BENERU
Financing and interest ratesPublished

Do I really have to choose between saving cash and using credit?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. It's the other way around. It's not save or borrow. You can borrow because you've saved.

Let's first look at who's bringing up this either-or. People who say "saving doesn't grow anything, borrow and buy right now" are often on the side that gets paid when a property sells. To them, your deposits are the wallet for the down payment and acquisition costs, and the more there is, the faster things go. Then people who say "debt is evil, save it all first" seem to have no stake, but they lose nothing even if you don't buy. Both make sense from where they stand. Don't you think?

The most interesting one is what the lending side says. In screening, lenders look not only at annual income but at deposits too. Some also look at how much you'll have left in hand after buying. Why do they look? Because they want to know whether you have the strength to recover when vacancies or repairs clog up the repayments. In other words, the lenders themselves are saying that the more cash you have, the easier you are to lend to. Far from opposing it, cash is the admission ticket to credit. With me so far?

If I stopped here, I'd be a disgrace to the name of the sharp-tongued debugger.

If it's an admission ticket, should you pour all of it in? Frankly, that's the trap. I'll set everything as assumptions. Savings of ¥6 million, a ¥18 million property, acquisition costs of ¥1.2 million. A uses all ¥6 million and borrows ¥13.2 million with a down payment of ¥4.8 million. B makes the down payment ¥1.8 million, borrows ¥16.2 million, and keeps ¥3 million in hand. At 2% over 30 years, the monthly repayment is about ¥49,000 for A and about ¥60,000 for B. B pays about ¥11,000 more every month. In exchange, even if a move-out and a broken water heater come in the same month, B can pay from the ¥3 million. A is lighter every month, but has zero in hand. And if A wants to buy something next, there are no deposits to show in screening. Am I wrong?

Well, A has a point too. Being lighter every month makes A strong against long, slow pain, like rent going down little by little. That's right, it's right, but that strength assumes "a big one-time expense doesn't come." It's not about which is correct; it's about where you cut the ¥6 million. This is the slightly tricky part, and where to cut differs by person.

So before you listen to the person who brought you the either-or, ask a lender. "What share of the purchase price should I put in as own funds, and how much in deposits should remain after buying for you to consider me?" That number is the first mark on the scale for where to cut your savings. Y'know?

Ginkgo-lined streets, you know — around the time the leaves turn yellow, the nuts fall too. People who look up and enjoy the leaves and people who pick up the nuts at their feet are doing both under the same tree. There's no tree that only gives you one or the other.

(Updated 2026.10.18)
Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Kakakaka. If you think it's one or the other, save or borrow, this country's system tied the 2 together with one string long, long ago.

In 1971 (Showa 46), the Act on Promotion of Workers' Property Accumulation was made, and zaikei savings, saved by deduction straight from your pay, began. In 1977 (Showa 52), zaikei loans came along, lending money for homes and such to employees who had zaikei savings. That's how they line up in the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare's chronology. According to the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare's guidance as of October 2026 (Reiwa 8), the zaikei home ownership loan has conditions such as having kept up zaikei savings for 1 year or more with a balance of ¥500,000 or more, and you can borrow up to 10 times the balance, with a ceiling of ¥40 million, and up to 90% of the costs. The amount saved is the yardstick for the amount you can borrow, you see.

Looking at the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare's announcement of August 2001 (Heisei 13), zaikei home ownership loans to individuals were decided for 3,948 homes from April to June that year, about ¥69.2 billion. The interest rate was fixed for 5 years: 1.61% for applications received from April to June, and 1.40% from July. The Government Housing Loan Corporation, listed on the same paper, was 2.50%, and 4.00% from the 11th year. Those who had saved had made their own entrance for when they borrowed — that's how I read it.

Even with the Japan Housing Finance Agency's Flat 35, when the amount borrowed exceeds 90% of the cost of building or the purchase price, screening becomes more careful, and the interest rate is different from the case of 90% or less. The money in hand moves not just the amount you borrow, but the price of borrowing too.

My wife, you know, always bought rice and miso with cash. When I asked at the liquor shop to put a big isshōbin bottle on my tab, the old man looked not at me but at my wife's face, and silently brought out the ledger. On the way home my wife told me, "Your tab is borrowed on my purse." I had nothing to say back.

Well, enough about me.

When you get greedy, it usually goes like this. If greed for not losing puts everything in savings, the years you can borrow and the years you earn go by. If greed for growing pours everything into the down payment, even sudden needs in your life get tied to the property's circumstances. Both greeds are the same in betting everything on one side. Cash and debt aren't enemies; it's a question of where to divide — that's what I think.

One thing only I'll tell the young ones. When you open your savings passbook, draw lines in pencil into 3: a cushion for living, a cushion for the property, and the part going to the down payment. Savings you can't draw lines in aren't a foundation for anything yet.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.18)

Read a little deeper