BENERU
Basics and getting startedPublished Updated

Why does taking investing to its conclusion lead to index investing?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Tonight I'm warming Shaoxing wine. It's a 10-year bottle, but I'm not the one who waited 10 years. The brewery did the waiting for me; all I did was buy it and pour. Index investing is a bit like that.

Let me turn back the clock. Commissions for buying and selling Japanese stocks used to be fixed at the same rate at every securities company. According to the Cabinet Office's regulatory reform material, they were fully liberalized in October 1999 (Heisei 11). In the material's graph, the commission rate, which had been around 0.5%, fell to around 0.2% after liberalization. The price of buying and selling dropped visibly, and the idea of comparing prices finally reached individuals' hands.

One more. In material the Financial Services Agency compiled in July 2017 (Heisei 29), Tsumitate NISA was to start purchases from January 2018 (Heisei 30), and it put limits on eligible products. Sales commission zero, and for investment trusts linked to an index, trust fees of 0.5% a year or less for domestic ones and 0.75% or less for foreign ones, and so on. The same material says that when these criteria were applied to the top 10 funds by net assets at the end of March 2016 (Heisei 28), 8 qualified in the United States and 0 qualified in Japan. Cheap index investment trusts becoming normal in Japan is a newer story than you'd think.

So, the way I see it, ending up at index investing isn't because people suddenly got wiser. The costs became visible, they became comparable, and when people compared, the cheaper one survived. That's all.

The same thing happened at the drinking spots. At a place I used to go, there was a man who ordered a different drink every night, saying "Tonight I'll finally hit the good one." One night he looked at the bill and went pale. Every glass spent searching for the good one had its price neatly attached. So from the next week he settled on his usual 2 gō of shochu. That first night, he had the happiest-looking face in the place. Kakakaka.

Well, never mind my stories. The difference from people who try to keep winning at trading lies, I think, less in skill than in how they handle fear. When prices fall, you get scared. Because you're scared, you sell. When the price comes back after you sell, this time you're scared of missing out and buy back high. That's mostly what happens when you're scared. With each buy and sell, commissions and taxes go out, and you sell low and buy high. Those who just hold the index have simply tied themselves to a system where they don't have to do anything even when they're scared.

I'll tell young people just one thing. When you feel like selling on a day the market drops, write your reason for selling in one line on paper, sleep on it for a night, and read it again. If you can still sell for the same reason in the morning, that's judgment, not fear.

(Updated 2026.10.14)
Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! Why does taking investing to its conclusion lead to index investing? Rather than taking it to its conclusion, I'm more of someone who got there the long way around.

At first it was individual stocks. I bought stocks that were the talk of the internet and sold when they went up. The first few months went well. I seriously thought maybe I had a talent for this.

But after that, a stock I was holding dropped sharply on its earnings. I didn't want to admit the loss, so I kept holding, and it dropped further. In the end, all my gains up to then were gone.

So I wrote out every buy and sell I'd made over one year. The number of trades, the commissions, the amounts I won, the amounts I lost. I also compared it with what would have happened if I'd held an index fund linked to the whole Japanese or world stock market over the same period. The result: the index was ahead. And the time I'd have spent glued to the screen would have been zero.

The other thing that surprised me was the difference in costs. Some index funds have trust fees of around 0.1% a year. Meanwhile, many active funds, where a fund manager picks the stocks, charge 1 to 2% a year. Suppose assets grow 5% a year, and you subtract either 0.1% or 1.5% in costs: ¥1 million becomes either about ¥2.6 million or about ¥1.99 million after 20 years. That's a difference of more than ¥600,000.

So I made my NISA regular investments index funds only. I deleted the individual-stock app from my phone's home screen. I buy a fixed amount every month and don't touch it after that. Even when the market falls, the regular investment buys cheap for me automatically.

That said, I also think index investing alone doesn't solve everything. I also own a condominium unit, and that uses borrowing, with money coming in as rent. Its nature is different from an index. It's not about which is better; their roles are different.

There are 3 things I'd like to tell my past self.

  • Write out a year's worth of your own trades and compare them with an index
  • Before the yield, look at the costs you're certain to pay
  • Index investing isn't "giving up"; it's a choice to receive the average cheaply

I've decided to think of what I lost on individual stocks as good tuition. Well, it was way too expensive for tuition! Oh well, whatever!

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper