BENERU
Basics and getting startedPublished Updated

When do people regret starting real estate investment?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Tonight I'm having a 5-year-old Shaoxing wine. Some liquor mellows as it ages, and some turns sour as it ages. You don't know until you open it — and regret is the same. Regret usually seeps in a few years after you buy.

Let me tell a slightly old story. On March 28, 2019 (Heisei 31), the National Consumer Affairs Center of Japan issued a warning about investment condominiums involving young people. The complaints the center received from people in their 20s had grown from 160 in fiscal 2013 (Heisei 25) to 405 in fiscal 2018 (Heisei 30) (as of the end of February 2019 (Heisei 31)), about 2.5 times. The total number was falling, yet only the young people's share was rising. Reading the contents, the examples line up: signed the contract because the persistent solicitation was frightening; bought because they were told the rent was promised, and are now in the red; made false declarations to the bank as the dealer told them, took out a loan, and became unable to pay. And it says many of the complaints came after the contract had already been signed.

Less than two years after that, on December 15, 2020 (Reiwa 2), the sublease rules in the Act on Proper Rental Housing Management Operations came into effect. Under the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's guidelines, if you advertise with words that easily mislead, such as promising rent, you must write, right next to them, that the rent is reviewed periodically and that it can be reduced under the Act on Land and Building Leases. Before the contract, you must explain in writing that the rent can fall. Read in reverse, it means that until then, there were people who sold without saying that, and people who learned it after buying and regretted it. In my reading, the regrets piled up and became rules.

When I told my wife this story, she said, "Just like the rice cooker you bought." The shop clerk told me, "This one machine can do everything," so I bought it, and in the end I've only ever cooked rice in it. "It can do everything" wasn't a lie. I just never opened the manual. Ka-ka-ka-ka, my wife still brings up the cooker from 30 years ago.

Back to the point. Put these two events side by side, and most regret comes not at the moment you lose money, but at the moment you realize "I wasn't told." The rent falls, you can't pay the loan, you want to quit but can't. All of it was written, where it was written. You put your seal on it without reading, or without being made to read. People don't change. But they can learn. What young people regretted at the end of Heisei is left on paper as the rules of Reiwa. For those who read, their predecessors' regrets come free.

Now, what to do. Before you put your seal on it, ask the seller this: "If I put this room up for sale the day after buying it, how much would it sell for?" The difference from the purchase price is the unrealized loss you carry from that day. If they dodge the question, have a different real estate company look at the sale price of the same room. The question is whether, knowing that difference, you still want to buy.

Regret won't kill you. But regretting with knowledge makes the liquor taste better than regretting without it.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.15)
Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! Times I've had regrets — I've got lots. But the one that hit hardest wasn't when I lost money.

The very first regret came right after I bought. I bought trusting, just as it was, the income and expense simulation the person in charge gave me. It assumed full occupancy for 35 years and rent unchanged for 35 years. Looking at it now I have to laugh, but back then I thought that was normal. When I lowered the rent in my second year, I looked back at the simulation sheet and realized, "This was never reality from the start."

The next regret was when I ran out of cash in hand. I'd put in too big a down payment, and hardly any savings were left. Right then the water heater broke, and replacing it cost somewhere over ¥100,000. I could pay it, but that month was really tight. Having a property but no money was a strange feeling. Rent comes in every month, yet my wallet was cold. On the books I had an asset, but there was no money I could use.

But the regret that hit hardest was something else. One night, while the numbers were running fine, a tenant called: "The floor above is noisy." Another call that week, and again the next week. The property management company stepped in, but I couldn't settle down the whole time. I was supposed to be making money, but it wasn't fun at all.

Thinking about it later, everything I regretted was not "something I didn't know" but "something I hadn't thought about." Rent falling, equipment breaking, trouble with tenants — anyone knows about those if they ask. But I hadn't thought that they would happen to me.

There are three things I'd like to tell the me of back then.

  • Rebuild the dealer's simulation yourself for the cases where rent falls and vacancy continues
  • Even after the down payment, keep enough cash in hand to pay for equipment breakdowns
  • Think not only about the numbers, but also about whether you can put up with the phone calls and the trouble

By the way, the cause of the noise upstairs was dance practice the upstairs tenant had started. I hear they keep it to weekends now! In my own place in Koiwa, I can hear the neighbor's TV pretty clearly, though!

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper