BENERU
Choosing and buying propertyPublished Updated

For investment, should I choose a studio unit or a family unit?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. It's backwards, backwards. You don't choose starting from the unit. You choose starting from who rents it.

Let me say it outright first. Studio or family unit isn't something decided by the owner's taste; it's something you let the people looking for a place at that station decide. Own a family unit at a station with lots of single people, or a studio at a station with lots of families, and even if the unit is well made, it's hard to fill.

Reason one: rent isn't proportional to size. Say a 25㎡ studio rents for ¥80,000 and costs ¥18 million, and a 65㎡ family unit rents for ¥140,000 and costs ¥39 million (both are assumptions). The gross yield is about 5.3% for the studio and about 4.3% for the family unit. The size is 2.6 times, but the rent is only 1.75 times.

And here's the real point. Costs follow size. For a condominium unit, the management fee and repair reserve fund are basically shared according to the unit's share of floor area. If it's ¥500 per ㎡ a month, the studio pays ¥12,500 a month and the family unit ¥32,500 a month. Per year, that's ¥150,000 and ¥390,000. Subtract these from the rent and the studio gets ¥810,000 a year, about 4.5% of the price, while the family unit gets ¥1.29 million a year, about 3.3%. Far from shrinking, the gap widens. How about it? Does that pay?

Well, there's a view that sides with the family unit too. Once a family moves in, they stay a long time, so there's less work finding tenants and less vacancy. It's right, it's right, but that's when "there are families at that station who rent." A family that can pay ¥140,000 a month is the kind that also thinks about buying at the same station. At a station where lots of people compare monthly repayments with rent and drift toward buying, only a teeny bit of renting families are left. Am I wrong?

So is a studio easy? Its weakness is the number of rivals. Around the station there are any number of units of similar size and similar layout. The older your unit gets, the more it gets lined up and compared with new ones. Having little to set yourself apart with is the painful part of studios.

So what you look at isn't the type of unit, it's what's in the station. Count the units currently being advertised at that station, studios and family units. How many units of about the same size are listed, and how long they take to disappear. Asking the property management company "which gets taken faster at this station?" is good too. If the answer isn't clear, that station doesn't have a strong deciding factor for either kind of unit. Get it?

An oden stall, you know, doesn't decide what to prep by whether daikon or beef tendon is classier. What goes in the pot is decided by what the customers passing by order.

Sources (in Japanese)

Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! Studio or family unit. When I chose my first unit, this was actually what I agonized over right up to the end.

There were two candidates. One was a 15-year-old studio a 5-minute walk from the station, for about ¥15 million. The other was a 20-year-old 2LDK a 12-minute walk from the same station, for about ¥28 million. Both were on sale with tenants in place.

Looking only at yield, the studio was higher. The rent was ¥70,000 for the studio and ¥120,000 for the 2LDK. Divided by the price, the studio was about 0.5 percentage points higher.

But when I talked to my father, he said, "Families stay a long time, you know." The apartment building my father took over from my grandfather has a 2DK unit, and the tenant there has lived there for more than 10 years. On the other hand, units for single people apparently often turn over in 2 to 3 years.

So I did the calculation including the cost of turnover. For the studio, a move-out every 3 years, each time with repair costs and 1 to 2 months of vacancy. For the 2LDK, a move-out once every 10 years; the repair costs are big, but there are fewer of them. Do it that way, and the gap in yield shrank a lot.

I also thought about when I'd sell. If the 2LDK is vacant, it can also be sold to a family who wants to live in it themselves. A studio can only be sold to people who invest.

So did I go with the 2LDK? In the end I chose the studio. The reason was the amount I'd borrow. A ¥28 million loan was too heavy for me back then. If a vacancy dragged on, the whole ¥120,000 of rent would stop. With the studio, even if it stopped, it would only be ¥70,000. I decided my first unit should be a size I could recover from even if it failed.

In fact, my studio now has had its tenants turn over 2 times since I've owned it. Just as my father said. But each time, the next person was found in about 1 month, so it's working out.

There are 3 things I'd like to tell the me of back then.

  • Compare not just yield, but also include how often tenants turn over and what it costs
  • Think about whether, when you sell, it can also be sold to people who'll live in it
  • Make your first unit a size you can recover from even if it fails

The tenant in the 2DK at my father's apartment building has apparently renewed again. My father takes a box of sweets every time they renew! Maybe I'll take something to the landlord in Koiwa too!

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper