BENERU
Basics and getting startedPublished

What should I know before going to a real estate investment seminar?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. It's the other way around. It's not what you should know before going to a seminar. It's what they get to know about you at the seminar.

Think back to the questionnaire they hand you at reception. Above the comments box, there may be lines like "Planned timing of purchase: within 3 months / within 1 year / undecided" and "Request an individual meeting: yes / no." Those are just the right items for deciding whom to call, in what order. A free seminar, with a rented venue, a hired lecturer, even tea served. Where does that money come from? From inside the price of the property that finally gets sold. Frankly, before you're a listener, you're being counted as a prospect. Get it?

I mean, I went too far. Not every seminar is like that. Some sessions carefully explain how taxes work and how management is arranged, and it's not a bad thing to properly hear the seller's side once. What the seller emphasizes and what they rush past can only be seen in the room. Going is right; going itself is right, but.

So. What you decide before going isn't knowledge, it's your own line.

One: how you circle the questionnaire. Circle "undecided" for timing and "no" for the meeting, and hand it in. If that means they won't let you hear the talk, then that's the kind of session it was. Am I wrong?

Two: decide in advance that there's nothing you'll sign that day. Booking an individual meeting, application forms, all of it goes home with you. If it's a story where you lose out unless you decide today, by tomorrow it should have turned into a story where you don't lose out.

Three: bring one question. "With this income and expense sheet, if a unit is vacant for 1 month a year and the interest rate goes up 1%, how much cash is left over each month?" A company that answers on the spot with numbers, you can trust just a teeny bit. If they laugh it off, then you've seen what assumptions the sheet was built on. OK?

"Hey, you said 'being counted as a prospect' earlier," you say? Yep, I said it. But that's their way of counting, and we have no obligation to go along with it. Staying a prospect and taking home only the talk is a perfectly fine way to attend. Does that answer it?

Fragrant olive, you know, calls you from around the corner with its scent, but when you turn the corner there's sometimes just one tree standing. And the pumpkin lantern under the eaves, flashy face and all, is hollowed out and empty inside. It's fine to walk where the scent and the face lure you. Just leave your seal and bankbook at home when you go out. See you.

Sources (in Japanese)

Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! What to know before going to a seminar? What I should have known was what "Ranked No. 1" really means!

I opened my household budget app and an ad came up. "Real estate investment seminar, popularity ranking No. 1," "Participant satisfaction 98%," "Bonus when you book from the app." I'm weak to the word "ranking." If it's No. 1, it can't go wrong! So I hit the booking button right then and there. That it said "PR" in small letters in the corner, I only noticed when I looked back later. I mean, it was written properly. I'm the one who didn't look!

The seminar was fun, and by the way home I was totally sold. On the questionnaire at reception, I honestly wrote everything: my employer, my annual income, my savings. Because it was the No. 1 seminar!

At the individual meeting the next week, what came out was an income and expense sheet for a newly built studio unit. "Your monthly out-of-pocket will be about ¥4,000." What's more, when you put the rent and interest rate into that company's app, the number came out as a neat graph. Seeing it on the screen, it somehow looked like an official number. I was told, "This unit looks like it will be gone with just 1 more applicant this week," and I signed the application form and transferred an application deposit of ¥100,000.

That night, looking at the graph in bed, I noticed. The rent was a line at the same height for all 35 years. With new buildings, rent is usually highest at the start and goes down as the years pass. The repair reserve fund goes up. Neither was in the graph. When I put those in and tapped at my calculator, the out-of-pocket looked like it would be not ¥4,000 a month but several times that.

The next day, I called to say I wanted to withdraw the application. 3 days of "We'll check," then another 1 week of "Please let us explain just one more time." When I looked it up, I found that refusing to return money held in deposit to someone who withdraws an application before a contract is formed is prohibited by the Building Lots and Buildings Transaction Business Act (Takken Gyōhō). When I told them that, the ¥100,000 came back. But for several months after that, I lived jumping at phone calls after 9 p.m. It went on until I said clearly, "Please don't contact me anymore."

3 things I'd like to tell myself back then.

  • If "PR" is next to "Ranked No. 1," it's a ranking of ads
  • With income and expense figures from the selling company's app, add in the falling rent and the rising repair reserve fund yourself before you look at them
  • Even after paying an application deposit, you can withdraw before the contract and get the money held in deposit back. State clearly that you're withdrawing

Even now, when I see a ranking, my finger feels like it's going to move on its own. So I hid the ads in my household budget app. Then what came up next was "Seminars popular with people who hid ads"! Hey, that's a ranking too! Well, let's call it growth that I didn't tap it!

Sources (in Japanese)

Read a little deeper