BENERU
Law, contracts and systemsPublished Updated

Is it all right to buy a stigmatized property as an investment?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. Whether to buy a so-called stigmatized property (jiko bukken) is judged by whether the price discount is worth the fall in rent, the length of vacancies, and the burden of disclosure when you sell. The approach to the scope of disclosure is set out in the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's "Guidelines on Disclosure of the Death of a Person by Licensed Real Estate Brokers" (October 2021 (Reiwa 3)).

The guidelines' approach

CategoryDisclosure by a licensed real estate broker
Natural death, accidental death in the course of daily life (a fall, choking, etc.)In principle need not be disclosed
Even for the deaths above, cases left undiscovered for a long period where special cleaning or large-scale renovation, etc. was carried outSubject to disclosure
Deaths other than the above (suicide, homicide, etc.)Subject to disclosure
For leases, when roughly 3 years have passed since a death subject to disclosure occurred (or, where special cleaning, etc. was carried out, since it was discovered)In principle need not be disclosed
Deaths in a neighboring unit, or in common areas not normally used in daily lifeIn principle need not be disclosed

For the "roughly 3 years" for leases and the treatment of neighboring units and common areas, there is an exception that excludes cases whose criminal nature, public notoriety, impact on society, etc. are especially high. For sales there is no guide for the period. Also, if a buyer or lessee asks whether such an incident occurred, what was found in the investigation must be disclosed.

Numbers to look at as an investment

ItemWhat to check
Purchase priceThe size of the discount compared with similar properties nearby
RentHow far the rent must be lowered to find a tenant during the period when disclosure is needed
Vacancy periodThe expected vacancy during the period when disclosure is needed
SaleBecause there is no guide for the period for sales, the need to disclose may remain when you sell

Order of checks

  1. Confirm in writing with the seller and the broker what happened, when, and in which room.
  2. Check whether special cleaning or large-scale renovation was done, and what it involved.
  3. Estimate the rent and vacancy during the period when disclosure is needed, using discounted figures.
  4. Estimate the price when you sell in the future, on the premise that a discount remains.

From here on, this is my opinion

I think the judgment on a stigmatized property should be made by separating the question of feelings from the question of numbers. Whether it bothers you differs from person to person, but whether it bothers the people who rent and the next buyer shows up in the rent and the sale price.

Sources (in Japanese)

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Is it all right to buy a stigmatized property as an investment? In my reading, half of this question is about price, and the other half is about fear. And it's the fear that moves the price.

Let me tell an old story. Though it isn't all that old. In February 2020 (Reiwa 2), the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism held the first meeting of its "Study Group on Psychological Defects in Real Estate Transactions." The announcement at the time says that how to handle facts such as a past fatal incident had become an issue, and that this was one factor holding back the revitalization of the market for existing homes. After rounds of discussion, the "Guidelines on Disclosure of the Death of a Person by Licensed Real Estate Brokers" were made on October 8, 2021 (Reiwa 3). The announcement at the time gives as background that there was no standard for brokers to investigate properly and disclose, and that judgments in the field of transactions were difficult.

In other words, until the autumn of 2021 (Reiwa 3), there was no measuring stick. Where there is no measuring stick, people fall toward the side of fear. Brokers didn't know how far they should go in telling, so they tended to swing between saying too much and saying too little. Buyers and renters alike feared a room where they didn't know what had happened, without knowing. What you don't know is what's scariest.

At the back of a shelf in a drinking place I often go to, there was a jar covered in dust. When I asked the old man who runs it, he said, "A customer who ordered that keeled over on the spot, long ago." None of the regulars would touch it. One night, emboldened by drink, I ordered it, and it was just old Shaoxing wine, mellowed and remarkably good. The old man confessed afterward that the customer keeled over because he'd emptied a whole shō of shochu before that. Until I knew the reason, the whole jar was frightening.

Back to the point. When people are afraid, it usually goes like this. Either they run without even looking at the price, or, wanting to cancel out the fear, they jump at it looking only at how cheap it is. They look like opposites, but they're the same in not having checked what happened. What changed with the guidelines is that there is now a measuring stick for putting that "what" into words. But this is a measuring stick for whether a broker discloses, not a measuring stick for the feelings of the people who rent or the next buyer. The feelings, then as now, show up in the price.

So before you decide to buy, get one sheet of paper. Rewrite what you heard from the broker in your own words, as if it were the explanation you'll hand to the next buyer someday when you sell this room. The places you can't write smoothly are the places you haven't checked yet.

What happened in the room isn't going to come and eat you. It won't kill you. The only time you get hurt is when you put your seal on it without knowing.

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper