Yeah yeah, it's Rita. It's backwards, backwards. You don't buy a property because the debt is good. Debt only puts on a good face when the property is good.
Answer first: debt itself is neither good nor bad. Debt is an amplifier. If the property earns well, it swells things in the good direction; if badly, in the bad direction — by the same multiple. That's all.
Let me show you why with numbers. All assumed numbers. A ¥20 million property, with net income after subtracting vacancy and expenses from rent of ¥1 million a year — in other words, 5% net. All cash, and it's 5% on your own money. Next, say you put in ¥2 million of own funds and borrow the remaining ¥18 million at a 2% interest rate. Interest is ¥360,000 a year. ¥1 million minus ¥360,000 is ¥640,000, which is 32% on the ¥2 million you put in. Wow, 5% becomes 32%. That's the view people call "good debt."
But what if net income drops to ¥600,000 a year (3%)? The cash buyer gets 3%. The borrower gets ¥600,000 − ¥360,000 = ¥240,000, or 12%. Still positive. Then at ¥300,000 (1.5%), the cash buyer gets away with 1.5%, while the borrower gets ¥300,000 − ¥360,000 = minus ¥60,000, minus 3% on own funds. Get it? The property's earnings only fell from 5% to 1.5%, but the borrower's number swung from 32% to minus 3%. Debt isn't judging good or bad — it's just making the swing 10 times wider.
"Well, you only subtracted interest," you say? Correct. Principal repayment goes out separately every month. Principal turns into your own equity, so it's not an expense, but it does leave your wallet. So looked at as cash in and out, it's tougher than the numbers above. A bit tricky? Add that in once with your own loan terms.
If I stopped here, my name as the sharp-tongued debugger would be ruined. I'll pick up the other side too. "All debt is bad" is also a pretty sloppy argument in its own way. If you lock ¥20 million of cash into one property, that money can't move anywhere else. For a property whose net income comfortably exceeds the interest, some people build up more by borrowing and starting early than by waiting until they've saved. In an era of rising prices, inflation works to shrink the weight of borrowed money. That's also a fact. Don't you think?
So how do you tell them apart? Not "Is this good debt?" but work out "how far does this property's net income have to fall before my own money goes negative?" In the example above, once net income drops below the ¥360,000 of interest — that is, 1.8% of the purchase price — you're into the red. How far is that line from your current net income? Far, and the amplifier is on your side; close, and it's your enemy. You know?
You know crabs? From outside the shell you can't tell how packed the meat is. So you lift it and check the weight. Debt is the same: you choose it not by the label "good" but by its weight when it's in your hand.