Yeah yeah, it's Rita. I get how you feel. Over ¥100,000 leaves your account every month, and nothing stays in your hands. Of course buying looks better. But you know, that premise that "rent just disappears" — a big part of it comes right along with you even after you buy.
Hold on a sec, let's start there. Suppose you buy a ¥60 million condominium in Tokyo with no down payment, borrowing at a 1% interest rate over 35 years. The interest you pay in the first year is roughly ¥590,000. If the management fee and repair reserve fund are ¥30,000 a month, that's ¥360,000 a year. Put fixed asset tax and city planning tax at ¥150,000 a year, and the total is ¥1.1 million a year, about ¥92,000 a month. All of this is money that leaves nothing in your hands even after you pay it. On top of that, the building gets older every year, so that loss in value comes on top. The part of rent that disappears just stays, with its name tag switched to interest, management fees, taxes and loss in value. Get it?
Well, the buyer's side has a point too. The principal part of each monthly repayment does stay as your own share. There's also the story that renting gets harder as you get older, and a retirement with no rent to pay is reassuring. That's right, it's right — but that's not "buying wins," it's "depending on how you buy, it can be a gain or a loss."
But of course, here's the real point. Where to start. Not property websites, and not how many times your annual income you can borrow. It's lining up your current rent and the "disappearing part" if you buy, on the same ruler.
Here's how. In a neighborhood you're interested in, pick one unit that's actually up for sale. Not to buy it — as material for the calculation. From that price, work out the first year's interest with your own interest rate and number of years. Add the management fee and repair reserve fund listed in the ad. For fixed asset tax, ask the broker's agent and you'll learn the annual amount. Divide the total by 12 and put it next to your current rent. If the difference is small, your reason to buy becomes "because I want to live there," not "because it pays," and that's fine. If the difference is large, only then is the case for buying backed by numbers. Does that answer it?
Also, between a house and a condominium, what's inside this "disappearing part" is different. With a house there's no management fee, but instead you fix the roof, the outer walls and the water heater all out of your own wallet. With a condominium the owners' association saves up for you, but instead you can't decide that amount on your own. Which is lighter changes with the age of the building and how much effort you want to put in. Honestly, if you look at ads for both without deciding this, you think you're comparing but you're not comparing anything. Are you missing this part?
You know pumpkins? Whole, they're heavy and you feel like you got a deal, but cut one open and there's a fair amount of seeds and pulp you don't eat. A home's price is the same — cut it open and look inside before it goes in the pot. See you.