BENERU
Basics and getting startedPublished

Is your own home an asset, or consumption?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. Here it is, the classic debate. The one where the "owning a home is an asset" camp and the "owning a home is a liability" camp keep punching each other forever.

I'll give you the answer first: both are right, and both are only looking at half. They're just looking at different sheets.

Let's sort it out once. There are two kinds of money sheets. One lines up what you own now and what you've borrowed: the BS (balance sheet). The other shows how much came in and how much went out in a year: the PL or the CF.

On the BS, your home is an asset. Sell it and it turns into cash. If there's a loan left, that amount sits opposite it as a liability. So, precisely, "the price of the home − the remaining loan balance" is the net worth you hold in your home.

On the other hand, looking at the yearly ins and outs, your home is something that takes money out of your wallet. No rent comes in. Fixed asset tax, the management fee and repair reserve fund if it's a condominium, the interest on the loan. All of it only goes out. The "owning a home is a liability" camp is looking only at this sheet. Get it? They're just grading the same house on different sheets.

Now the real point. So what should you judge by?

My way is to split the money you pay into "gone for good" and "built up."

Let's do it in numbers. All assumptions. Say you buy a ¥50 million condominium with a ¥10 million down payment and a ¥40 million loan at 1.2% interest. Interest in the first year is roughly ¥480,000, fixed asset tax and the like ¥150,000, the management fee and repair reserve fund ¥360,000. That's money gone for good that doesn't come back: ¥990,000 a year. If you think the ¥10 million down payment could have been earning 3% a year, add that opportunity cost of ¥300,000 and it's ¥1.29 million.

Rent the same unit for ¥200,000 a month and it's ¥2.4 million a year. All gone for good.

See, owning has less money gone for good. So owning wins? No, hold on a sec.

On the owning side, there are things that aren't on this sheet. The risk that the home's price falls. Lump-sum payments for major repairs. The illiquidity of not being able to sell right away when you want to. The lack of freedom: it's hard to move even when you want to. The ¥2.4 million of rent includes the fee for pushing all of that onto the landlord.

So if you fix the question, it becomes this. Not "is your own home an asset or consumption," but "in exchange for the difference in money gone for good, which risks am I taking on?"

And one more thing. I don't recommend locking in your home as "the place I'll live for the rest of my life." If you hold it as an asset, being convertible to cash at any time is the condition for being an asset. Even the special provision that lets you deduct up to ¥30 million when you sell the home you lived in has a deadline: the end of the year that contains the day 3 years after you stopped living there. Only people who keep the option of selling can treat their home as an asset.

Conclusion. Your home is an asset on the BS and a cost on the CF. Line up the numbers so you can explain it on either sheet, then decide. If someone talks to you using only one of the sheets, think about which side that person wants to sell you.

You know chestnuts — the burr outside hurts, and when you crack them open there's even the bitter inner skin. The monthly payments stab at your eyes like the burr, but the part you can eat is beyond the inner skin. Don't throw your home away after looking only at the payment sheet either; peel it all the way to the net worth sheet before you judge.

Sources (in Japanese)

Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! I really agonized over this question once too.

One weekend I went to a model home park. I just wandered in, but after I filled out a questionnaire a salesperson came over and told me, "Rent is money thrown away. If you're paying the same amount, it's better to make it your own asset." I rent a place in Koiwa for ¥90,000 a month, and when I heard that I suddenly panicked! Was I throwing ¥90,000 down the drain every month?

When I got home, I ran the numbers on the ¥40 million condominium they'd recommended. Borrowing at 1.2% interest over 35 years, the repayment is about ¥117,000 a month. On top of that, the management fee and repair reserve fund are about ¥30,000 a month, and fixed asset tax averages out to about ¥10,000 a month. That's ¥157,000 a month in total. ¥67,000 more than my current rent! ...Wait, but the size is different too, so this is a strange way to compare, right?

So I changed what I was comparing. I compared "money that doesn't come back" with "money that doesn't come back."

All ¥90,000 of rent doesn't come back. That one's easy to see.

On the owning side, of the ¥117,000 repayment, the interest in the first month is ¥40,000. The principal part becomes my own share, but the interest doesn't come back. The ¥30,000 management fee and repair reserve fund and the ¥10,000 fixed asset tax don't come back either. Added up, it's about ¥80,000 a month.

Owning a home also had about ¥80,000 a month of money that doesn't come back! It was only ¥10,000 different from rent. On top of that, the interest goes down year by year, but the repair reserve fund often goes up, and if the condominium's price falls, the value of the principal part shrinks too.

I think the phrase "money thrown away" made only the rent look like waste. It's obvious once someone says it, but at the time I didn't notice at all.

3 things I'd tell myself back then.

  • Don't compare rent with the monthly loan repayment as they are.
  • Add up the owned home's interest, management fee, repair reserve fund and fixed asset tax, and compare "money that doesn't come back" with "money that doesn't come back."
  • On a day you've panicked, don't stamp your seal on anything.

In the end, I still rent. I still don't know which is the right answer, but at least I've stopped getting down every time I pay rent. With ¥90,000, I'm properly buying a place to live!

Read a little deeper