BENERU
Choosing and buying propertyPublished Updated

For a unit with a tenant where I can't see inside, what should I look at before buying?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. Let me ask you just one thing first. Do you want to keep receiving rent from that unit for a long time? Or do you want to empty it eventually and sell it, or use it yourself? Depending on which, the weight of what you look at changes.

And before looking at the paperwork, there's one more thing to think about. Why is that unit up for sale with someone still living in it? From the seller's side, selling with the tenant in place means you don't have to wait for them to leave, and you don't have to spend money fixing it up after it's emptied. On top of that, you can advertise the yield calculated on the current rent. If there's someone who's lived there a long time at an old rent, that number looks pretty.

I mean, I'm not saying the seller is doing anything wrong. That's right — wanting to sell fast and not wanting the hassle are both natural. But a way of selling that avoids showing the inside is also a way of selling that's convenient for the seller. For the person in the middle, too, if the deal doesn't close, there's no work. So the words "You can't see inside, but the rent is coming in properly," even if they're not a lie, are words pointed in the direction of closing the deal. Don't you think?

Let me give the answer to the question in short. For a unit you can't see inside, you buy by looking not at the inside of the unit, but at "the reason they want to sell this unit in this form."

Sometimes they won't tell you that reason even if you ask. So work backward from the paperwork. In the lease agreement, the rent and the year the contract started. The record of any late rent. In the report on important matters issued by the property management company, any unpaid management fees or repair reserve fund, the balance of the reserve fund, and the schedule for major repairs. And the advertised rent for similar units in the same building or nearby. The last comparison is the one that works best. Get it?

A unit whose current rent is higher than the advertised rents is like a pot where the stock was made too strong. The moment you swap the ingredients, the flavor thins out. In other words, the advertised yield drops on the day the current tenant moves out. Deciding on yield alone without looking at this is full-of-holes as a calculation.

"Didn't you just ask what I want to do?" For someone who wants to keep receiving rent, the gap between the rent and the market, and the repair schedule, weigh the most. For someone who plans to empty it and sell or use it, the cost of fixing up the inside of the unit lands on top of that in full. Same paperwork, but the order you read it in changes. Am I wrong?

Rent above market, a small reserve fund for the building's age, major repairs coming soon. If you see a lineup like that on paper, the reason for selling mostly shows through too. Frankly, sometimes that tells you more than seeing the inside.

You know sweet osmanthus — even when you can't see the tree, you know it's there from the scent before you turn the corner. For a unit you can't see, too, decide after smelling what comes off the paperwork.

(Updated 2026.10.15)
Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Do you remember April 1, 2020 (Reiwa 2)? That's the day a major amendment to the Civil Code took effect. Among it was a provision that if a unit is sold with someone living in it, the duty to return the security deposit that was held passes to the buyer. Article 605-2, paragraph 4. If you're buying a unit where you can't see inside, first keep this one line in your head.

Let me tell you a slightly older story. The Civil Code made in the Meiji era didn't say what happens to the security deposit when a rented house is sold. So the courts decided it. The Great Court of Cassation in 1930 (Showa 5) and 1943 (Showa 18), and the Supreme Court on July 17, 1969 (Showa 44), ruled that the duty to return the security deposit passes to the new owner as a matter of course. It was also the view of the case law that if there was late rent under the previous owner, what remained after deducting it from the deposit was what passed on. The Ministry of Justice's council materials, too, cite these 3 rulings side by side.

In other words, even before it became a provision, the same treatment had continued for about 90 years. Even so, without a provision, it's hard for buyers to notice. In 2020 (Reiwa 2), it was finally put into words.

What's more, not being able to see inside also means not knowing how many years' worth of traces of living the previous tenant has left. Inquiries to the National Consumer Affairs Center of Japan about restoration of rental housing were 13,273 in fiscal 2023, 13,312 in fiscal 2024, and 14,711 in fiscal 2025. Wear on a unit when a tenant leaves is still a seed of disputes today. Wear from ordinary living is borne by the landlord, not the tenant, so the longer someone has lived in a unit, the more the fixing-up after they leave hits the buyer's wallet.

People have always been like this. What they can't see, they imagine on the good side. Rent coming in properly, someone living there a long time — that alone makes them assume even the inside of the unit is good. But buying a unit you can't see means taking on, all together, the money the previous owner held and the wear the previous tenant left.

So when the sale documents come out, take your own finger and trace the security deposit amount written in the lease agreement against the amount deducted from the sale price, and check whether they're the same. If those match, at least the money you can't see is settled.

As for the wear, you won't know until you open it up. There's no point being frightened of what you can't know. Even if you open it and get a shock, as long as you didn't buy it at a price that knocks you off your feet, you won't die of it.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper