BENERU
Management and operationPublished

What am I paying for with the fee I pay a rental management company?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. The management commission you pay a rental management company is payment for acting on your behalf in collecting and remitting rent, handling inquiries and complaints from tenants, dealing with equipment breakdowns, and handling procedures such as lease renewals and move-outs. Both the rate and which tasks are included differ from one management contract to another, and costs such as tenant recruitment may be billed separately.

Tasks often included in the management commission

TaskDetails
Collecting and remitting rentReceives rent from tenants, deducts the management fee and so on, and remits the rest to the owner
Handling arrearsSending payment reminders and dealing with the guarantee company
Tenant supportTaking inquiries, complaints and reports of equipment breakdowns, and arranging contractors
Lease renewals and move-outsRenewal procedures, attending move-out inspections, estimates for restoration (when tenants leave)
Regular reportsReporting income and expenses and the condition of the property to the owner

Tasks that often cost extra

TaskDetails
Recruiting tenantsBrokerage commission and advertising costs
Repair and restoration workThe cost of the work itself
Renewal administration feeMay be charged separately when a lease is renewed

Rules under the Act on Proper Rental Housing Management Operations

Rental housing management businesses that manage 200 or more units must be registered with the Minister of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism. Registered businesses are required to do the following.

ItemDetails
Explanation of important mattersBefore concluding a management contract, explain the scope of the work, the fees and so on in writing
Segregated management of assetsManage rent and other money received from tenants separately from the business's own assets
Regular reportsReport regularly to the owner on how the management work has been carried out

Order of checks

  1. In the management contract, check the scope of the tasks included in the management commission.
  2. Get a list of the costs charged separately for recruitment, renewals and move-outs.
  3. Check whether the management company is registered as a rental housing management business.
  4. Check how often regular reports are made and what they contain.

From here on, this is my opinion

When comparing management companies, I think you should compare not the rate of the management commission but the tasks included in that rate plus the total of the costs charged separately. Even if the rate is low, a lot of separate costs can make the annual payments larger instead.

Sources (in Japanese)

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Young people these days remember the money they pay a management company as a rate, "such-and-such % of the rent," and think that means they understand it. A rate is only a price tag. Many can't say what the price tag is for. If you ask me, that money is a substitute for work landlords used to do with their own feet and hands.

What I remember is the days when the landlord of a rental house would go around knocking on tenants' doors at the end of the month to collect the rent, and if told there was a water leak, would run off himself to call a tradesman. This is in the numbers too. According to material from the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism, in the Government Housing Loan Corporation's survey of the rental housing market at the time, in fiscal 1992 (Heisei 4) 75.0% of landlords did all of the management themselves, and 25.0% left it to a business. In the questionnaire survey of fiscal 2019 (Reiwa 1), landlords doing it all themselves were 18.5%, and those leaving it to others were 81.5%. In about 30 years, it turned upside down.

As more landlords left it to others, the uneven skill of those being entrusted became a problem. So in December 2011 (Heisei 23), the government started a registration system for rental housing management businesses by public notice. But it was a voluntary system where only those who wanted to register did so. Then in June 2020 (Reiwa 2) it was promulgated as a law, and from June 2021 (Reiwa 3) registration became mandatory for businesses of a certain size. From a voluntary list to the binding of law took 10 years.

Let me talk about Shaoxing wine. Shaoxing wine is aged in jars. The brewery looks after the jars, watches the temperature where they are kept, and lets the years pile up. But the brewery doesn't decide the taste for you. Whether it's a 3-year or a 10-year wine, which jar to open, is decided by the one who drinks. Kaoliang liquor is the same. The kaoliang you drink in a Manchurian winter is strong enough to burn your throat, but which strength to choose is up to the drinker. What you leave to the brewery is the labor, not your tongue. Kakakaka.

Back to the point. What you buy with the management commission is the landlord's labor and time. The feet that run to collect rent, the ears that answer the phone in the middle of the night. That, you really can have taken off your hands. But what the 1992 (Heisei 4) landlord saw with his own eyes, the feel of which room's tenant lived what kind of life and which wall was starting to wear, can't be bought with money. However much you hand over, that much slips out of the landlord's hands. It's also the landlord who makes the final decision on how much to set the rent, and whether to repair or not.

People don't change. But they can learn. When you hand it over, it gets easier. When it gets easier, you stop looking. Up to that point, the Heisei landlord and the Reiwa landlord are the same. Learning means keeping one place you look at yourself, even after you've handed things over.

Just one word for the young ones. When you read the report that comes from the management company, write back at least one question, even just one. As long as answers keep coming back, it's still your property.

Read a little deeper