BENERU
Basics and getting startedPublished Updated

NISA looks too good to be true. Why is the government recommending it?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. And, and, and there it is. "If the government recommends it, there's a catch." The classic line that comes up every single time money is the topic.

Yeah, as a general rule that's right. The government doesn't cut taxes out of kindness alone. And the purpose is written right out in the open. The Doubling Asset-based Income Plan, decided on November 28, 2022 (Reiwa 4), says that more than half of households' ¥2,000 trillion in financial assets is held as cash and deposits with low returns, and it even lists targets to double the number of NISA accounts from 17 million to 34 million and the purchase amount from ¥28 trillion to ¥56 trillion over 5 years. Far from being a hidden catch, it's written in big letters on the signboard. Don't you think?

So why do it even knowing that? This is the government's side of the story. Tax-free means not taking tax it could have taken. The government is cutting its own share to try to change how households behave. What does it want badly enough to give up its share of taxes? For money to leave deposits and stay in the market for a long time.

You can see that in the design. NISA from 2024 (Reiwa 6) made the tax-free holding period unlimited and created a lifetime overall limit of ¥18 million. It's built so the longer you hold, the more the benefit piles up, right? Flip it around: for people who repeat short-term buying and selling, it isn't that good a deal. Get it?

So, here's the thing. Well, the government gaining doesn't mean you're losing. That's right, it's right — but the government's gain and your gain overlap only when you use it the way the government intended. Whether it's a good deal is decided not by the system but by how you use it. I think you felt it was nothing but a good deal because you were only looking at the overlapping part. Seriously, that in itself isn't a bad thing.

Earlier I made it sound like "there's no catch," but I didn't say there's nothing to watch out for. Tax-free status works when there's a profit, and the government doesn't fill in the gap when your principal shrinks. That's what isn't written on the signboard.

The way to check is to divide the money you have by "how many years you can leave it untouched." The part you can leave for a long time is the part that overlaps with what the government intended; the part you'll use soon is the part that doesn't. So? Is that worth it? If you move even the non-overlapping part based on the signboard's words, it'll end up painful. OK?

Pacific saury is piled high and sold cheap at the front of the shop because the shop wants to sell it all. That doesn't mean the buyer loses. But the one who comes out ahead is the person who grills and eats it that day, not the one who leaves it at the back of the fridge. See you.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.14)
Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! I got new glasses last week. I went with thinner frames, and somehow I look smart! I only look it, though. Before getting to why NISA is the government's recommendation, I'll tell you about the time I didn't properly hear what I was told!

It was spring 2024, the year the new NISA started. At the counter, the person in charge told me, "With the new NISA, the allowance comes back when you sell." Amazing! So I can swap things in and out easily! I got all excited by myself right there.

That year, I had used up the ¥2.4 million growth investment allowance early. In summer, out of the investment trusts I held, the part I'd bought for ¥600,000 had grown to ¥700,000, so I tried to sell it and switch to a different investment trust. Because I thought the allowance would come back right after I sold!

It didn't come back! It's written on the Financial Services Agency's NISA site too: the allowance for what you sold is restored from the following year onward. And what comes back isn't the ¥700,000 sale price but the purchase price, in other words the book value of ¥600,000. Everything the person in charge said was correct, but in my head I'd added "right away" and "at the sale price" on my own. Why did I add those, me!

I had no growth investment allowance left, and what I was switching into wasn't eligible for the tsumitate investment allowance either, so I had no choice but to buy it in a regular taxable account. It happened to go up, and when I sold part of it the next year, about 20% of the profit was taken as tax. That's an amount that wouldn't have been taken if I'd been able to buy it in NISA. It's not a big amount, but it frustrates me that I could have avoided it if I'd listened properly.

What I learned from that is that even a system the government recommends doesn't bend its detailed rules to match my assumptions. How the allowance comes back was written properly in one line on the site. The words of a recommendation are short and feel nice, but the rules you only understand by reading them yourself, line by line.

There are 3 things I'd like to tell my past self.

  • "The allowance comes back" means "it comes back from the following year onward, only by the amount of the purchase price"
  • Restate what the person in charge says in your own words and ask back, "Is that right?"
  • Before selling inside NISA, check how much of that year's allowance is left

When I told this story at home, my older sister said, "Even with new glasses, you still can't see the important part." This is no time to be impressed by how clever that was, though!

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.14)

Read a little deeper