BENERU
Selling and exitPublished Updated

Should I sell a condominium unit with a tenant as is, or sell it after it becomes vacant?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. When selling a condominium unit with a tenant, you can choose to sell it to an investor with the tenant in place (an owner change), or wait for the tenant to move out and sell it vacant. A vacant unit can also be sold to people who will live in it themselves, so the price generally tends to be higher; on the other hand, asking a tenant to leave is not easy. Under an ordinary lease, the lessor needs a justifiable reason to terminate or refuse renewal.

Differences between the two ways of selling

ItemSell with the tenant in placeSell vacant
Main buyersInvestorsPeople who will live in it, and investors
How the price is setTends to be set by rent and yieldTends to be set by market prices of nearby homes
Price tendencyOften lower than vacantTends to be higher
Time until saleNo need to wait for the tenant to leaveRental income stops while you wait for the tenant to leave
ViewingsOften the interior cannot be shownThe interior can be shown

Points to note when asking a tenant to leave

Type of contractDetails
Ordinary leaseA justifiable reason is needed for the lessor to request termination or refuse renewal. Payment of a move-out fee may be taken into account
Fixed-term building leaseEnds when the contract period expires. There is no renewal

Under the Act on Land and Building Leases, when the lessor requests termination, the lease ends when 6 months have passed from the request, provided there is a justifiable reason.

Order of checks

  1. Check whether the lease contract is an ordinary lease or a fixed-term building lease.
  2. Check, through appraisals, both the expected price with the tenant in place and the expected price if vacant.
  3. If you make it vacant, account for the loss of rental income while waiting for the tenant to leave, and the cost of restoration.
  4. Compare the cash left over in the two cases and decide how to sell.

From here on, this is my opinion

I think you should not choose to sell vacant based on the price difference alone. You need to compare including the rent and costs during the wait for the tenant to leave, and your relationship with the tenant.

Sources (in Japanese)

Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hi, it's Jamie! Sell with the tenant in place, or sell after it's vacant? I once sold one of the condominium units I owned, so let me tell you about how I agonized over it then.

When I decided to sell, there was a tenant in the unit. I asked a brokerage firm for an appraisal, and two numbers came out. Selling to an investor with the tenant in place, around ¥16 million. Making it vacant so it could also be sold to people who'd live in it, around ¥18 million.

A ¥2 million difference! So at first I thought, let's sell after it's vacant.

But the person in charge at the brokerage told me, "Getting the tenant to move out isn't something you can easily do for your own convenience." With an ordinary lease contract, the lessor needs a legally justifiable reason to have the tenant leave. Apparently "because I want to sell" isn't a reason on its own.

So I checked when the tenant's renewal was. There was more than 1 year until the next renewal. Whether they'd leave was up to the tenant. And while waiting, I couldn't decide when to sell.

Also, if it became vacant, no rent would come in during that time. There'd be restoration costs too. Without fixing up the interior, it would be hard to sell to someone who'd live in it. Adding it all up, a large part of the ¥2 million difference disappeared in the calculation.

In the end, I sold to an investor with the tenant in place. The price was settled a little above ¥16 million. The procedures finished cleanly, and I didn't cause the tenant any trouble. The buyer can just keep receiving the rent, after all.

I learned later that if the time the tenant happens to move out on their own lines up with when you want to sell, you can sometimes sell it vacant for more. If you're not in a hurry to sell, that kind of waiting is an option too, apparently.

There are 3 things I'd like to tell myself back then.

  • Get appraisals both "with the tenant in place" and "vacant"
  • Having a tenant move out can't be done for the seller's convenience
  • Compare after subtracting the rent during the vacancy and the restoration costs from the price difference

I'm glad I didn't jump at the ¥2 million difference. Subtract everything, then put your glasses back on and look at the numbers — that's my way!

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper