BENERU
Corporations, inheritance and successionPublished

What is "5 buildings, 10 units" in real estate investment? What changes when you reach business scale?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. The tax treatment changes depending on whether your real estate leasing counts as "business scale." The National Tax Agency uses as a guide roughly 5 or more detached houses, or 10 or more rental units in apartment buildings and the like (the so-called 5 buildings, 10 units standard). At business scale, you can use the blue return special deduction of up to ¥650,000, salaries paid to family employees on a blue return, deduction in full as expenses of losses from bad debts and demolition, and so on.

Guide to business scale

CategoryGuide
Detached housesRoughly 5 or more
Rental units in apartment buildings and condominiumsRoughly 10 or more
ConversionGenerally, 1 detached house is counted as 2 rental units

This is a formal guide. Even below 5 buildings, 10 units, leasing may be judged to be a business in substance based on how it is managed and similar factors.

What changes depending on whether it is business scale

ItemBusiness scaleNot business scale
Blue return special deductionUp to ¥650,000 if requirements are metUp to ¥100,000
Salaries to family employees on a blue return / deduction for family employeesAvailableNot available
Bad debts on rentNecessary expense in the year the debt went badGo back to the year the income was recorded, and recalculate income as if there had been no income
Losses from demolition or disposal of a buildingFull amount as a necessary expenseCapped at the amount of real estate income before deducting the loss
Individual enterprise taxMay be charged if the prefecture's criteria are metIn principle not charged

Procedures

DocumentWhere to file / deadline
Notification of opening of a sole proprietorshipTax office. Within 1 month from the day the business started
Application for approval of blue returnsTax office. In principle by March 15 of the year you want to file a blue return (if you started the business on or after January 16, within 2 months of starting)

Order of checks

  1. Count the number of buildings and units you own.
  2. Check whether it counts as business scale, using the 5 buildings, 10 units guide and how it is managed.
  3. If it does, check the deadlines for the notification of opening and the application for approval of blue returns.
  4. Check the requirements for the ¥650,000 blue return special deduction (double-entry bookkeeping, electronic filing, etc.). From returns for 2027 (Reiwa 9), filing through e-Tax becomes a requirement for the ¥650,000, and the amount becomes ¥750,000 when you keep high-quality electronic books (FY2026 (Reiwa 8) tax reform).

From here on, this is my opinion

While you have 1 or 2 units, the deduction is at most ¥100,000 even on a blue return. I believe whether to aim for business scale should be decided not for the taxes, but by whether you have a plan to add more properties.

Sources (in Japanese)

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. And, and, and here it is — 5 buildings, 10 units. It shows up looking like "cross this and you're a real pro," but honestly, it's just a line someone drew.

A line for what? It's the guide the National Tax Agency uses to see whether you're leasing real estate "as a business." For rental units in apartment buildings and the like, roughly 10 or more; for detached houses, roughly 5 or more. Cross this line and the blue return special deduction goes from up to ¥100,000 to up to ¥650,000, you can count the salary of family members working with you as an expense, and you can expense in full the losses from demolishing a building or from rent that goes bad. That much is straight from the textbook.

And this is where everyone's eyes light up: "¥650,000!" No, hold on a sec. The ¥650,000 isn't money coming back to you. It's an amount you can subtract from income. What comes back is only the increase in the deduction times your tax rate.

Back to the calculation. Assume someone with an income tax rate of 20% and a resident tax rate of 10%. If the deduction goes from ¥100,000 to ¥650,000, the increase is ¥550,000. ¥550,000 × 30%, so the tax saved is about ¥165,000 a year (leaving out the special reconstruction income tax). OK?

And the ¥650,000 comes with conditions. You keep double-entry books, attach a balance sheet and a profit and loss statement, file by the deadline, and on top of that either file through e-Tax or keep high-quality electronic books. If you use neither e-Tax nor high-quality electronic books, it's ¥550,000, so the increase is ¥450,000 and the tax saved is about ¥135,000.

But of course, this is where the real point starts. A calculation that only adds and never subtracts isn't a calculation.

The first thing to subtract is individual enterprise tax. It's a prefectural tax; in Tokyo, real estate leasing is taxed at 5%, with a proprietor's deduction of ¥2.9 million a year. And individual enterprise tax doesn't let you subtract the blue return special deduction. If real estate income before the blue return special deduction is ¥4 million, then (¥4 million − ¥2.9 million) × 5% is ¥55,000. Subtract that from ¥165,000 and you have ¥110,000 left. You know?

One more, and this one's seriously a trap: where the line is drawn differs from tax to tax. For Tokyo's individual enterprise tax, you're recognized as being in the real estate leasing business at 10 or more detached houses, or 10 or more units for anything other than detached houses. That's a different way of counting from income tax's "roughly 5 detached houses." Same-looking numbers, pointing at different things.

The rest of the subtraction is the work of keeping the books, and the fee if you hire someone.

Calculate this far and you can see it. 5 buildings, 10 units isn't a line to buy units in order to cross. It's a line you find you've crossed as a result of adding units. Buying a 10th unit for ¥165,000 a year in taxes has the same shape as buying something you don't need to use a discount coupon. Well, for someone who was going to add units anyway, it is worth knowing in advance the deadlines for the notification of opening and the application for approval of blue returns in the year you cross. That's right. Does that answer it?

You know hot pots — the more ingredients you add, the fancier they look, but the work of skimming the scum grows too. The number of ingredients doesn't decide how good the pot is; you add to match the number of people eating. See you.

Sources (in Japanese)

Read a little deeper