BENERU
Choosing and buying propertyPublished Updated

How can I tell a good real estate investment company from a bad one?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. Being able to honestly write that you can't tell the difference — that's a good eye. Companies selling investment property all look about the same, brochure photos and sales talk alike. You can't tell them apart not because your eyes are bad, but because they're actually made to look alike. But still, you're a bit soft.

Let me bite. The moment you try to judge whether a company is good or bad, you're already one step off target. The same company can easily be the seller on one property and the broker on another. Even if you score the company, it won't tell you which face it's wearing in the deal in front of you.

No, I'm not saying looking at the company is pointless. Whether it has a license, whether it has a record of administrative action — checking that does no harm. It's right, it's right — but that only confirms "does it clear the minimum line," and it doesn't answer good or bad. Don't you think?

But of course, this is where the real point starts. What you should look at isn't the company, it's where the other side stands in this deal. Licensed real estate brokers have a rule to show the transaction type, meaning whether they're the seller, an agent, or acting as an intermediary (brokerage). That's the thing written small in the corner of the ad.

If they're the seller, there's no brokerage commission. Instead, the company's profit is the gap between the purchase cost and the selling price, and that gap is dissolved into the price where you can't see it. If it's brokerage, the fee has a cap set by a national notice. For a deal where the price exceeds ¥4 million, the cap is 3% of the price plus ¥60,000 (excluding tax). But they don't get a single yen unless the deal closes, so there's pressure to get it done. If they're an agent, the cap is up to 2 times the amount calculated for brokerage. With me so far?

The tricky bit is you can't say which one is good and which one is bad. Not every seller company sells at an inflated price, and being a broker doesn't mean neutral either. Still, where the money comes in from decides what the other side will want to push. A seller will want to avoid talking about what's inside the price, and a broker will want to say "you have to decide now." Right?

So the way to check is simple. First ask, "On this property, are you the seller, or the broker?" If they say they're the seller, ask one more thing. "If I wanted to let go of this unit next month, how much would you buy it back for?" How far apart the selling price and the buyback price are gives you an idea of how wide the margin dissolved into the price is. If they dodge the answer, seriously, that's an answer too.

You know fragrant olive — from the scent you can tell right away that autumn's here, but you can't tell which tree it's coming from unless you get close. Shimeji mushrooms are the same. The front of the pack all looks the same, but flip it over and look at the base and each one is different. Don't look at the sign. Look at the back of this one pack.

(Updated 2026.10.15)
Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Young people these days decide whether a company is good or bad by the number of stars in online reviews. Have you ever thought about who's giving those stars? If you ask me, there's something to look at before the stars.

What I remember is that when I'd only just come to Japan, even to rent one room I had no choice but to swallow whatever the agent told me. I wanted to look into it, but I had nothing to go on. But the systems that give you something to go on were piling up little by little. According to Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism material, the Building Lots and Buildings Transaction Business Act (Takken Gyōhō) was enacted in 1952 (Showa 27), and at that time it was a registration system for businesses. That first law already included prohibitions such as not disclosing facts. In 1964 (Showa 39) it changed from registration to licensing, and you could no longer do business without a license from a minister or a governor. That's where the era of "put up a sign and anyone's a broker" ended.

But a license is only a ticket at the entrance. Telephone solicitation for investment condominiums became a problem, and from October 1, 2011 (Heisei 23), the enforcement regulations prohibited soliciting without stating the company name or the purpose of the solicitation, continuing to solicit after being refused, and calling or visiting at inconvenient hours. In the ministry's practice, 9 p.m. to 8 a.m. is treated as the guide for inconvenient hours. Turn that around, and it means that until then, calls where they didn't give their name, and calls that kept coming after you refused, weren't clearly prohibited.

My wife is better at taking these calls than I am. She asks first, "Who is this, and what is it about?" and if the name is vague, she hangs up with "I can't talk with someone who can't give their name." When I said, "Hear them out a little more," she came back with, "Would you buy green onions from a greengrocer who won't tell you his name?" I had nothing to say.

Now. In 1952 (Showa 27) they wrote "don't hide the facts," and yet nearly 60 years later they had to add: give your name, stop when refused, don't call at night. Times change, but people's habits don't. The side that wants to sell wants to push, and the side listening finds it hard to refuse. The law has been patched on, chasing those habits from behind.

So the quick way to judge good or bad is whether they keep to the lowest line the law sets, even where nobody's watching. Small rules, more than big promises.

There's one thing to do. When you're solicited, first make them tell you the company name, the name of the person in charge, and the license number, and then say clearly, once, "I have no intention of signing a contract." A company that calls again even after that is a company that casually does what has been prohibited since 2011 (Heisei 23). If you learn that, the call was useful after all.

To a long relationship with people who keep the rules. Cheers.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper