BENERU
Basics and getting startedPublished Updated

I can't find any real estate with good terms right now. Are stocks or bonds better?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. You know, AI doesn't swallow a sentence whole — it cuts it into small words before reading. I'll read it that way too. "Right now," "seem to have good terms," "solid." Cut into these 3, the shape of the question changes quite a bit.

First, "seem to have good terms." The terms you saw — whose numbers are they? The gross yields lined up on property portals are numbers the selling side made look good so the property would sell. They're calculated on rent assuming full occupancy, with nothing taken off for management fees, vacancies or repairs. In other words, the better a property's terms look, the more effort may have gone into how it's presented. Flip it around: if none of them looked good, maybe it's because your ruler is doing the subtraction properly. That's not a bad thing.

Then it's only fair to turn the same eyes on stocks and bonds. Who was the first to say the word "solid"? Some of the products a sales counter or an ad recommends carry the seller's commissions or trust fees. Even with bonds, something with visible contents like government bonds and a product that just has "bond" in its name with all sorts of things mixed inside are totally different in how solid they are. If you doubted the real estate yield, you have to doubt this "solid" just as much, or you'll seriously end up grading only one side leniently.

Let's sort out the specs. With stocks and bonds, after you buy you basically do nothing yourself. In exchange, you can't touch the price movements at all. With real estate, after you buy comes the work of finding tenants, fixing things and setting the rent. In exchange, how well you do that work can change your take-home. Being able to hold more than your own money through borrowing is also on the real estate side, but that means the role of repaying out of your own wallet when units are vacant comes along with it.

So? Is that worth it? This is where the answer changes from person to person. If you're willing to spend a few hours a month dealing with a property and you value being able to change your take-home that way, real estate has room for consideration. If you'd rather spend that time on your main job or your family, holding stocks and bonds steadily is the better deal. It's not about which one is superior.

Well, let me say something about the "right now" part too. Whether the current market is high or low, I don't know. Honestly, nobody knows. Rather than deciding based on something you can't know, deciding by what you can pay with your time keeps your judgment steady even when the market moves. Am I wrong?

One way to check. Pick one property you were interested in and one product the counter called "solid," and on the same sheet of paper write out the money the selling side receives from each. For a property, the brokerage commission; for a product, the sales commission and trust fees. Line them up, and once you can see which seller's cut is bigger, and what each ad's numbers leave out, the grading is finally fair. Are you following?

You know new-crop rice? People say it's best freshly cooked. Just having "new crop" written on the bag makes the price tag bolder too. What? Even last year's rice can hold its own if you wash it properly and cook it? Oh, really. In the end, the mouth that cooked and ate it is more right than the words on the bag.

(Updated 2026.10.14)
Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Young people these days look into things a little, and if there's nothing good, they give up on it right away. I won't say that's wrong. But before giving up, did you check when your own ruler was made?

Let me tell an old story. On January 29, 2016 (Heisei 28), the Bank of Japan introduced a system that put a negative 0.1% interest rate on part of the money banks deposit with it. Deposit money and you get charged interest — in my long life I'd never heard of such a thing. In September of that year, a system was added that held down even longer-term interest rates. For borrowers, money could be borrowed cheaply. On the other hand, buying government bonds earned barely any interest. Japanese government bonds for individuals have a minimum interest rate of 0.05% a year set, but having a minimum set means it can fall that far.

People who looked into real estate in those days lined up cheap borrowing and bonds that produced almost nothing, and gazed at property yields. No wonder properties looked like they were shining.

Then on March 19, 2024 (Reiwa 6), the Bank of Japan decided to end negative interest rates and move to a framework of steering short-term interest rates. In the issue terms the Ministry of Finance published on September 2, 2026 (Reiwa 8), Japanese government bonds for individuals were 2.24% a year for the fixed 5-year type and 1.95% initially for the variable 10-year type. Both before tax, mind you. Government bonds have come back to the point of paying around 2% a year without you doing anything. When that happens, borrowing rates slowly rise too.

Let me talk about liquor here. Kaoliang liquor is a baijiu made by fermenting and distilling sorghum, and it's strong. Shaoxing wine is made from glutinous rice and aged for years to bring out its color and aroma. There's a tradition, they say, of brewing it the year a daughter is born, burying it in the ground, and digging it up on the day she marries. Either way, the core of the flavor is decided by the water and rice of the year it was brewed. It can't be changed afterward.

Now then. You felt "there are no properties with good terms right now," not because your eyes have clouded over. What you're comparing against has changed. Seen with the ruler from when bonds paid almost nothing, properties shine. Seen with today's ruler, where bonds pay around 2%, even after borrowing, putting in the effort and fretting over vacancies, the extra on top looks thin. In my view, that way of feeling makes sense.

But that doesn't mean real estate is finished either. The interest rate ruler has moved greatly twice in the last 10 years or so. It may move again. Each time the ruler moves, which side comes out ahead switches places.

Well, it won't kill you. But not being able to sleep is a problem. If you own a property, there will be days you lie awake at night thinking about vacancies and repairs. With government bonds, you can just sleep until maturity. How well you sleep is part of the yield too.

I'll recommend just one thing. Work out the take-home yield, after expenses, of a property you were interested in, and on the same sheet of paper write that month's interest rate for Japanese government bonds for individuals. How much of a difference remains — that's your wage for the effort. If you feel like working for that wage, go ahead and do real estate.

I'm a man who could empty a whole isshō bottle of shochu and still go out to the fields the next morning. Whichever you choose, it won't kill you. Staying lost without choosing is far worse for your health.

(Updated 2026.10.14)

Read a little deeper