BENERU
Financing and interest ratesPublished

Credit I didn't use — how many years later, and where, has it disappeared to?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. When I crossed the sea from Manchuria to this country, all I had in hand were the clothes I was wearing and one small bottle of kaoliang liquor my mother had sent with me. My name over there counted for nothing here. The amount I could borrow was zero. I worked, trust built up bit by bit, and at last I was told, "We can lend to you." For me, credit was something that builds up afterward, and then shrinks again with the years.

What I remember is a drinking friend, an employee, saying at his 60th birthday celebration, "That's the end of working for me." The line for the working years has since shifted back, little by little. From April 2006 (Heisei 18), employers were required to take steps such as raising the mandatory retirement age to 65 in stages or introducing a continued employment system. In April 2013 (Heisei 25), an amendment took effect abolishing the arrangement that let labor-management agreements narrow down who is covered by continued employment. From April 2021 (Reiwa 3), securing work opportunities up to age 70 became an obligation of effort for employers.

But the line on the borrowing side, it seems to me, hasn't moved along with it. In the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's survey for fiscal 2025 (Reiwa 7), 98.4% of institutions look at age at full repayment in home loan screening, and 96.1% look at health. In the item on age at full repayment, the most common answer from institutions was "under 80." The Japan Housing Finance Agency's group credit life insurance, too, can be joined only under age 70, and coverage lasts until the last day of the month of your 80th birthday.

Where does credit you didn't use disappear to? One is the years. Since the ceiling is fixed, while you hesitate, the period you can borrow for will eventually be shaved off a year at a time. The other is the body. Get flagged for one thing at a health checkup, and your answers on the group credit life insurance declaration change. Changing employers or taking on other debt also reduces it. All of these shrink silently while you hesitate.

When I was young, at a celebration where an old jar of Shaoxing wine was being opened, I put on airs — "I'll save it for tomorrow's pleasure" — and went home without drinking. But the next night, hung over from drinking too much at another place, not a drop would go down my throat. When I showed up on the third day, the jar was empty. Kakakaka. The wine I had saved didn't wait for me.

Now then. Don't misunderstand me. Deciding not to use it is a fine choice. If you borrow, you shoulder the duty to repay and the worry over months when the rent stops. All I want to say is that the choice not to use it also comes with a deadline. Not using it while knowing the deadline, and finding it had vanished without your knowing — even with the same "didn't use it," the substance is completely different.

People don't change. But they can learn. My habit of putting things off won't be cured until I die. But writing "by when" on paper is something I can learn.

On your next birthday, write on the first page of your notebook the number you get by subtracting your age from 80, and the number you get by subtracting your age from 70. They give a rough idea of how many years are left until the ceiling on the years you can borrow and repay, and until the cutoff age for joining group credit life insurance. Upper limits differ by lender, so when you're ready to borrow, rewrite them with those numbers.

Well then, a toast to the wine you leave undrunk, knowing the deadline.

Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! That's exactly me too. I've been unsure for 4 years now whether to buy a second property. 38 years old, living in a rental in Koiwa, and all I own is 1 second-hand condominium unit.

And while I was hesitating, my credit almost vanished to a place I hadn't decided on myself.

Last spring, at a standing soba shop in front of the station, the 2 people next to me were saying, "The No. 1 town in the most-desirable-places-to-live ranking really is nice, huh." On the way home I looked up the ranking, and in the No. 1 town a second-hand condominium was listed for ¥30 million. Before I knew it, I'd gone to view it on the weekend, and the next week I'd submitted a home loan preliminary screening. If it's No. 1, I can't go wrong, I figured. I completely forgot to ask myself, "What about the second investment property?"

The preliminary screening passed. And then the person in charge asked me, "Are you also considering a second investment property?"

So we calculated together. The yardstick was the Flat 35 criteria. With an annual income of ¥4 million or more, annual repayments on all borrowing must be 35% or less of annual income. This calculation also includes the loan on the condominium unit I rent out to someone. Assuming an annual income of ¥5.5 million and 1.0% over 35 years, the limit is ¥1.925 million a year. The first property's repayment is about ¥876,000 a year, and the ¥30 million loan's repayment is about ¥1.016 million a year. Together that's about ¥1.892 million, leaving just over ¥30,000 a year. By this yardstick, the second property is almost zero! Screening for investment loans also looks at rental income, so in reality it depends on the bank.

While I was hesitating, I thought, "I'm not using it, so my credit is still all there." Wrong. While I left its use undecided, a ranking almost decided it for me.

In the end, I didn't buy that unit. I withdrew the preliminary screening, and what remained was the train fare for the viewing and 2 weekends completely gone. The person in charge saw me off with a smile.

Don't get me wrong — it's not that buying a home is a mistake. Owning a home in the town you want to live in is a fine use all by itself. Not buying a second property is a proper choice too. It's just that credit can't be used for everything at once; use it on one thing and something else disappears. And while I hesitated for 4 years, I got 4 years older. Not deciding has a deadline too.

3 things I'd tell myself back then.

  • "The town everyone wants to live in" and "where I want to use my credit" are separate questions to answer
  • Before submitting a preliminary screening, calculate how much that borrowing reduces your other limits
  • If you're going to hesitate, decide first "until what year you'll hesitate"

The other day at the greengrocer in the Koiwa shopping street, the guy said to me, "Hey kid, you stop at the same spot every week." 5 minutes every week deciding whether to get half a napa cabbage or a whole one. I'm a man who's been hesitating 4 years over how to use his credit — at least let me hesitate over cabbage!

Sources (in Japanese)

Read a little deeper