BENERU
Basics and getting startedPublished Updated

Is there an asset whose value doesn't fall even in a major financial crisis?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. "A lifelong asset that's strong against any crisis." That line you often see in ads — hold on a sec. Strong, measured by what?

You can't say "its value doesn't fall" without deciding on a ruler. Measured by the yen ruler, yen cash doesn't drop by even ¥1. A ¥10,000 note is still ¥10,000 the morning after a crisis. But measured by the prices of goods, it has dropped by as much as prices rose. Measured in dollars, it has dropped by as much as the yen weakened. Something that doesn't fall by one ruler falls neatly by another. So an asset that doesn't fall by every ruler is impossible by design.

Well, I get what the ads are trying to say. In a crisis, there are things whose prices are relatively less likely to collapse. Gold tends to be bought when trust in currencies wavers, and your own country's government bonds tend to be bought as a place to escape to. That's right, it's right, but it's a story with a triple condition: "in a certain kind of crisis, measured by a certain ruler, relatively." The ad cuts all those conditions away into a single line.

But of course, here's the real point.

Among the assets that look like they don't fall, there are some that just don't get a price every day. Stocks and crypto assets get prices by the second, so every drop is visible. Real estate and unlisted things don't get a price until you put them up for sale. In the middle of a crisis there are no numbers lined up, so they only look like they haven't fallen. A drop you can't see and not falling are different things. A bit tricky? Well, hang in there.

One more thing. What really hurts in a crisis is sometimes less the price and more whether you can use it when you want to. You can wait for a price to come back, but next month's rent won't wait for you.

"But you just said nothing doesn't fall by every ruler"? Right, so swap the question. Not "which one doesn't fall" but "by which ruler would it hurt me if it fell." If you'll keep living in Japan, the prices of goods; if you have payments abroad, dollars; if you have expenses next year, the yen in hand. Once the ruler is decided, the candidates narrow down a lot. Get it?

The way to check is simple. Take each asset you hold, one by one, and write out whether it's "likely to fall in a crisis" by 3 rulers: yen, prices of goods and dollars. Nothing should come out with a circle on all 3. Honestly, just seeing that, you won't go along with the ad's one-liner anymore. Am I wrong?

You know La France pears? They're hard while they're on the tree, and after harvest you ripen them and wait until they're ready to eat. Which one tastes best is decided by when you want to eat it. Assets, too, are things you choose after deciding when and on what you'll use them. See you.

(Updated 2026.10.14)
Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Which asset doesn't lose value even in a big crisis. In the old folks' way of putting it, which is "the wealth that lets you sleep with your pillow high," eh.

Let me give my view first. No such wealth exists. But if you know how the thing everyone thinks comes closest to it has been protected, it starts to look different. Bank deposits.

Let me tell an old story. Not a made-up one, mind you. It's a story left in the Financial Services Agency's records.

After the prices of land and stocks collapsed at the start of Heisei, the damage to financial institutions grew deep, and an era came when people asked whether their deposits would come back safely. So from fiscal 1996 (Heisei 8), as a temporary measure for the financial crisis, the state put in place a special measure to protect deposits in full. Whatever financial institution you deposited with, they'd be protected regardless of the amount.

But temporary is temporary. On April 1, 2002 (Heisei 14), time deposits and the like were returned to the principle. A line was drawn: per financial institution, per depositor, up to ¥10 million of principal plus its interest. The minister in charge of financial affairs issued a statement that day. Ordinary deposits had a little more grace, and came inside the same line on April 1, 2005 (Heisei 17). Only deposits for settlement that bear no interest have continued to be protected in full since then.

What I find interesting about these changes is that the thickness of the protection has been decided by the depth of the crisis. When the crisis was deepest, the state protected everything. Once things calmed down, it drew a line. In other words, the story that "deposits don't go down" has been supported less by the nature of deposits themselves and more by the rules of the time. Rules get rewritten as times change.

Stocks, gold bullion, foreign government bonds and real estate each have crises they're strong against and crises they're weak against. In my long life, I've never once seen a situation where one of them won against every crisis. After all, even deposits, thought to be the most solid, have had the line of how they're protected redrawn.

Well, it won't kill you. But not being able to sleep is a problem. What hits hardest in a crisis is less the ups and downs of prices themselves than spending the night without knowing how far your own money is protected. If you know, you can sleep even when things fall.

Just one thing to do. Line up your bankbooks by financial institution, and see whether you have deposits at any one place over the line of ¥10 million of principal. If you're over, that's when you first need to think about how to split it.

Drink is the same. The one who knows what's on their own shelf and how much sleeps better than the one who guesses which brewery's sake is best. Kakakaka.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.14)

Read a little deeper