This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. What the owner can charge the tenant is the cost of repairing wear and damage caused by the tenant's intent or negligence, or by use beyond ordinary use. Wear from ordinary living (ordinary wear and tear) and deterioration over time (aging) are, in principle, borne by the owner. The revised Civil Code, in force from April 2020, put this rule into the text of the law (Civil Code, Article 621).
Division of costs
Organizing the approach of the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's "Troubles over Restoration and Guidelines (Second Revised Edition)" gives the following.
| Category | Examples | Borne by |
|---|---|---|
| Aging, ordinary wear and tear | Discoloration of wallpaper and floors from sunlight, marks from placing furniture, pushpin holes | Owner |
| Intent or negligence, or beyond ordinary use | Tobacco tar stains and smell, scratches from pets, mold that spread because condensation was left alone, nail and screw holes drilled to hang heavy objects that require replacing the underlying board | Tenant |
How elapsed years are considered
Even when a cost is the tenant's to bear, the owner cannot necessarily charge the full cost of replacing with new. The guidelines take into account that the value of fixtures and the like falls over the years, and reduce the tenant's share.
| Part | Approach |
|---|---|
| Wallpaper (cloth) | With a useful life of 6 years, it declines to a residual value of ¥1 |
| Flooring (partial repair) | Elapsed years are not considered |
| Tatami facing, fusuma paper | Treated as consumables; elapsed years are not considered |
Calculation example (assumption): a tenant who lived there for 4 years stained, with tobacco, wallpaper that was new when they moved in. If the cost of replacing it is ¥60,000, the tenant's share is ¥60,000 × (6 years − 4 years) ÷ 6 years = about ¥20,000.
Security deposit and special clauses
The rule is that the security deposit (shikikin) is returned after the premises are handed back, less unpaid rent and the like (Civil Code, Article 622-2). There is a Supreme Court judgment (December 16, 2005 (Heisei 17)) holding that a special clause making the tenant bear the cost of repairing ordinary wear and tear requires that the clause be clearly agreed, for example by the scope of ordinary wear and tear the tenant bears being specifically written in the contract (or explained orally and clearly recognized by the tenant).
Order of checks
- Record the condition of the unit at move-in and move-out with photos and a checklist.
- For each scratch or stain, separate whether it is ordinary wear and tear or due to the tenant's use.
- Calculate the tenant's share taking the years of residence into account.
- If there is a special clause, check whether its scope is specifically written.
From here on, this is my opinion
I think restoration costs are decided at move-in rather than at move-out. Without a record from move-in, you cannot show which damage occurred during the tenancy.
Sources (in Japanese)
- e-Gov法令検索「民法」(checked 2026-10-13)
- 国土交通省「原状回復をめぐるトラブルとガイドライン(再改訂版)」(checked 2026-10-13)
- 裁判所「平成16(受)1573 敷金返還請求事件 平成17年12月16日 第二小法廷判決」(checked 2026-10-13)