BENERU
Financing and interest ratesPublished

Is "once you've paid off the loan, you're safe" always right?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. If I grade that sentence, it gets 50 points. Up to "once you've paid off the loan," full marks; it goes off at "you're safe." That your debt becomes zero is true. Whether you become able to move when you're in trouble is a separate answer sheet.

First, let's look at who says these words. Usually it's parents or seniors, household-finance books, and the anxiety inside yourself. These people have something in common. Even if you do as they say and it turns out wrong, they lose nothing. The one who pays in the month the water heater breaks is you, not the person who said it. As for the lending side, if the money comes back early, the worry of a bad loan goes down, but the interest goes down too, so it's not as if they're cheering with both hands up. For investment loans, some places charge a fee for early repayment (it depends on the lender). In other words, nobody who says "once it's paid off you're safe" carries the responsibility if it turns out wrong. Am I wrong?

So, here's the real point.

All assumptions. Age 55, loan balance ¥8 million, interest rate 2% with 15 years remaining, monthly repayment about ¥51,500. Savings of ¥9 million. Repay the ¥8 million in one lump sum now, and the roughly ¥1.27 million of interest you would have paid disappears, and ¥51,500 a month is freed up. Zero debt, feels great, right? But the next day your bankbook shows ¥1 million.

Even if you save all of the ¥51,500 freed up, getting your savings back to ¥4 million takes about 58 months, nearly 5 years. What if, during those 5 years, you're off sick for half a year, or the roof needs repairs, or your child's school fees go up? If ¥1 million isn't enough, you have no choice but to borrow again. But for someone around 60, right after their income has dropped, finding somewhere to borrow at a low interest rate is, honestly, not easy. Even if you own a house, you can't split a house into small pieces to pay with. OK so far?

One more thing that's easy to overlook. Mortgages often come with group credit life insurance. The thing where the balance disappears if the borrower dies. Pay it off, and this protection disappears along with the debt. From the family's point of view, it's the same as canceling one insurance policy. For an investment property, the interest on the loan could be counted as an expense, so paying it off can increase the profit on the books and increase taxes.

Let me pick up the other side too. Paying off is not a bad move. Once there's no monthly repayment, spending really does get lighter when you're living on just a pension. You also get out from under the worry of interest rates rising. The ¥1.27 million of interest is like an insurance premium for keeping ¥9 million in hand, and some people don't need that insurance. Get it?

So what you look at isn't "when you'll pay it off" but "how much will be left on the day after you pay it off." Next to your repayment schedule, write the bankbook balance for the day after your planned payoff date. Decide whether to hurry based on how many months of living costs that is. There's also the way of repaying just half and keeping the rest in hand. Don't you think?

You know oden? Eating up all the ingredients is fine, but if you drink every drop of the broth, tomorrow you can't simmer even one daikon. If there's broth left in the pot, you can add ingredients again. Ciao.

(Updated 2026.10.18)
Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

This is Wang. These days there are young people who walk around wearing "zero debt" on their chest like a medal. Paying it all off is admirable. But a medal won't fix a roof, and it won't rebuild a collapsed house.

Let me turn the clock back. There was the Niigata Earthquake in 1964 (Showa 39), and prompted by it, the earthquake insurance system was created in 1966 (Showa 41). That's what the Ministry of Finance writes. It was around then that the state began facing, through a system, the obvious fact that a house breaks even without debt. Even today, earthquake insurance is something you take out attached to fire insurance, and the amount paid is set within a range of 30% to 50% of the fire insurance amount.

But even with a system, nothing starts if you haven't joined. In the Cabinet Office's review materials on the Great Hanshin-Awaji Earthquake, the household take-up rate for earthquake insurance in Hyogo Prefecture was a mere 2.9% in fiscal 1993 (Heisei 5). Then, in January 1995 (Heisei 7), that earthquake came. Houses that had been paid off and houses still being paid for collapsed alike.

After that, voices rose from the disaster areas, and in May 1998 (Heisei 10), the Act on Support for Reconstructing Livelihoods of Disaster Victims was created. At first, the amount paid was at most ¥1 million. With the 2004 (Heisei 16) revision it became at most ¥3 million, and even in the Cabinet Office's guidance as of October 2026 (Reiwa 8), it's up to ¥3 million for a household whose home was completely destroyed and is rebuilt. And this is money for rebuilding the livelihood of the household that lived there. To rebuild a whole house, it's nowhere near enough. The shortfall can only be filled with money on hand, insurance, or the ability to borrow once more.

The night I finished paying off my loan, I too went to open a jar of Shaoxing wine to celebrate. Then my wife plunked our bankbook down on the jar's lid. "The debt may be over, but the roof leak isn't. You open it once this balance has come back." In the end, that jar sat sealed in the kitchen until New Year's of the year after I'd finished paying the roofer. Kakakaka.

Back to the point. Having no debt means one fewer stream of money going out each month. Being able to move when you're in trouble means being able to pay even when money suddenly has to go out. On a night when nothing happens, the two look the same. You see the difference on the morning something breaks.

People don't change. But they can learn. Enjoying watching the balance go down is the same for me, and that won't change until I die. But you can learn to line up one more number beside the number you've reduced.

Try one thing. Take out your home insurance policy, write down the amount paid if it all burns down in a fire and the amount paid in an earthquake, and next to them, write how much it would likely cost to rebuild the same house now. If the gap is large, before putting money into early repayment, keep money aside to fill that gap.

Once you empty the sake jar, you have nothing to bring out for the next celebration. Leaving one cup's worth at the bottom is the etiquette of someone who drinks for a long time.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.18)

Read a little deeper