BENERU
Basics and getting startedPublished Updated

My family is against my real estate investment. How do I persuade them?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Young people these days, when their family objects, right away start thinking about "how to talk them around." Your family isn't someone to talk around. They're the people who may end up in the mud with you when you fail. Let's look at what that mud is made of, through how the rules have changed.

Let me turn the clock back. When someone borrows money, a relative or acquaintance stamps their seal and promises to pay in their place if they can't. A pamphlet the Ministry of Justice put out in March 2018 (Heisei 30) carries an example of someone who made that promise for a friend's business debt, was asked for ¥100 million after the friend went bankrupt, and lost their own home. The rules have taken steps little by little. According to the same pamphlet, from April 1, 2005 (Heisei 17), strict rules applied to promises to cover, all together, future debts of undetermined amount, including loan debts. Then in May 2017 (Heisei 29), an amendment to the Civil Code was passed, and from April 1, 2020 (Reiwa 2), when an individual promises to cover a debt taken on for a business, the person must go to a notary office in person within 1 month before the contract to have their intention confirmed and put into a notarial deed (called a notarial deed declaring the intention to guarantee); otherwise the promise has no effect. A spouse or the like who is actually working in the principal debtor's business falls outside this procedure, mind you. One more thing: a person who asks someone to cover a business debt now has to tell that person about their own assets, income and expenses, and other debts.

When I was young, there was a hungover morning when I couldn't remember a single thing about the promises I'd made the night before with the owner of a bar. When I showed my face at the place, it seems I'd said, "I'll cover all the drinks for next month's gathering." It was written in the owner's ledger, in my handwriting. Ka-ka-ka-ka. The handwriting was mine, all right, but I didn't know a thing about what it said. Nothing costs more than words you wrote without knowing what they meant.

In my view, your family's objection is tied to this same flow. I'd say the law went to the trouble of putting a notary in the middle because cases kept coming of relatives stamping their seals without knowing what was inside and losing their livelihoods. When your family says "don't do it," somewhere in their head they're thinking they might be asked for their seal too, that the whole household might get dragged in. This is usually what happens when people are scared. They can't see the shape of what scares them, so they oppose all of it together. The one being opposed gets scared too, and looks only for words to talk them around. Both sides are scared, and the conversation doesn't move a step.

So show them the shape of the fear. Before you talk to your family, go to the bank you're planning to borrow from and ask whether they'll require anyone in your family to promise to cover the debt or to provide collateral, and if so, whom and what. Then tell your family that answer just as it is. If you find out it won't be required, one road by which your family ends up in the mud is gone. If it will be required, then even if you win them over while keeping it hidden, what's inside will come out sooner or later, at the moment of stamping the seal.

A toast to a sober family meeting, before anyone stamps a seal.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.15)
Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! My family was against it too. It was when I told my mom I was going to buy my first unit.

I explained it all, full of energy. What the gross yield was, how much rent would come in, how a little would be left each month even after paying the loan. I even used the word "leverage"! My mom listened in silence. She made tea, set it in front of me, and listened in silence again. I was thinking, I've convinced her. Then, after hearing everything, she asked just one thing: "What will you do if it's empty?"

I couldn't answer. I'd hardly thought about what would happen when it was vacant. When I said, "The person in charge said it would fill up right away," my mom looked even more worried.

So I took it home once and redid my table. Full occupancy, 3 months vacant, rent down 10%, interest rate up 1%. In each case, how much would go out each month. How many months my savings could hold out. And at what point I'd sell.

The next time we talked, my mom traced the "3 months vacant" row of the table with her finger and asked, "Can you pay for these months?" This time I could answer. "I can. I have several months' worth in savings. If it goes beyond that, I'll sell."

My mom didn't say she agreed. But she said, "Then do it exactly the way this table says." I think that was my mom's "OK."

What I figured out was that what my mom was against wasn't real estate investment; it was me not thinking about the bad times. Every question she asked was a question I should have thought through myself. A family's objection isn't just a brake — it was a free inspection.

3 things I'd tell myself back then.

  • Before talking to your family, make the numbers for when things don't go well first
  • Show the table for the bad cases before the good story
  • Decide "at what point I'd stop," and share it with your family

By the way, that table is still on the fridge at my mom's house. Every time I go home, she says, "I'm keeping an eye on the vacancy row, you know!"

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper