BENERU
Basics and getting startedPublished

What is "I'm scared of debt" really about — the amount, the interest rate, vacancies, or my own income?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! I'm a sucker for rankings! When I picked a glasses frame that was "No. 1 in the best-seller ranking," I found 2 people at work with the same glasses that very week! They noticed too and gave me a little nod!

So, the scared-of-debt thing. Before I bought my first unit, I was terrified of the loan too. Enough that I'd wake up in the middle of the night remembering "35 years." But I'd never once tried to break down what exactly I was scared of.

That's when I found an online "ranking of stations with low vacancy rates." A second-hand unit came up at a station near the top, so I jumped at it: "That's the vacancy worry gone!" When I asked the person in charge about the interest rate, they said, "It's 1.5% variable. Even if it goes up 1%, that's about ¥8,000 a month." I nodded: "¥8,000 is fine then!" Without doing the calculation myself.

I borrowed ¥16 million over 35 years. Repayment was about ¥49,000 a month. Adding the management fee and the repair reserve fund, about ¥65,000 a month, and the rent was ¥70,000. On paper, it worked.

Then, year 2. The tenant moved out, and it took 2 months to find the next one. The ranking was the average for the whole station, not about my unit! In 2 months, about ¥130,000 went out of my salary. And in the same year, my company had bad results and my bonus went down. I'd been planning to cover short months with the bonus!

Later, I redid the calculation for what the person in charge had said. At ¥16 million over 35 years, 1.5% is about ¥49,000 a month, and 2.5% is about ¥57,000. The difference is about ¥8,200. The person in charge was right! What I didn't check was "what if it goes up more?" At 3.5% it's about ¥66,000, and the difference is over ¥17,000.

So I finally turned each fear into yen, one by one. 2 months of vacancy: about ¥130,000. The difference if the interest rate goes up 2%: about ¥210,000 a year. Both were amounts I could absorb if I set savings aside. My mistake wasn't being scared. It was letting a ranking and one remark from the person in charge erase the fear before I calculated it! What remained was the case where vacancy and a smaller bonus land in the same year. With my current savings, I can't set aside enough to cover that. So I decided not to buy a second unit yet. That was the first time I decided after looking at it in yen.

3 things I'd tell myself back then.

  • A ranking is a station's average. Work out first what you pay in the months your own unit is empty
  • When you're told "even if it goes up 1%, it's ¥X,000 a month," calculate the 2% case yourself
  • Don't count on the bonus; check whether your monthly salary alone can pay for the vacant months

These days I take my glasses off only when I look at rankings. The prescription is so strong that the No. 1 number looks the biggest!

(Updated 2026.10.18)
RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. "I'm scared of debt" isn't one feeling. It's a label on a single bag stuffed with 4 separate fears.

Debt is scary. As a general statement that's right, it's right, but. Then why do people do it even knowing that? People who say investment loans are scary put their seal on a 35-year home loan fairly casually. Even though, on amount alone, the home loan is often bigger.

The reason is simple: the home loan bag never had "vacancy" in it to begin with. You're the one living there, so it doesn't go empty. And the monthly repayment looks like a replacement for the rent you pay now. Same debt, but the bag has one less thing in it. In other words, what people are scared of isn't debt itself; it's something specific in the bag. Get it?

The short answer to the question. The 4 split into ones you can prepare for and ones you can't.

The amount, you can decide yourself before you borrow. The most reachable fear. The interest rate can be calculated. Suppose you borrow ¥20 million at 2% over 35 years: about ¥66,000 a month; at 3%, about ¥77,000. The difference is about ¥11,000 a month, about ¥130,000 a year. How many years of that difference you can hold in cash puts the size of the fear in yen, right? Vacancy's the same: if a unit with a repayment of about ¥66,000 sits empty for 3 months, that's about ¥200,000, a bit more when you add the management fee and such. You can build thickness against this with cash too.

A bit tricky? Well, hang in there. This is where it splits.

The one left, your own income. Only this one's a different breed. Vacancy and interest rates can be boxed in as "so many months' worth," but income is a 35-year story and can't be boxed in. Illness, changing jobs, your employer's circumstances. Group credit life insurance wipes out the loan mainly when you die and the like; just having your income drop doesn't stop the repayments. Even with a plan to repay from rent, if vacancy and an income drop land in the same year, what holds it up in the end is your own wallet.

Well, the income fear can be thinned out too, with cash on hand or family income. That's right too. But it only thins out; it doesn't disappear.

So, here's what to decide with. Line up the 4 and split them into fears that vanish if you stack up money, and fears that remain even if you do. If the remaining side is small, that "scared" gets settled by preparation. If the remaining side is big, that fear is probably a correct alarm, and a for-real basis for deciding not to borrow. Gritting your teeth through the fear and pushing ahead, and quitting everything because of the fear, are the same in that you're deciding without opening the bag. Am I wrong?

Write the 4 on paper, and next to each write "how many months of cash makes it vanish." The box you couldn't fill in is your real fear. Does that answer it?

Oysters, you know — looking at them in the shell, they're all equally scary, but open them and each one's meat is a different size. If you're scared of getting sick, there are moves: pick the ones for cooking, or eat them raw on a day you feel well. But some people's bodies just can't take them. Declining once you know that isn't running away. See you.

(Updated 2026.10.18)

Read a little deeper