for finding a tenant pile on too, ¥400,000 going out all together. Trying to fill this ¥400,000 hole with ¥6,400 a month of lightness takes about 63 months. If you hold ¥1.5 million in cash, you can pay it that month and have ¥1.1 million left. This difference is for-real huge. Get it?

So, then.

If I end here with "so prepayment is pointless," that's just as sloppy as "the more you reduce, the safer." Let me pick up the other side too. What if the toughness isn't "one month" but "every month"? The pattern where rent goes down, interest rates go up, and the monthly income and expenses stay in the red. Cash gets cut away by that deficit every month and runs out someday. Prepayment of the repayment-reducing type keeps working every month until full repayment. For this kind of toughness, there are situations where reducing the balance suits better. Am I wrong?

"Didn't you just say cash, flat out?" Yep, I did. But let me add one more thing. Cash can be put toward prepayment later. But money you've prepaid can't be turned back into cash later. If you try to borrow again, there's screening, and it's harder to pass the tougher the period. The one-way ticket is the repayment. So while you're still unsure, the edge goes to keeping it in hand. Okay?

So what do you look at? Open your bankbook for the past year and mark the month when the property's expenses were the hardest. Was that a "big one-time expense," or a "slow, steady deficit every month"? If the former, thicken your cash; if the latter, consider the repayment-reducing type. Look at the face of what you're preparing for first.

Crabs, you know — the shelled meat can be eaten right away, but shelled meat can't go back into the shell. Leave them in the shell, and you get to choose when to eat. No need to rush and shell them all. Ciao.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.18)
Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. What helps with a sudden expense is cash on hand, and what lowers the monthly burden is prepayment of the repayment-reducing type. With the term-shortening type the monthly repayment does not change, so it is no help in a tough month. Which to prepare for depends on whether the "tough month" you have in mind is a one-time expense or a deficit that continues every month.

The 2 types of prepayment

TypeMonthly repaymentLoan term
Term-shortening typeDoes not changeBecomes shorter
Repayment-reducing typeBecomes smallerDoes not change

The minimum amount and fees differ by lender. For example, with the Japan Housing Finance Agency's individual housing loans, you can prepay without a fee from ¥1 million at a counter, or from ¥100,000 online.

Calculation

Assume a balance of ¥15 million, an interest rate of 2.5%, 20 years remaining, and own funds on hand of ¥3 million (these numbers are assumptions).

ChoiceMonthly repaymentInterest savedFunds on hand
No prepaymentabout ¥79,500―¥3 million
Repay ¥3 million with the term-shortening typeabout ¥79,500 (term shortened by about 4 years 10 months)about ¥1.65 million¥0
Repay ¥3 million with the repayment-reducing typeabout ¥63,600about ¥820,000¥0

The term-shortening type reduces interest more, but only the repayment-reducing type makes the monthly payment lighter.

Comparing by kind of "tough month"

Kind of toughness¥3 million of cash on handTerm-shortening typeRepayment-reducing type
A one-time expense (replacing equipment, restoration after a tenant leaves, etc.)Can be paid that monthNo effectA reduction of about ¥16,000 a month does not fill it right away
A deficit that continues every month (falling rent, rising variable rates, etc.). Assume a shortfall of ¥15,000 a monthRuns out in about 200 monthsNo effectA reduction of about ¥16,000 continues until full repayment and nearly fills the shortfall
Income from your main job falls or stopsCan also be used for living costsNo effectRepayment becomes lighter, but it cannot be used for living costs

Order of checks

  1. Check the balance, interest rate and remaining term in the loan agreement or repayment schedule.
  2. Estimate the amount you expect as a one-time expense (the cost of replacing equipment, repayments for several months of vacancy, etc.).
  3. Decide that amount first, as cash to keep on hand.
  4. If you put the rest toward prepayment, check the type, minimum amount and fees in the lender's guidance.

From here on, this is my opinion

"The smaller the loan balance, the safer" is not necessarily true. I think you should first set aside cash to prepare for one-time expenses, and consider the repayment-reducing type only for the amount beyond that, as preparation for monthly deficits. I think it is best to think of the term-shortening type separately, as an option for reducing interest rather than as preparation for tough months.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.18)

Read a little deeper