BENERU
Repairs and buildingsPublished

The repair reserve fund for my condominium is being raised. How should an owner think about it?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. The rent doesn't go up by a single yen, and only the money going out increases. Yeah, I get being angry. I get it, but that feeling of "I lost out" — the direction of the accounting is probably backward.

I mean, the repair reserve fund isn't money that disappears once you pay it, right? It builds up in the owners' association's account and someday gets used for work on the outer walls, the roof or the pipes. It's just moving from the owner's wallet into another wallet called the building. Well, it's a wallet you can't withdraw from on your own, so I get why it looks like a loss. But it hasn't disappeared. Get it?

So here's the thing. If you think about this as a choice between "accept the increase or oppose it," you usually get it wrong. The question isn't for or against; it's "who pays for that work, and when."

The work will come eventually. What it'll be spent on and how much it'll cost are visible to some extent in the long-term repair plan. The only thing not decided is how to pay. Do today's owners pay little by little through the monthly reserve? Pay all at once as a lump sum just before the work? Or postpone the work and have the next buyer knock it off the price as a run-down building? Whichever you pick, someone pays. Making it zero was never one of the options. Am I wrong?

Say you oppose it and it's kept as it is. You save a few thousand yen a month, and the yield looks just a teeny bit better. Seriously, it only looks that way. When you sell, the buyer looks at the reserve balance and the future plan in the owners' association's documents. If they see the building is short, that amount gets knocked off the price. The money you saved tends to get paid back through the sale price.

"But you just said it doesn't disappear"? Right, there's just one exception. The money saved up belongs to the owners' association, so even if you sell your unit, the unused part doesn't come back to the person who sold. So the sooner you plan to sell, the more the increase really looks like a loss. That part is right. It's right, but in that case what decides gain or loss isn't the increase itself, it's how much the thickness of the reserve shows up in the sale price.

So the answer changes with how many more years you'll be in this building. If you hold it long, the increase is prepayment for work you'll use yourself. If you hold it short, it's a dowry for the next buyer, and the game is whether you can recover it in the sale price. If you say "it went up, I lost out" without deciding which position you're in, the accounts won't add up. Don't you think?

If you want to get your hands moving, multiply the amount the increase adds by the number of years you plan to hold. Then, from the plan's table, pick out the lump sum likely to come before the work if the fund is kept as it is, and line them up. Well? Does that add up for you?

You know matsutake mushrooms — they only show up for a moment in autumn, but the price is the price of years spent tending the mountain. From a mountain whose tending was skimped on, nothing shows its face even when autumn comes.

Sources (in Japanese)

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Tonight I'm warming some Shaoxing wine and drinking it. A jar aged 5 years costs more than one aged 3 years because the years of aging cost money. A condominium's repair reserve fund is much the same: skimp on the money you set aside, and the price jumps later. I understand being angry when you get notice of an increase. But this isn't just about your building. For the last quarter century, the same thing has been happening all over the country.

In the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's Comprehensive Condominium Survey, the repair reserve fund per unit was ¥7,378 a month in FY1999 (Heisei 11). By FY2018 (Heisei 30) it was ¥11,243, and by FY2023 (Reiwa 5), ¥13,054. In the same FY2023 (Reiwa 5) survey, 36.6% of owners' associations answered that their reserve balance was short compared with the long-term repair plan. That's more than 1 in 3.

Why did it come to this? When selling new, they want the monthly burden to look light. So many plans start low and raise it in stages later. That's what's called the stepped-increase reserve method. In April 2011 (Heisei 23), the country made guidelines on condominium repair reserve funds and showed target amounts. In September 2021 (Reiwa 3), those target amounts were revised. Even so, plans that start too cheap and jump sharply later remained. So in June 2024 (Reiwa 6), a guide was added to the guidelines: for a stepped-increase plan, the starting amount should be at least 0.6 times, and the final amount within 1.1 times, the amount you'd save if you saved evenly throughout the plan. The country said clearly that plans starting cheap and multiplying several times later aren't good.

When I crossed by ship from Manchuria to Japan, there was a man who haggled down his fare. He went into the cheap hold, the waves washed over it, and all his luggage got soaked. After we reached land, he grumbled that the lodging to dry out his things ended up costing more.

Back to the subject. When many people are afraid of an increase, opposition wins at the general meeting and the fund is kept as it is. Then at the next review, the increase is even bigger. If people are afraid of that too and put it off, then when the time for the work comes, they either collect a lump sum or postpone the work itself. That's usually what fear leads to. What's really frightening isn't this increase; it's that what built up without being raised comes all at once later.

Since the 2024 (Reiwa 6) guide was made, you can see the nature of a plan in numbers. If this increase is one to bring the plan closer to the range of 0.6 to 1.1 times, it's an increase that makes sense. If, on the other hand, even after the increase the plan still has a big jump ahead, that's something fair to question at the general meeting.

Get the table of reserve amounts in the long-term repair plan from the general meeting materials, and divide to see how many times the plan's average amount the first and last amounts each are.

Young one, being angry at money going out is a sign of good health. Put that anger straight into the division.

Read a little deeper