This is Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. When aiming for ¥1 million a month in cash flow in a short period, the method commonly described is buying whole buildings with large borrowing. However, when you calculate with assumptions, the property scale needed comes to several hundred million yen, and the burden of vacancies, rising interest rates and repairs grows by the same multiple. Also, cash flow is not profit itself.
Estimate based on assumptions
Assumptions: gross yield 10%, vacancy rate 10%, operating expenses 20% of rental income, borrowing 95% of the purchase price, interest rate 2.5%, loan term 30 years (taxes and major repairs not included)
| Purchase price | Annual net rent | Annual repayment | Monthly cash flow |
|---|---|---|---|
| ¥200 million | about ¥14.4 million | about ¥9 million | about ¥450,000 |
| ¥300 million | about ¥21.6 million | about ¥13.5 million | about ¥670,000 |
| about ¥450 million | about ¥32.4 million | about ¥20.3 million | about ¥1 million |
What grows when the scale gets larger
| Item | Details |
|---|---|
| Vacancy | At the ¥450 million scale, a rise of just 10 percentage points in the vacancy rate reduces net rent by about ¥3.6 million a year |
| Interest rate | The larger the loan amount, the larger the impact of a rise in interest rates |
| Repairs | With a whole building, you bear major repairs such as outer walls, roof waterproofing and water supply and drainage yourself |
| Taxes | Income tax and resident tax are deducted from cash flow |
Cash flow and net worth
Monthly cash flow is the flow of money that stays in hand. The result of an investment is settled by the change in net worth — the price when you sell minus the remaining loan balance. Even if cash flow is positive, if the property's value falls faster than the loan is paid down, net worth decreases.
Order of checks
- From your target cash flow, work backward to the property scale needed, using your own assumptions.
- Calculate income and expenses with vacancy, interest rate and repair stresses applied.
- Calculate the cash left over after tax.
- Compare the expected sale price with the remaining loan balance, and check how net worth changes.
From here on, this is my opinion
I think you should aim for how your net worth grows rather than for an amount of monthly cash flow. That is because the amount of cash flow can be made to look large simply by borrowing more.