BENERU
Basics and getting startedPublished Updated

Is not investing the same as going all in on the yen?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. Not investing and holding all of your assets in yen cash or deposits can be described as being concentrated in a single asset: the yen. When prices rise, the same amount of money buys less, so the real value of cash falls. However, cash has the qualities that its principal does not decrease and it can be used right away, and how much to hold in cash depends on your purpose and time frame.

Rising prices and the real value of cash

The value, in today's prices, of ¥1 million held at zero interest (estimate)

Rate of price increaseAfter 10 yearsAfter 20 yearsAfter 30 years
1% a yearabout ¥905,000about ¥820,000about ¥742,000
2% a yearabout ¥820,000about ¥673,000about ¥552,000
3% a yearabout ¥744,000about ¥554,000about ¥412,000

Characteristics of each asset

AssetResilience to rising pricesMain risks
Cash and depositsWeakErosion of value from rising prices
StocksSaid to be relatively strong over the long termPrice fluctuations
Real estateRents and prices may move with prices in generalVacancies, repairs, difficulty selling, interest rates on borrowing
GoldMay move with prices in generalPrice fluctuations, no interest or dividends

What holding cash means

Cash has the qualities that its principal does not decrease and it can be used right away when needed. For several months of living expenses and money you plan to use within a few years, holding cash or deposits often suits the purpose better than holding assets whose prices move.

Order of checks

  1. Separate several months of living expenses and money you plan to use within a few years.
  2. Check for how many years the remaining money can be left unused.
  3. For money that can be left for a long time, estimate the effect of rising prices.
  4. If you hold assets whose prices move, check whether the amount is one you could bear if they fell.

From here on, this is my opinion

I think you should recognize that holding everything in cash is not "doing nothing" but one choice: concentrating in the yen. If you choose cash on that understanding, that too can be a rational decision.

Sources (in Japanese)

Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hi, it's Jamie! Is not investing the same as going all in on the yen? For a while after I started working, I was in exactly that state. My whole salary went into an ordinary deposit account. I thought investing was scary, and deposits don't go down.

What changed my mind was a visit to my grandmother's house. She showed me her old household account books. Prices of eggs and rice from decades ago were written in them. "Back then, this is how much you could buy with a salary," she said. Compared with today's prices, it was completely different.

My grandmother said, "Money doesn't go down, but what it can buy does."

When I got home, I did the math myself that same day. If you hold ¥1 million at zero interest and prices rise 2% every year, then after 10 years it buys about ¥820,000 worth of today's goods. After 20 years, about ¥670,000 worth. The number stays at ¥1 million, but what's inside keeps shrinking.

I thought, this is scary. But that didn't make it feel right to put everything into investments either. In fact, a coworker of mine moved almost all their deposits into stocks, and when prices fell they panicked and sold. "I thought it would go up," they said, and they were down for a while.

So I split my money into 3.

The first is 6 months of living expenses. This stays in deposits. It's for sudden expenses, or for when my job changes. This money isn't for growing; what matters is that I can use it right away.

The second is money I plan to use within a few years. Like replacing a car. This is deposits too.

The third is money I won't use for 10 years or more. This I put into an installment plan for index funds in NISA. Later I also bought a second-hand condominium unit, but that's another story.

Back when everything was in deposits, I never imagined I was betting everything on the yen. But once I started thinking about it in parts, I could choose for myself: "this part I'll hold in yen."

There are 3 things I'd like to tell myself back then.

  • Know that sticking only to deposits is also a choice
  • Split money by when you'll use it, then decide where to put it
  • Move only the money you won't use for a long time into things less likely to lose out to prices

I still think about my grandmother's account books sometimes. Ever since then, every time she sees me, she asks, "How much were eggs?"

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper