BENERU
Cash flow and yieldsPublished Updated

A vacant unit hasn't been filled for 3 months. Should I lower the rent?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. When a unit sits empty for 3 months, young people immediately ask, "Should I lower it?" I'm the type who'd duck my head and wait 6 months, so I can't talk big. But I do feel like grumbling a word: before you lower it, know how long the lowered price will stay put. Ka-ka-ka-ka.

Let me turn the clock back. On March 1, 2000 (Heisei 12), the fixed-term lease system took effect. According to the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's explanation, with an ordinary lease the contract is renewed unless there is a justifiable reason, and either party can demand an increase or decrease in rent regardless of any special clause. A fixed-term building lease ends when its term comes, there is no renewal, and increases or decreases in rent follow what the special clause provides. From that day, landlords had a way to set the term and the method of deciding rent by contract.

More than 20 years have passed since then. In the Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications' 2023 (Reiwa 5) Housing and Land Survey, of 9 million vacant homes, about 4.43 million are for rent. From the renter's side, it's an age when towns are overflowing with units to choose from.

Here's my view. With an ordinary lease, assume that rent once lowered will hardly move until the next tenant leaves. Even if you want to raise it back, it turns into a dispute unless the other side says yes. So lowering the rent after 3 months of vacancy isn't about those 3 months; it's about the next however many years.

Once, on a hungover morning, I asked the liquor shop for a delivery. My head felt like it would split, and I only said to the young fellow on the phone, "The usual." What arrived was a dozen 1.8-liter bottles. Apparently, drunk the night before, I'd said, "Next time, make it a dozen." It would have looked bad to send them back, so I just accepted them. For 6 months, my wife glared at me every time I walked past the shelf. Nothing stays with you longer than a word said when you're weak.

Back to the topic. Even when times change, people's habits don't. When a vacancy drags on, people want relief fast, so they reach for the easiest tool to understand, namely the rent. There are more kinds of contracts than in the old days, yet the tool people pick up is always the same one.

So, before lowering it, ask the property management company one thing. How much difference in inquiries is likely between listing it on an ordinary contract with lowered rent, and listing it on a fixed-term building lease with a set term at close to the current rent? Some renters dislike fixed-term leases, so the answer could go either way. Even so, rent lowered after comparing carries a different weight from rent lowered out of fear.

An empty unit just doesn't produce rent; it won't eat me. Nobody dies from 3 months of vacancy. Steel yourself, compare, and then decide.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.15)
Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! A vacancy of 3 months — I've been through it too. Every day I looked at my unit's listing on the portal sites, my heart pounding over whether inquiries would go up. Every time I got word that a viewing was booked I was thrilled, and every time I heard it didn't work out I was crushed. In those 3 months, I think I went through more emotional ups and downs than anyone!

My unit's rent was ¥80,000. After the previous tenant left, it wasn't filled for 3 months. The property management company said, "I think it'll be filled if you lower it by ¥5,000," but I didn't want to. I mean, that's a whole ¥60,000 less a year! I decided to wait until it was filled at ¥80,000.

So I did the math. If I lowered it by ¥5,000 and the next tenant stayed 4 years, the loss would be ¥5,000 × 48 months = ¥240,000. On the other hand, if I kept it at ¥80,000 and it stayed vacant 3 more months, the loss would be ¥80,000 × 3 months = ¥240,000. The same! If it stayed vacant longer than 3 more months, lowering it would leave more in hand.

In the end, I waited 2 more months after that, it still wasn't filled, and I lowered it. Once I lowered it, it was filled in 2 weeks. The rent for the 2 months I waited, even counted at the lowered rent, was ¥150,000. That never came back. Even now I wonder what I was waiting for during those 2 months.

But there's one more thing I noticed. Lowering the rent also affects the price when you sell the unit. Investment units are often priced from their rent, so if rent drops by ¥60,000 a year and it's valued at a 5% yield, it works out to being valued ¥1.2 million cheaper (that's an assumption!). So instead of the rent itself, I should have compared, with the property management company, options like making the first few months' rent free, or raising the advertising fee to the brokerage firm that finds tenants.

There are three things I'd like to tell the me of back then.

  • Compare lowering and waiting by how many months of vacancy would make them equal
  • Before lowering the rent, compare it with making the first rent free or raising the advertising fee
  • If you're going to wait, decide "until when" first

By the way, I heard the tenant who took it said at the viewing, "At this price, I'll decide on the spot." I thought, you could've said that 2 months ago! But 2 months ago, it wasn't at that price, was it. Yep!

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper