BENERU
Selling and exitPublished Updated

Why is a broker's appraisal so different from a company's buyout price?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. A broker's appraised value and a buyout price are different prices for different transactions. The appraised value is the price at which the broker expects the property can be sold to an individual buyer, and it is not a fixed price. The buyout price is the price at which a company buys the property on the spot. It is not unnatural for there to be a difference.

How the two transactions differ

ItemBrokerageBuyout
BuyerA third party, such as an individualA real estate company
How the price is decidedDecided only once a buyer is foundDecided at the amount the company offers
Time until soldUnknown until a buyer is foundShort
Brokerage commissionChargedNot charged when the company buys directly
Seller's liabilityDepends on the contractOften a special clause exempting liability is attached

A buyout company resells the property after buying it, for example by rebuilding or renovating it. The amount after deducting those costs and its profit becomes the buyout price.

The appraised value is an "opinion"

Article 34-2, paragraph 2 of the Building Lots and Buildings Transaction Business Act (Takken Gyōhō) states that when a licensed real estate broker, in concluding a brokerage agreement, gives an opinion on the price at which the property should be sold, it must make clear the basis for that opinion. The appraised value is an "opinion" whose basis should be explained. Even if a high appraised value comes out, it is not a promise that the property will sell at that amount.

Brokerage commission

When the property is sold through brokerage, there is a cap on the remuneration a licensed real estate broker can receive. For the part of the sale price over ¥4 million, it is 3.3% (including tax). In the simplified calculation, it is "sale price × 3% + ¥60,000" plus consumption tax.

  • Cap when sold for ¥12 million: (¥12 million × 3% + ¥60,000) × 1.1 = ¥462,000
  • For land and buildings with a sale price of ¥8 million or less, under a special provision, the cap can be raised to 1.1 times ¥300,000 (¥330,000), taking into account the costs required for brokerage (effective July 1, 2024 (Reiwa 6)).

Seller's liability

Even with the special clause often used in buyouts stating that the seller does not bear liability (liability for non-conformity with the contract (keiyaku futekigō sekinin)), the seller is not released from liability for facts the seller knew of but did not disclose (Civil Code Article 572).

Order of checks

  1. For the broker's appraised value, ask to be shown its basis in writing, such as the comparable transactions used.
  2. Calculate what you would actually receive if it sold at the appraised value, after deducting the brokerage commission and other costs.
  3. Compare it with the buyout price, and decide by when you need to sell.
  4. For a buyout, check in the contract the scope of the special clause exempting liability.

From here on, this is my opinion

I think what you should compare is not the appraised value and the buyout price, but the expected proceeds from brokerage and the proceeds from a buyout. Then decide based on how much time you can spend until the sale.

Sources (in Japanese)

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. The question "Can there really be this big a difference?" — if I grade it, it's half right and half off. That there's a difference is right. What's off is thinking the ¥12 million one is "the real price."

Let me bite first. ¥12 million — who came up with that number? The broker, right? A broker's work doesn't start unless the seller hands them the job. And sellers usually want to hand it to whoever gives the highest number. In other words, the broker side has a reason to give a high-ish appraisal. Mixed into the ¥12 million may be not only "the price it can sell for" but also "the price for getting the job." You know?

Wait a sec, I think to myself too. That makes the broker sound like the bad guy. No, well, not really. The same logic works on the ¥3 million buyout too. The company earns more the cheaper it buys, so it has a reason to come in low. One who comes in high, one who comes in low. Both are putting out numbers for their own convenience. So there's no point agonizing over "which one is right." Get it?

But well, of course, here's the real point. If both have their own convenience mixed in, then bring in one number that has no one's convenience in it.

Before that, let's work backward. All of this is an assumption. If it really is a home that sells to an individual for ¥12 million, say the company, after buying it, spends ¥2 million on renovation, ¥1 million on expenses like taxes, registration and brokerage commission, and ¥500,000 on interest and upkeep for the few months until it sells, and wants to keep ¥1.5 million as profit. ¥12 million − ¥2 million − ¥1 million − ¥500,000 − ¥1.5 million means it could buy for up to ¥7 million. And it offered ¥3 million. Then you'd ask, what's the ¥4 million difference? Either the ¥12 million is optimistic to begin with, or the company's view is pretty harsh — it's one of the two.

So let's check which. On the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's Real Estate Information Library, look at what similar properties nearby actually traded for. If those are close to ¥12 million, there's a suspicion the ¥3 million buyout is too cheap. If they're close to ¥3 million, then ¥12 million was a dream price. While you're at it, get one more buyout estimate from a different company, and you'll know whether ¥3 million is the market rate or a number from that one company only. Am I wrong?

It's not which one is right, it's which one is padding its own convenience, and by how much. Once you can see that, you won't be thrown around by the size of the difference. Honestly, lining up two numbers with no yardstick to compare them is the biggest waste.

You know burdock root — it's priced completely differently with the dirt on and washed. But inside, it's the same root. The price tag just changes depending on who pays for the work of getting the dirt off. First, brush off a little of the dirt with your own hands.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper