BENERU
Management and operationPublished Updated

When a tenant moves out, how much of the restoration cost can the owner charge the tenant?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. What the owner can charge the tenant is the cost of repairing wear and damage caused by the tenant's intent or negligence, or by use beyond ordinary use. Wear from ordinary living (ordinary wear and tear) and deterioration over time (aging) are, in principle, borne by the owner. The revised Civil Code, in force from April 2020, put this rule into the text of the law (Civil Code, Article 621).

Division of costs

Organizing the approach of the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's "Troubles over Restoration and Guidelines (Second Revised Edition)" gives the following.

CategoryExamplesBorne by
Aging, ordinary wear and tearDiscoloration of wallpaper and floors from sunlight, marks from placing furniture, pushpin holesOwner
Intent or negligence, or beyond ordinary useTobacco tar stains and smell, scratches from pets, mold that spread because condensation was left alone, nail and screw holes drilled to hang heavy objects that require replacing the underlying boardTenant

How elapsed years are considered

Even when a cost is the tenant's to bear, the owner cannot necessarily charge the full cost of replacing with new. The guidelines take into account that the value of fixtures and the like falls over the years, and reduce the tenant's share.

PartApproach
Wallpaper (cloth)With a useful life of 6 years, it declines to a residual value of ¥1
Flooring (partial repair)Elapsed years are not considered
Tatami facing, fusuma paperTreated as consumables; elapsed years are not considered

Calculation example (assumption): a tenant who lived there for 4 years stained, with tobacco, wallpaper that was new when they moved in. If the cost of replacing it is ¥60,000, the tenant's share is ¥60,000 × (6 years − 4 years) ÷ 6 years = about ¥20,000.

Security deposit and special clauses

The rule is that the security deposit (shikikin) is returned after the premises are handed back, less unpaid rent and the like (Civil Code, Article 622-2). There is a Supreme Court judgment (December 16, 2005 (Heisei 17)) holding that a special clause making the tenant bear the cost of repairing ordinary wear and tear requires that the clause be clearly agreed, for example by the scope of ordinary wear and tear the tenant bears being specifically written in the contract (or explained orally and clearly recognized by the tenant).

Order of checks

  1. Record the condition of the unit at move-in and move-out with photos and a checklist.
  2. For each scratch or stain, separate whether it is ordinary wear and tear or due to the tenant's use.
  3. Calculate the tenant's share taking the years of residence into account.
  4. If there is a special clause, check whether its scope is specifically written.

From here on, this is my opinion

I think restoration costs are decided at move-in rather than at move-out. Without a record from move-in, you cannot show which damage occurred during the tenancy.

Sources (in Japanese)

Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! Restoration — at first I thought "whoever made the mess pays for all of it." I mean, it was the tenant who made the mess, right?

This was when a tenant who'd lived in my unit for 4 years moved out. I went to the move-out inspection, and the wallpaper had turned yellow from tobacco tar. I could tell from the smell the moment I walked in. Honestly, it was a bit of a shock. They seemed like a nice person, and they'd paid the rent properly through the renewal too. That was wallpaper I'd had all redone before they moved in! The estimate for replacing it was ¥60,000. I immediately thought, the tenant can pay for this. I told the property management company too: "Please charge the full amount!"

And the answer that came back was "What you can charge is about ¥20,000."

Huh, why? I asked, and they told me about the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's guidelines. The idea is that wallpaper's value falls to ¥1 over 6 years. If someone lived there 4 years, the remaining value is one third. One third of ¥60,000 is about ¥20,000. Tobacco stains are the tenant's to bear, but not all of it. When I thought about it, even if the tenant hadn't smoked, the wallpaper would have gotten fairly old after 4 years anyway. When they told me it'd be wrong to charge for that aging too, well, they had a point.

There were other things I'd planned to charge for. Dents in the floor where furniture stood, sun-faded tatami, the pushpin holes from hanging a calendar. But those all come from ordinary living, so they're mine to bear. The memo list I'd made kept getting shorter and shorter.

What troubled me most was that I had no photos from when they moved in. If the tenant said, "This scratch was there from the start," I had nothing to show otherwise.

There are three things I'd like to tell the me of back then.

  • At move-in, take photos of the unit together with the tenant and keep them
  • For things like wallpaper whose value falls with the years, put in the years of residence and calculate before you charge
  • Count scratches and sun fading from ordinary living as your own expenses from the start

By the way, on move-out day that tenant gave me some sweets and said, "Thank you for everything all this time." I took them back to my place in Koiwa and gratefully ate every last one! If I'd charged the full amount, I don't think I could have swallowed them!

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper