BENERU
Market and macroPublished Updated

With zero or negative interest rates, is there no benefit to investing in stocks or real estate?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. What is this — the arrow in this question is stuck in backwards. "With zero interest rates, there's no benefit to stocks or real estate"? Textbooks say pretty much the exact opposite.

Short answer to the question: there is a benefit. But it isn't "you make money." It's a comparison benefit — "better than a deposit" — and on top of that, that part is usually already in the price you pay.

First, I'll grant the general theory. When interest rates are low, money left in a deposit doesn't grow. Borrowed money is cheap, too. So people move into stocks and real estate. And when you convert future rent or dividends into today's value, the discount gets smaller, so a property with the same rent gets a higher price. Up to here, it's correct. Get it?

So why do people do it even when they know? If everyone knows low rates push prices up, the part they know is already in the price. They know they're buying at a high price, and they buy anyway. The reason is that what they're comparing against is zero. If deposits barely grow, even a property whose yield has shrunk to 3% still looks good. The yield has actually dropped, but thanks to the zero sitting next to it, it looks first-rate. Kind of a sad story.

In buri daikon terms, a low-rate era is a time when dashi is ridiculously cheap. The daikon soaks up plenty of cheap dashi and looks plump. But what it soaked up was dashi — the daikon didn't get bigger. You have to look separately at whether it's the daikon or the dashi deciding the flavor. You know?

Well, I'll poke at myself here: if you ask, "So did the people who bought during low rates lose out?" — not necessarily. People who already owned were on the side where prices went up, so they gained. People coming in new start from the raised price. Same low rates, but the benefit you get differs depending on when you got on. That's the other answer to "is there no benefit?"

And a comparison benefit shrinks when the thing you compare against changes. Once deposit rates start rising, the yield that looked first-rate next to zero suddenly starts to look ordinary. If you borrowed to buy, your repayments go up too. It's not that there's no benefit — it stretches and shrinks depending on what it's up against. Does that answer it?

Here's how to check. Put the yield of the property or stock you're considering next to the deposit rate at the time, and look only at the difference. Is that difference wide enough to survive deposit rates rising by 1%? That gives you a rough view of how much of the low rate is riding on the price. Seriously, just changing the ruler you set beside it changes the whole view. Am I wrong?

You know fragrant olive? While the scent is strong, the whole town smells nice and every street looks lovely. But after the flowers fall, what's left is just the street, and where that street really leads.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.14)
Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Young people these days think that "interest rates" means zero or negative. They've only known an era without interest, so it can't be helped, but from where I sit, that's the most worrying part.

Let me answer the question first. Even in the era of zero and negative interest rates, there was a point to putting money into stocks or real estate. Moving money that won't grow in a deposit makes sense. But more important than that: zero was not "forever," and the way it ended was not a straight line.

A bit of old history. According to the Bank of Japan's records, the policy of holding short-term rates at effectively zero began in February 1999 and was lifted once in August 2000. Then in March 2001, the very next year, it stepped into so-called quantitative easing, which targets the balance of current accounts at the Bank of Japan. A reversal less than a year after lifting. That quantitative easing was lifted in March 2006 too, but it went back to the easing side again, and in January 2016 a policy was even introduced that put an interest rate of minus 0.1% on part of the current accounts at the Bank of Japan. Negative interest rates ended in March 2024, and the framework was changed to one that encourages short-term rates to stay at around 0 to 0.1%.

Line it up, and zero came back even after it ended once, and rates fell again even after they began to rise. For about 25 years, they went back and forth in the low range.

When I showed my wife this timeline, she said, "Same as your giving up drinking. You say you've quit, then you go back." I shot back, "The Bank of Japan decides in meetings. I decide right before my evening drink. The weight is different." But she said, "If both go back, it's the same," and went off to the kitchen. Kakakaka. I had no comeback.

Back to the point. What you can read from this timeline is how hard it is to call the direction of interest rates. Anyone who moved in 2000 thinking "now rates go back to normal" would have been tripped up the next year. On the other hand, anyone who borrowed having decided zero would last forever has had to redo their calculations because of what has happened since 2024. Both bet on one direction — in that, they're the same.

Times change, but human habits don't. The habit of assuming that what's going on now will keep going. In low times you think they'll stay low; once rates start rising you think they'll keep rising.

So don't try to call the direction. Take out the contract for the money you've borrowed or plan to borrow, find the one line about when and under what rules the interest rate is reviewed, and draw a red line under it. Even if you can't call the direction, when it will hit you is written on paper.

It would be nice if a young person who has never known an era with interest and an old man who remembers the day rates went back to zero could share a drink in front of the same contract. To that drink — cheers.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.14)

Read a little deeper