BENERU
Choosing and buying propertyPublished

I'm happy with my current rental. Should I buy a home before construction costs rise?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. If you are happy with where you live now, there is no need to hurry to buy a home only because construction costs are soaring. Whether renting or buying is more economically advantageous depends on how long you will live there, the property's location, interest rates, and future rents and home prices. When comparing, consider not only 30 years of total rent but also the costs that arise after buying, and securing a place to live in old age. Also, rising construction costs affect the price of new homes, but movements in the prices of existing homes and in rents differ by region.

Items to compare between renting and buying

ItemRentingBuying
Monthly housing costsRent, renewal feeLoan repayment, management fee and repair reserve fund
TaxesNoneFixed asset tax and city planning tax, taxes at acquisition
RepairsIn principle borne by the landlordBorne by you
MovingEasyRequires selling or renting out
Old ageIt may become harder to rent as you get olderA place to live is secured
When letting goJust cancel the leaseIf it doesn't sell, you keep holding it

On how hard it is to let go

If real estate does not sell, you keep holding it, and taxes and management costs keep arising. Since April 2023, the "system for transferring inherited land to the national treasury," under which the state takes over inherited land subject to certain requirements, has been in place, but land with a building on it is not eligible, and an examination fee and a contribution are charged.

Order of checks

  1. Check how many more years you intend to live in your current home, and whether there are plans for changes in family makeup or workplace.
  2. Work out the total of loan repayment, management fee and repair reserve fund, and fixed asset tax if you bought a home with the same conditions.
  3. Compare it with the rent, and compare spending over the whole period you will live there.
  4. Check your options for renting in old age, and whether the home you buy could be sold in the future.

From here on, this is my opinion

I think that rather than hurrying because construction costs are soaring, you should first decide how long you will live there and your policy for housing in old age. Buying is deciding where to live and, at the same time, holding an asset that is hard to let go of.

Sources (in Japanese)

Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hi, it's Jamie! Stay renting, or buy a home? Until very recently, I was torn about this the whole time too. Every time someone said "rent is money thrown away," I'd wobble.

My rent is about ¥80,000 a month. About ¥1 million a year. Live there 30 years and it's about ¥30 million. Looking at that number, it really does start to feel like buying is the better deal.

So I actually went to see a second-hand condominium nearby and did the math. About the same size, ¥28 million. Borrowing the full amount at a 1% interest rate over a 35-year repayment, the monthly repayment is about ¥79,000. Almost the same as my rent. Up to here I thought, "Buying's better, then."

But on top of that come a management fee and repair reserve fund of about ¥30,000 a month. And fixed asset tax in the low hundreds of thousands of yen a year. The long-term repair plan said the repair reserve fund is scheduled to go up every few years. It's not like it stays at the current amount for 35 years. Adding it all up, it came out quite a bit higher than my rent every month.

The other thing I thought about was letting go. I might be transferred, and if I get married I might need a bigger place. With a rental I just move, but a home I bought has to be either sold or rented out. If it doesn't sell, the management fee and taxes keep coming even if I'm not living there.

On the other hand, I also found reasons to buy. Something I noticed watching my grandparents: apparently it can get harder to rent as you get older. Having a decided place to live in old age has value beyond just money.

In the end, I'm still renting. My current place is close to the station, and the landlord is nice. I'm not unhappy with it. But I'm no longer swayed by the phrase "rent is money thrown away." I realized that even if you buy, there's "money thrown away" in other forms: the management fee, taxes and repairs.

Instead, I decided to settle what to do about a place to live in old age by the time I'm in my 40s. Until then, I'll also save up the money for a down payment.

There are 3 things I'd like to tell myself back then.

  • Compare not just rent and loan repayment, but add in the management fee, repair reserve fund and taxes too
  • Decide first how many years you intend to live there
  • Think about housing in old age separately from money

Living in a current home you're happy with while thinking about your next move. I think that's a perfectly good choice too!

Read a little deeper