BENERU
Management and operationPublished Updated

Will allowing pets help fill vacancies?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. When vacancies drag on, you get anxious, right? I understand wanting to cling to it when you hear that allowing pets will fill the unit. I understand, but that "will fill" — where did that number come from?

The gain or loss from allowing pets can be written roughly as one formula. The gain is: months of vacancy shortened × rent, plus extra rent × months the tenant stays, minus the additional upkeep cost when they move out.

Let's plug in numbers as an assumption. Rent ¥70,000, plus ¥3,000 a month for allowing pets. If vacancy shrinks from 3 months to 1 month, that's 2 months' worth, ¥140,000. For the extra rent, if they stay 4 years, ¥3,000 × 48 months is ¥144,000. Together, ¥284,000. If the extra cost of replacing flooring and removing odors at move-out is, say, ¥200,000, the net is plus ¥84,000. Okay? Looking at the numbers alone, not bad.

If I stopped here, I wouldn't deserve the name of sharp-tongued debugger.

The biggest term in this formula is "months of vacancy shortened." But it only shrinks when the cause of the vacancy was "not being chosen by people looking for a place they can live in with pets." If the cause is rent above market, allowing pets probably won't shorten the vacancy. Then the ¥140,000 term becomes zero, and the formula is ¥144,000 minus ¥200,000, minus ¥56,000. Same formula, but just swapping one cause flips the sign. Get it?

I mean, it can swing the other way too. In an area with few places you can live in with pets, vacancy shrinks, tenants stay longer, and the months of extra rent stretch out. That's right — there really are situations where allowing pets is a strong move. But whether you're in that situation lies outside the formula. Fiddling only with the numbers inside the formula seriously won't give you the answer.

There's one more term people tend to forget to put in the formula. The residents of the other units. If complaints come up about barking or smells and the neighbor moves out, that unit's vacancy lands in the formula too. With a condominium unit, the management bylaws may not allow pets in the first place, so reading the bylaws comes before writing the formula. Am I wrong?

So the first thing to do isn't plugging numbers into the formula; it's checking whether vacancy will really shrink. Ask the property management company for the number of inquiries in the last several months that asked "Can I live there with a pet?" If that number is close to none, the biggest term is, frankly, empty. Allowing pets is a move that only works when it hits the cause of the vacancy.

You know apples — they say you can't tell whether one has honey in the core until you cut it. So a good judge looks at the color of the bottom and the weight in the hand before putting in the knife. Cutting can wait until you've checked.

(Updated 2026.10.15)
Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. What I've got in my hand right now is Shaoxing wine, warmed lukewarm. My cat has climbed onto my lap and has been peering into my cup for a while. The question was whether a unit you can live in with dogs or cats will find a tenant. Sometimes it will. But what I want to talk about is what comes after it does.

Let me turn back the clock. In March 1998 (Heisei 10), the Ministry of Construction, as it was then, put together the "Guidelines on Disputes over Restoration." When a tenant leaves, wear from ordinary living and aging over the years is borne by the landlord, and damage from the tenant's carelessness is borne by the tenant — that was the line drawn. There were many disputes over security deposits hardly coming back at all, so the state put out a yardstick.

Even so, landlords were afraid. You never know what will get broken. So they wrote into the contract, loosely, "repairs at move-out are at the tenant's expense." But on December 16, 2005 (Heisei 17), the Supreme Court ruled that if the tenant is to bear even wear from ordinary living, the scope must be specifically written in the contract, or explained verbally and agreed to with the tenant clearly understanding it. A loosely written special clause was treated as not having been established.

In the revised edition of August 2011 (Heisei 23), the form for restoration conditions to attach to a contract clearly listed scratches on pillars and wallpaper and odors caused by a pet kept by the tenant as items borne by the tenant. It also includes an example checklist where lessor and lessee inspect the unit together at move-in and move-out and record the wear spot by spot. Then on April 1, 2020 (Reiwa 2), Article 621 of the amended Civil Code made it a provision that ordinary wear and aging over the years are not included in the tenant's restoration.

To give you my view: fear makes this roughly what happens. You think you've protected yourself by writing that everything is at the tenant's expense, and when a dispute actually comes, that paper is no use. Even though the route to saying damage from dogs and cats is at the tenant's expense is written right into the state's form.

The other day I grumbled to my wife, "Since the cat came, the scratches on the floor have increased." She asked back, "Which of those scratches were already there before the cat came?" I couldn't answer. Nobody had properly looked at the floor before it came.

Now then. If you're going to rent to someone with a dog or cat, on move-in day go around the unit together with the tenant, write down the scratches on pillars, floors and wallpaper spot by spot, attach photos, and both sign your names. On the day they leave, compare against that paper and you won't have to argue over which scratches came from the animal.

Someone who doesn't measure how much wine is in the flask before warming it won't know, after it's all drunk, who drank how much. The measuring comes before the pouring.

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper