BENERU
Basics and getting startedPublished

Is there any point in thinking about borrowing when I don't even have 3 months of living expenses in reserve?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. Credit shrinks with age; if you don't use it, it fades away. Hear that, and you want to move now, even if your savings are thin. I get that impatience. I get it, but if someone without even 3 months of reserve borrows now, almost none of the gain from hurrying stays in their hands.

Think about this question as "borrow or don't borrow," and you're stuck. Decide not to borrow, and it feels like your credit is wearing away; borrow, and the lack of savings is scary. Whichever you choose, you can't settle. So rearrange it. Not whether to borrow, but what to do first.

First, let's measure the reason for hurrying. If the upper limit on age at full repayment is 80 and the longest loan is 35 years, the term only starts to shrink after you pass 45 (the limit depends on the lender). If a 35-year-old waits 1 year, the term they can borrow for doesn't shrink by even 1 year. What you lose by waiting a year is often smaller than you think. Following?

Flip it: what happens if you borrow with no reserve? Borrowing turns part of your monthly take-home pay into "spending that can't be moved." Then if one thing comes along, dental treatment or a wedding or funeral, about the only place left to pay from is a card cash advance. And here's the painful part. The Japan Housing Finance Agency's Flat 35 includes credit card cash advances and installment payments in its calculation of the total debt-to-income ratio (as of April 1, 2026 (Reiwa 8)). The credit you supposedly hurried to use gets whittled down again by small debts to fill holes. The you who hurried reduces the very thing you didn't want reduced. Am I wrong?

Well, let me pick up the other side too. "What if property prices go up while I'm waiting?" That's right, it is right, but nobody knows whether they'll go up or down. Running with certainly thin cash on hand to avoid a price rise nobody knows about is, frankly, betting in the wrong place. Don't you think?

But, well, of course, now the real point. So, until the reserve is built, you don't need to think about borrowing at all? There is a point in thinking about it. In fact, now is the easiest time to think about it. As long as you're not filling out an application, you can look at properties and run calculations, and not a single yen goes down.

Suppose your living expenses are ¥200,000 a month; then 3 months' worth is ¥600,000. There's a way to make the period of saving this ¥600,000 not just endurance. Decide the repayment amount that would go out every month if you borrowed, say ¥60,000 a month, and move that amount straight into a reserve account every month. ¥600,000 in 10 months. 10 months of living as if you'd borrowed. If your life stops working along the way, that repayment amount was too heavy, and you've finished revising the amount to borrow before you borrow. If it works, the account holds a reserve and you've got a sense of the repayment amount. Either way, you lose nothing. OK?

La France pears — right after they're picked off the tree they're hard, and bite into one as is and it isn't sweet. Rather than spotting one at the store and sinking your teeth in now while you can, leave it in the kitchen and wait until the area around the stem gets a little soft, and the same fruit becomes much more delicious.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.18)
Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! Is it OK to think about borrowing when you don't even have 3 months of living expenses in reserve? Me, in that state, I didn't just think about it — I actually borrowed!

It started with a bookstore's "Investment Book Ranking for People in Their 30s." The band on the No. 1 book said in big letters, "Even with little savings, you can take the first step today." This is it! I went straight to the register. I read only the band and Chapter 1, and that night I was already opening property websites.

My savings back then were about ¥450,000. My living expenses were about ¥180,000 a month, so 2 and a half months' worth. I found a second-hand studio unit, and after paying the acquisition costs, what I had on hand fell below ¥300,000. Even so, when the call came saying I'd passed the loan screening, I was relieved from the bottom of my heart. If the bank says it's OK to lend, that means my household finances are fine too, right! Riding that relief, I never once wrote down what would arrive after buying, or what money goes out of my own life once a year.

And so it came, one after another. A few months after buying, the tax notice for real estate acquisition tax. In my case, about ¥120,000. I knew the tax existed, but I hadn't thought about when it would come! In the same month, the renewal of the rental where I live myself. The renewal fee was 1 month's rent, about ¥80,000. On top of that, 2 friends' weddings came in a row, and the gift money and travel came to about ¥80,000. About ¥280,000 altogether. The not-quite-¥300,000 I had on hand almost vanished.

Then, a dental filling came out. After paying for the treatment, I didn't have enough for that month's card payment, so I borrowed ¥150,000 as a card cash advance.

From then on, every payday, money left my account in the order of the loan debit, the cash advance repayment and the card payment, and I got scared to look at my balance. Half a year until I finished repaying the ¥150,000. If even one more thing had broken in that time, what would I have covered it with next! With no reserve, one expense calls in the next debt — I learned that with my body.

The book with the band isn't bad. When I read further later, Chapter 3 said in bold, "Secure a separate reserve for living expenses first." The one who stopped at Chapter 1 was me!

There are 3 things I want to tell the me of back then.

  • Passing the screening only meant the bank saw that it could lend. Whether my household finances had a margin was something I had to check myself
  • Before applying, line up by month and write down the taxes that arrive after buying and the once-a-year expenses of your own life
  • If one line on a band makes you want to move, read that book to the last chapter before you move

Now, I'm skipping the coffee milk I used to drink on the way home from the public bath in Koiwa, and putting that money into my reserve. The lady at the bathhouse counter worried, "You haven't been drinking it lately, is something wrong?" I promised that when my reserve reaches 3 months' worth, I'll drink 2 bottles at once!

(Updated 2026.10.18)

Read a little deeper