BENERU
Selling and exitPublished Updated

When selling a property, which is better, a general brokerage agreement or an exclusive brokerage agreement?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. General or exclusive, which is better? ...What's this? I mean, as a question it's perfectly fair, but I make the same face as when someone asks me "a taxi or a bus, which is better?" You haven't told me where you're going or what you're carrying.

So I go back to the formula. A condominium unit selling for ¥20 million, as a hypothetical number. The upper limit on the brokerage commission for a sale is 3% for the part of the price above ¥4 million, and roughly you can work it out as "price × 3% + ¥60,000." For ¥20 million that's ¥660,000 (consumption tax not included). That's the upper limit they can receive from the seller. And here's the crux. This upper limit is "per party to the request," so if the same firm also finds the buyer, it gets ¥660,000 from the buyer too. ¥1.32 million in total.

Let's compare. If another firm brings a buyer at ¥20.5 million, the firm only gets the seller's side: ¥20.5 million × 3% + ¥60,000 = ¥675,000. If its own client buys at ¥19.5 million, ¥19.5 million × 3% + ¥60,000 = ¥645,000 comes in from both sides, for ¥1.29 million. The deal that's ¥1 million higher for the seller is the deal that's ¥615,000 less for the firm. Seriously, put it in a formula and that's what you get.

Did you just think, "Then exclusive is scary because of withholding the listing (kakoikomi), so let's go with general"? Hold on a second. General brokerage has a formula too. If you ask several firms, each firm gets zero if it doesn't sell, and zero if another firm beats it to it. So what pays best for each firm is closing quickly, even if it means lowering the price a little. The formula where early price-cut proposals tend to come is this one. Well? Does that add up for you?

It's right, the point that exclusive comes with the danger of withholding the listing is right, but that doesn't mean general is fine. Both kinds of contract have a force pulling in a different direction from the seller. Only the direction differs.

To put the answer to the question simply: which is better isn't decided by the type of contract. It's decided by whether the seller uses the monitoring tools that come with that type. With exclusive and exclusive-and-sole brokerage agreements, the law sets registration with the designated real estate information network (within 7 days for exclusive, within 5 days for exclusive-and-sole, excluding non-business days) and reports at least once every 2 weeks for exclusive and at least once every 1 week for exclusive-and-sole, and the term is up to 3 months. General brokerage has no such obligations, but in exchange you can line up several firms' activity and compare it. Get it?

So what you look at is the content of the reports. Whether they list "inquiries from other firms: X, viewings: X, applications: X." If inquiries from other firms stay at zero the whole time, either the property is weak or word isn't getting out. Even if it's maybe the former, just knowing that lets you talk about pricing. With general brokerage, have each firm submit its report in the same format and line them up side by side. Am I wrong?

You know lotus root — it has lots of holes, so you can see through to the other side. A sale contract is the same: if you're handed a solid lump with no holes, you can't see inside. Have them open holes called reports, peek through to the other side, and then decide the price. Ciao.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.14)
Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Kakakaka. Which is better, general or exclusive, you ask? It hasn't even been half a century since those two names were put in order in law.

Let me tell an old story. According to material from the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism, the 1980 (Showa 55) revision of the Building Lots and Buildings Transaction Business Act (Takken Gyōhō) put the rules for exclusive brokerage and general brokerage in order, and set things such as putting the contract in writing. But the systems for brokers to share information on properties for sale were still scattered, and the material says that in 1987 (Showa 62) there were 106 distribution organizations crowding the country. So the 1988 (Showa 63) revision created a new type, exclusive-and-sole brokerage, and made registering properties with a designated real estate information network mandatory. In 1990 (Heisei 2), 37 designated real estate information networks were launched across the country. The 1995 (Heisei 7) revision clearly positioned the designated real estate information networks in law, and the obligation to register properties under exclusive brokerage and the obligation to give the client a document showing the registration were written into the articles. In 2016 (Heisei 28), a function to manage the status of properties was added to that system.

Let me talk about Shaoxing wine. In Shaoxing, I've heard, there was a custom of filling a jar with wine when a daughter was born, burying it in the ground, and digging it up to serve on the day she married. It's called nü'erhong. When and in front of whom to open a jar aged for years is decided by the family. Gaoliang liquor, on the other hand, is made by fermenting sorghum and distilling it. With strong liquor, if you don't decide how much to pour yourself, the liquor drinks you instead.

Line up the changes over these more than 40 years, and one thread comes into view. The law has given brokers heavier homework the more a contract entrusts everything to one firm. In 1980 (Showa 55), put the contract on paper; in 1988 (Showa 63), put the property on the brokers' network; in 1995 (Heisei 7), give the seller proof that it was put on that network. It advanced one step at a time. For a seller who has entrusted one firm, it's hard to see what's happening in the broker's hands. As I see it, the law has opened windows in that wall you can't see through, one pane at a time.

What sets today's seller apart from a seller of the Showa era is that those windows arrive in your hands as paper. A seller in the Showa era had almost no way to know how their property was circulating among brokers. Under today's law, a broker entrusted under exclusive or exclusive-and-sole brokerage that has registered with a designated real estate information network must give the client a document certifying the registration without delay. What gets registered is also written in the law: location, size, physical characteristics, asking price and so on. If you receive that paper and put it away, envelope and all, it's like having a window opened for you and then drawing the curtains.

So if you entrust one firm, first check that the document has arrived. Once it has, put it next to the brokerage agreement and check, one by one, whether the registration date is within the required number of days from the contract, and whether the location, size and asking price are listed as discussed.

Well then, to the day you open the jar. The one who sets the price of what you're selling is your own hand. Cheers.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.14)

Read a little deeper