Yeah yeah, it's Rita. "Real assets that are strong against inflation. Now, before interest rates rise." Wow, a line I've seen somewhere many times. To the question of whether interest rates or inflation matter more, this line cheekily uses both and lands on "so buy." Clever, right?
The first thing to look at is who wants to play up which one. People who want to sell property play up inflation. Rents and prices go up along with prices in general, they say. People who want to recommend products other than real estate, or who want to grab eyes with a headline, play up interest rates. Rate hikes will push real estate down, they say. The bank doesn't care either way, as long as it can lend. Everyone is just enlarging whichever side suits what they're selling. With me so far?
So, the answer to the question. Interest rates hit the price first, and inflation hits later, by way of rent. And inflation only works for properties whose rent keeps up with prices.
Let's try it with assumed numbers. Take a property whose rent after expenses, the take-home, is ¥1 million a year. If buyers price it at a 4% yield, the price is ¥25 million. Say interest rates rise and the yield buyers want becomes 4.5%. Same ¥1 million, but the price is about ¥22.22 million. About 11% cheaper. In theory, it takes effect right away, from the next deal that gets priced.
Then how do you win it back with rent? To get back to ¥25 million at 4.5%, the take-home has to be ¥1.125 million, meaning a 12.5% increase. Even if rent rises 2% every year, it takes about 6 years to catch up. On top of that, rent is set by contract, and it mostly moves at renewal or when tenants change. Well? Does that add up?
No, I know it's not as simple as "if interest rates go up, yields go up by the same amount." In a phase where prices are rising, buyers may also expect "rent should go up" and not raise the yield that far. What, didn't I just say interest rates come first? Yes, interest rates hit first. But how hard they hit depends on how much buyers believe in inflation. That's why you miss the moment you make it a two-way choice. Am I wrong?
So what do you look at for your own property? Honestly, put side by side the price you get by dividing the take-home rent by the current market yield, and the price you get by dividing it by that yield plus 0.5%. How many years would rent take to fill that gap? Then check that against what the rent was set at the last time that unit changed tenants. A few lines of that calculation are more honest than one line in an ad.
You know the daikon in oden — it heats through quickly, but it takes time for the broth to soak into the core. Interest rates are the heat, inflation is the broth. What? It'll soak in if you leave it overnight? Oh, sure. The loan repayment won't wait that night for you, though.