BENERU
Choosing and buying propertyPublished Updated

When buying, what is the difference between a property sold by a real estate company and one sold through a broker?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. Between a property whose seller is a real estate company and a property whose seller is an individual with a real estate company acting as broker, what differs is whether there is a brokerage commission and the legal provisions that protect the buyer. When a real estate company is the seller, the Building Lots and Buildings Transaction Business Act (Takken Gyōhō) restricts arrangements unfavorable to the buyer regarding the period of liability for non-conformity with the contract (keiyaku futekigō sekinin), the amount of earnest money (tetsukekin), the protection of earnest money, and so on.

Differences by seller

ItemReal estate company is the sellerIndividual is the seller (brokered)
Brokerage commissionNot charged (when buying directly from the seller)Charged
Liability for non-conformity with the contractSpecial provisions less favorable to the buyer than the Civil Code are void, except one setting the period for giving notice of non-conformity at 2 years or more from handoverA special provision excluding liability can be agreed (except where, for example, the seller knew and did not disclose)
Amount of earnest moneyUp to 20% of the priceNo legal upper limit
Protection of earnest money, etc.Protective measures are required above a certain amountNo provision
Cooling-offContracts made at places other than offices, etc. are coveredNot covered

What to check for a property sold by a real estate company

ItemDetails
PriceIn place of the brokerage commission not being charged, the seller's profit is included in the property price
Period of liability for non-conformityHow many years from handover, and what it covers
Protection of earnest moneyThe method of protective measures and the institution providing the guarantee

What to check for a property sold by an individual

ItemDetails
Liability for non-conformityWhether there is an exemption provision, and how long the period is
Condition of the propertyCheck the seller's declarations about roof leaks, equipment defects and so on in the disclosure statement (property condition report)
Building condition surveyFor a second-hand home, check whether a building condition survey has been carried out

Order of checks

  1. Check who the seller is in the statement of important matters and the sale contract.
  2. Check the period and scope of liability for non-conformity with the contract.
  3. Check the amount of earnest money and whether there are protective measures.
  4. Compare with other properties on a total including the brokerage commission.

From here on, this is my opinion

When comparing properties, I think you should check the scope and period of liability for non-conformity with the contract before whether there is a brokerage commission. This is because the cost of repairing defects found after handover can be larger than the brokerage commission.

Sources (in Japanese)

  • デジタル庁(e-Gov法令検索)「宅地建物取引業法」(checked 2026-10-14)
  • デジタル庁(e-Gov法令検索)「民法」(checked 2026-10-14)
Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hi, it's Jamie! A property sold by a real estate company versus a brokered one. What's the difference when buying? When I was first looking for a property, I didn't know this difference and compared them only on whether there was a brokerage commission.

I had two candidates. One was a second-hand condominium unit that a real estate company had bought itself, renovated, and was selling. The other was a unit an individual owner was selling, with a real estate company acting as broker. On price, the unit sold by the real estate company was about ¥1.5 million higher.

At first I thought that since there's no brokerage commission, the unit sold by the real estate company might not be that much more expensive. With the brokered unit, the brokerage commission would be close to ¥700,000.

But as I heard more about the contracts, that wasn't the only difference. The unit sold by the real estate company came with a contract where, for 2 years from handover, if a hidden defect was found, the seller would fix it. Apparently when a real estate company is the seller, the law doesn't let them make that period shorter than 2 years.

On the other hand, the contract for the unit sold by the individual said, "The seller does not bear liability for non-conformity with the contract." It was an old unit, so if anything turned up after handover, I'd be fixing it myself. The person in charge said, "With individual sellers, it's a common special provision."

So for the individual's unit, I asked to see the report on the property's condition written by the seller. It lists what the seller knows, like whether there are traces of roof leaks or equipment defects. It also turned out the water heater had been in use for more than 10 years.

In the end, I chose the individual seller's unit. Even replacing the water heater with the price difference, it was still cheaper. But I bought it ready to take on defects after handover myself. Sure enough, I replaced the water heater half a year later.

Three things I'd tell myself back then.

  • Whether the seller is a real estate company or an individual makes a big difference to responsibility after handover
  • For a property sold by an individual, check the exemption provision for liability for non-conformity and the condition report
  • Compare not just the brokerage commission but also repair costs after handover

On the day I replaced the water heater, I told the person in charge, and they said, "You did plan for that properly." Even when you've planned for it, it still hurts when you pay. But it's way better than the hurt you didn't plan for!

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper